Jump to content

User:Jéské Couriano/ArbEnfCount/ArchiveGroups/250s

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Legend
Blk TBan Warn NEA Decl Acpt PLS Misc NV PE STL WD NOR
Block Topic-ban Warning Non-enforcement Declined appeal Accepted appeal Page-level sanction Misc. Moot/not a violation Procedural error Inconclusive Withdrawn Other decline reason
Archive no. Sanctions total Thread Arb case Date of last post Sanctions applied Summary Notes
251 1 block
2 topic-bans
1 warning
2 declined appeals
1 miscellaneous
1 inconclusive
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by Roscelese C&S May 01, 2019 Roscelese: Block remains in place. Decl N/A
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by Dlthewave GC May 03, 2019 User:Dlthewave/Whitewashing of firearms articles: Deletion endorsed for want of consensus to overturn Decl Appeal was against the deletion of a user subpage.
RevertBob BLP May 04, 2019 RevertBob: Block (1w) Blk N/A
Tagishsimon GG May 15, 2019 -nil- STL Discussion petered out.
Sir Joseph PIA May 14, 2019 Sir Joseph: Ban from PIA area (3mo) TBan N/A
Huldra PIA May 15, 2019 Huldra: Ban from PIA area (3mo) TBan N/A
WookieInHeat AP2 May 15, 2019 WookieInHeat: Warned to adhere to AP2 sanctions Warn WookieInHeat took a brief hiatus when the thread began, but did ultimately return. Admins declined to do more than warn, calling the hiatus "time served had a block been issued".
SashiRolls GMO May 20, 2019 SashiRolls and Tryptofish: Mutual interaction ban (indef) Misc N/A
252 1 block
2 topic-bans
1 successful appeal
2 miscellaneous
3 moot/not violations
1 procedural error
SMcCandlish ATC May 22, 2019 SMcCandlish and RoyMcCoy (filer): Mutual interaction ban (6mo) Misc N/A
BorchePetkovski EE May 24, 2019 BorchePetkovski: Ban from Macedonia topic area (indef) TBan N/A
User:Snooganssnoogans AP2 May 27, 2019 -nil- NV Edits being complained about were one contiguous revert.
SashiRolls AP2 May 28, 2019 SashiRolls: Aspersions restriction (1yr) Misc Harder sanctions were deterred by the belief amongst admins and commentators that AE was being weaponised.
Batvette AP2 May 28, 2019 Batvette: Topic-ban from post-1932 politics of the United States topic area[i] (indef) TBan N/A
Grayfell BLP, R&I May 30, 2019 -nil- PE Subject was never formally alerted to either case's contentious topics restrictions.
Volunteer Marek EE May 31, 2019 -nil- NV This thread led directly to APL.
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by Tryptofish GMO June 06, 2019 Tryptofish: Interaction ban with SashiRolls made one-way (SashiRolls from Tryptofish) Acpt N/A
Roscelese C&S June 10, 2019 Roscelese: Block (4w) Blk N/A
François Robere EE June 13, 2019 -nil- NV Dismissed as a content dispute; administrators noted that evidence here should be presented to ArbCom at APL.
253 1 block
2 topic-bans
1 warning
1 non-enforcement action
1 declined appeal
3 moot/not violations
1 procedural error
1 withdrawn
1 not acted on for other reasons
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by Roscelese C&S June 13, 2019 Roscelese: Block remains in place Decl N/A
CharlesShirley AP2 June 18, 2019 -nil- NV Dismissed as a content dispute.
WookieInHeat AP2 June 18, 2019 -nil- NV Subject self-reverted the edit in dispute.
Arglebargle79 AP2 June 21, 2019 -nil- NV Subject went on an extended wikibreak, making the thread moot.
(IPv4 address starting 63.) AP2 June 21, 2019 -nil- PE Thread was effectively a WP:AN3 report; filer was told to take it there.
Eric Corbett CE June 22, 2019 -nil- NOR Thread took place in the middle of WP:FRAMGATE, and there was little appetite for dealing with this due to that.
Marvin 2009 FLG July 02, 2019 Marvin 2009: Formally warned of FLG sanctions Warn N/A
Mehrajmir13 IP July 02, 2019 -nil- WD Filer attempted to close their own thread, which was interpreted as an attempt to withdraw.
Eric Corbett[2] GGTF July 03, 2019 Eric Corbett: Block (1mo) Blk N/A
BorchePetkovski EE July 05, 2019 BorchePetkovski: Block (indef, non-enforcement) NEA The indefinite block was issued due to their sporadic editing history and because they seemed to only be there to edit Macedonia-related pages.
Cinderella157 GWE July 05, 2019 Cinderella157: Block (5d) Blk N/A
Wumbolo AP2 July 11, 2019 Wumbolo: Ban from Andy Ngo topic area (indef) TBan N/A
JohnTopShelf AP2 July 13, 2019 JohnTopShelf: Ban from post-1932 politics of the United States topic area[i] (indef w/90d appeal moratorium) TBan N/A
254 1 block
1 topic-ban
1 successful appeal
1 moot/not a violation
1 not acted on for other reasons
Buffs AP2 July 15, 2019 Buffs: Topic-ban from post-1932 politics of the United States[i] overturned as void ab initio Acpt Ban was issued based on edits that had, at best, a very tenuous connexion to the topic area.
Wumbolo AP2 July 24, 2019 Wumbolo: Block (24h), topic-ban from post-1932 politics of the United States topic area[i] (indef) Blk, TBan The block was for removing this enforcement thread while it was being discussed.
Roscelese C&S July 24, 2019 -nil- NV Edits in dispute were one contiguous revert.
Srithikdatta AP2 Aug. 18, 2019 -nil- NOR While Srithikdatta had been warned of AP2 sanctions, the edits being complained about were performed within 15 minutes of the warning, causing several administrators responding to voice reservations.
255 1 block
2 topic-bans
2 non-enforcement actions
1 not acted on for other reasons
(1 unlisted thread not counted as a duplicate)
Eric Corbett GGTF Aug. 13, 2019 Eric Corbett: Block (72h) Blk Thread began devolving into a policy discussion about the Featured Article process.
JGabbard AP2 Aug. 21, 2019 -nil- NOR Formal sanctions considered disproportionate to the breach. (In other words, the violation was so minor/technical in nature that sanctions were considered unjustifiable.)
IronAngelAlice GG, AP2 Aug. 23, 2019 IronAngelAlice: Block (72h, non-enforcement) NEA Most of the edits complained about pre-dated the formal CTOP warnings they recieved, but given the overall behaviour one administrator opted to block as a non-enforcement action.
TimothyHorrigan AP2 Aug. 27, 2019 TimothyHorrigan: Block (1w, non-enforcement) NEA N/A
CMTBard PS Aug. 29, 2019 CMTBard: Topic-ban from autism and vaccination topic areas (indef) TBan N/A
PeterTheFourth GG, BLP Sep. 04, 2019 PeterTheFourth: Topic-ban from BLP area (6mo) TBan N/A
256 2 blocks
2 topic-bans
1 warning
1 non-enforcement action
1 successful appeal
1 page-level sanction
2 moot/not violations
1 procedural error
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by Icewhiz APL (during case) Sep. 04, 2019 -nil- NV Sanction being appealed lapsed on its own terms during the thread.
Bill Josephs PIA Sep. 04, 2019 Bill Josephs: Block (2w) Blk It was noted that Bill Josephs appeared to be a single-purpose account and any further breaches of their topic ban would be met with an indefinite block.
Benjamin M.L Peters AP2 Sep. 03, 2019 Benjamin M.L Peters: Block (indef, non-enforcement) NEA It was noted that their edits were just as problematic in other politics topic areas as they were in the AP2 area.
Icewhiz APL (during case) Sep. 08, 2019 -nil- NV Filer was requesting enforcement of an interaction ban between Icewhiz and Volunteer Marek in a discussion related to APL's proposed decision (where both editors were parties and any misconduct could be handled by the Arbitrators or their clerks).
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by Buffs PIA Sep. 11, 2019 Ibn Saud: Extended-confirmed protection lifted. Acpt Appeal was against extended-confirmed protection on a page.
Gbabuch PIA Sep. 13, 2019 Solomon's Pools: Extended-confirmed protection (indef) PLS N/A
Lsparrish PS Sep. 15, 2019 Lsparrish: Warned against edit-warring and promoting fringe views in the PS area Warn N/A
Lo meiin PIA Sep. 19, 2019 -nil- PE Edits in question, while related to PIA, weren't on a page in the topic area and even if they were Lo meiin hadn't been formally warned.
WikipediansSweep PS Sep. 19, 2019 WikipediansSweep: Topic-ban from fringe science topic area (indef) TBan N/A
TheTimesAreAChanging EE Sep. 20, 2019 TheTimesAreAChanging: Block (2mo) Blk N/A
Paul Siebert EE Sep. 28, 2019 Paul Siebert: Topic-ban from Eastern Front (World War II) topic area (3mo) TBan N/A
257 1 block
2 topic-bans
1 declined appeal
1 miscellaneous
3 moot/not violations
3 procedural errors
1 withdrawn
1 not acted on for other reasons
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by TheTimesAreAChanging EE Sep. 30, 2019 TheTimesAreAChanging: Block remains in place. Decl N/A
KHMELNYTSKYIA EE Oct. 01, 2019 KHMELNYTSKYIA: Topic-ban from Ukraine topic area (indef) TBan Case was filed under EEML; that case only had targeted hard remedies and KHMELNYTSKYIA's activity on en.wp post-dates it.
Roscelese C&S Oct. 05, 2019 Slugger O'Toole (filer): Ban from reporting Roscelese to any administrative noticeboards (indef) Misc Foot-shot; thread deemed frivolous with respect to Roscelese.
WikipediansSweep PS Oct. 06, 2019 WikipediansSweep: Block (1w) Blk N/A
François Robere EE Oct. 07, 2019 -nil- NV Dismissed as a content dispute, as the edits (and discussion where they were made) were about a Haaretz article published in the wake of APL which publicly identified some editors.
ClarinoI TRB Oct. 07, 2019 -nil- NV Subject had stopped editing a week prior to the thread's close, making the thread moot.
Greyshark09 PIA Oct. 09, 2019 -nil- PE Diffs provided were not self-evidently disruptive, and the filer did not clarify why those edits were violations.
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by Paul Siebert EE Oct. 13, 2019 Paul Siebert: Topic-ban from Eastern Front of WWII topic area remains in place due to appeal being withdrawn WD Withdrawn when it became clear the appeal would be declined.
Piznajko EE Oct. 19, 2019 Piznajko: Topic-ban from Ukraine topic-area (indef) TBan N/A
Piotrus APL Oct. 21, 2019 -nil- PE Thread filed by a newly-registered account (which would be almost immediately indefinitely blocked as a sockpuppet) and deemed frivolous with respect to Piotrus.
LD1998 AP2 Oct. 27, 2019 -nil- PE Subject had been given a handwritten alert warning instead of the mandated template warning and as such was considered to not be formally warned. The edits at issue also pre-dated the faux alert and so weren't actionable even if LD1998 had been properly warned.
Paul Siebert EE Oct. 27, 2019 -nil- NV Edits were deemed to be toeing the line, but only by technicality; they were still not related to the Eastern Front of World War II directly.
Johnrichardhall CC Nov. 05, 2019 -nil- NOR Filer was seeking sanctions over actions taken in responce to provocation.
258 1 block
1 topic-ban
1 non-enforcement action
2 miscellaneous
2 moot/not violations
2 procedural errors
1 withdrawn
SashiRolls GMO Nov. 10, 2019 SashiRolls: Ban from GMO area (indef), one-way interaction ban from Tryptofish (indef) TBan, Misc. The sanctions levied here replace those issued in Archive 251 (thread: SashiRolls).
Gas Van and sourcing requirements APL Nov. 11, 2019 -nil- NV Dismissed as a content dispute.
(IPv6 address starting 2600:) AP2 Nov. 11, 2019 List of concentration and internment camps: Semi-protection (2w, non-enforcement) NEA N/A
My very best wishes EE Nov. 12, 2019 -nil- WD Withdrawn by filer to avoid sanctions, as thread was filed in defiance of a topic ban.
WP:GMORFC GMO Nov. 15, 2019 WP:Requests for comment/Genetically modified organisms: Consensus for minor housekeeping edits achieved Misc Request was to gain consensus to make minor housekeeping edits to an RfC in the topic area per an existing discretionary sanction
Harshil169 -- Nov. 17, 2019 -nil- PE Request is a bare template except for the names of the filer and subject.
MyMoloboaccount APL Nov. 17, 2019 MyMoloboaccount: Block (1w) Blk N/A
Kazemita1 -- Nov. 18, 2019 -nil- PE Filer was seeking sanctions for breaches of a community-designated contentious topic. (Said topic would become an Arbitration CTOP in IRP.)
Actionjackson09 IP Nov. 18, 2019 -nil- NV Thread deemed to be frivolous. Filer would be blocked independent of the thread for disruptive editing.
259 1 topic-ban
1 declined appeal
2 moot/not violations
2 procedural errors
3 inconclusive
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by MyMoloboaccount APL Nov. 25, 2019 -nil- NV Sanction being appealed lapsed on its own terms during the thread.
The Rambling Man TRM Nov. 28, 2019 -nil- PE Request was seen as out of scope for Enforcement and was referred to Clarification.
Samp4ngeles AP2 Dec. 20, 2019 -nil- NV Subject self-reverted the edit in dispute.
Fifth Harmony Fanboy AP2, BLP Dec. 25, 2019 Fifth Harmony Fanboy: Ban from post-1932 politics of the United States topic area[i] (indef) TBan N/A
Edit5001 AP2 Dec. 26, 2019 -nil- STL Thread petered out due to a lack of focus; subject given informal warning.
(IPv4 address starting 98.) TRB Dec. 26, 2019 -nil- STL Thread petered out. Page at locus of dispute was protected independent of the thread.
Jweiss11 AP2 Dec. 30, 2019 -nil- STL Admins could not come to a consensus that the edits in dispute were covered by Jweiss11's Andy Ngo topic-ban.
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by EmilCioran1195 PIA Jan. 02, 2020 EmilCioran1195: Block remains in place. Decl N/A
Pali Upadhyay IP Jan. 05, 2020 -nil- PE Intended as an appeal, but does not use the standard template and is malformed. (Alternatively, something cut off the request and it was archived unactioned as is.)
260 1 block
3 topic-bans
2 warnings
1 successful appeal
1 miscellaneous
1 moot/not a violation
1 procedural error
BullRangifer AP2 Jan. 06, 2020 BullRangifer: Warned to adhere to his aspersions restriction
Rusf10 (filer): Warned against filing retaliatory noticeboard threads; ban from filing spurious reports at administrative boards (indef)
Warn x2, Misc "If Rusf10 initiates an administrative report against another user in the topic area and that report is dismissed with a result of 'no action' or 'no violation', or otherwise deemed frivolous, a 1-month topic ban from the topic area may be imposed at the discretion of any uninvolved administrator." -Johnuniq, summarising the ban while closing the thread
Here come the Suns PIA Jan. 07, 2020 Here come the Suns: Block (1mo), ban from PIA area (6mo) Blk, TBan ArbCom would indefinitely block the subject a week after the thread's initial close on Dec. 31, 2019.
Xenagoras AP2 Jan. 19, 2020 -nil- NV Sanction being enforced lapsed on its own terms during the thread.
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by Arthur Rubin GC Jan. 22, 2020 Arthur Rubin: GC topic ban replaced with a 1RR in the same area Acpt N/A
Notagainst CC Jan. 26, 2020 Notagainst: Ban from CC area (6mo) TBan N/A
Kmoksha IP Feb. 01, 2020 Kmoksha: Ban from India topic area (indef w/6mo appeal intervals) TBan N/A
Volunteer Marek EE Jan. 31, 2020 -nil- PE Thread filed by a newly-registered editor and likely sockpuppet, and so was deemed an attempt at harassment.

Footnotes

[edit]
  1. ^ a b c d e Until 2021, the AP2 area was defined as "American politics post-1932".