Jump to content

User:Jéské Couriano/ArbEnfCount/ArchiveGroups/210s

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Legend
Blk TBan Warn NEA Decl Acpt PLS Misc NV PE STL WD NOR
Block Topic-ban Warning Non-enforcement Declined appeal Accepted appeal Page-level sanction Misc. Moot/not a violation Procedural error Inconclusive Withdrawn Other decline reason
Archive no. Sanctions total Thread Arb case Date of last post Sanctions applied Summary Notes
211 1 block
1 topic-ban
1 miscellaneous
4 moot/not violations
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by Thucydides411 AP2 Feb. 25, 2017 -nil- NV Block being appealed lapsed on its own terms during thread. The underlying discretionary sanction that led to the block would also be terminated during the thread as virtually impossible to comply with.
JFG AP2 Feb. 25, 2017 -nil- NV Dismissed as a content dispute.
CatapultTalks AP2 Mar. 01, 2017 CatapultTalks: Ban from post-1932 politics of the United States topic area[i] (3mo)
Mr Ernie: Enforcement ban (indef)
TBan, Misc Two third parties used the thread to snipe at each other; responding admins would give one an indefinite enforcement ban and warn the other one that they would also receive one if they continued to treat AE as a battlefield.
Joe1w AP2 Mar. 06, 2017 -nil- NV Subject blocked as a sockpuppet independent of the enforcement thread.
The Rambling Man TRM Mar. 07, 2017 The Rambling Man: Block (1mo) Blk N/A
Volunteer Marek AP2 Mar. 08, 2017 -nil- NV Edits being complained about amounted to a single revert in totality.
212 2 blocks
1 warning
1 successful appeal
1 moot/not a violation
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by The Rambling Man TRM Mar. 13, 2017 The Rambling Man: Block reduced to 1w Acpt Thread is ~60% of the archive.
Nishidani PIA Mar. 14, 2017 Nishidani: Block (24h) Blk N/A
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by Capriaf AP2 Mar. 21, 2017 -nil- NV Block being appealed lapsed on its own terms during thread. Discussion still continued afterward, but there was no consensus that the block itself was invalid.
Oncenawhile PIA3 Mar. 22, 2017 Oncenawhile: Formally warned of PIA sanctions and their exact wording
Huldra: Block (48h)
Blk, Warn Oncenawhile self-reverted, saving themselves from a block.
213 1 block
2 topic-bans
2 warnings
2 declined appeals
2 successful appeals
1 page-level sanction
1 moot/not a violation
2 withdrawn
3 not acted on for other reasons
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by Huldra PIA3 Mar. 24, 2017 Huldra: Block lifted. Acpt N/A
TracyMcClark PIA Apr. 04, 2017 -nil- NOR Thread deemed frivolous with respect to TracyMcClark; formal sanctions against the filer were considered disproportionate.
TheBD2000 AP2 Apr. 04, 2017 -nil- WD Withdrawn after the subject self-reverted and started discussion.
238-Gdn PIA Apr. 05, 2017 238-Gdn: Formally warned to adhere to 1RR and 500/30
Yitzchak Ginsburgh: Extended-confirmed protecion (indef)
Warn, PLS N/A
Shrike PIA3 Apr. 10, 2017 -nil- WD Filer would likely have drawn sanctions if the thread had not been withdrawn, as it was deemed frivolous with respect to Shrike.
The Rambling Man TRM Apr. 10, 2017 -nil- NV Thread dismissed as an attempt to weaponise AE.
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by Vergiotisa MAC Apr. 14, 2017 Vergiotisa: Block remains in place. Decl N/A
Seraphim System PIA Apr. 17, 2017 -nil- NOR Formal sanctions considered disproportionate to the breach. (In other words, the violation was so minor/technical in nature that formal sanctions were considered unjustifiable.)
Razzieman AP2 Apr. 18, 2017 Razzieman: Block (1mo), ban from post-1932 politics of the United States topic area[i] (3mo) Blk, TBan N/A
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by Theadjuster BLP Apr. 18, 2017 Theadjuster: Block remains in place, ban from BLP area (3mo) Decl, TBan Reviewing administrators came to a consensus that a topic-ban was also warranted.
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by JFG AP2 Apr. 23, 2017 JFG: 0RR on Russian interference in the 2016 United States presidential election reduced to 72h. Acpt N/A
E.M.Gregory PIA Apr. 26, 2017 E.M.Gregory: Warned to be more careful in contentious topic areas. Warn N/A
EJustice AP2 Apr. 27, 2017 -nil- NOR Thread was crossposted to the Administrators' noticeboard as well, since the subject was a university professor using their class on Wikipedia to POV-push - a situation AE was not set up for.
214 2 blocks
3 topic-bans
1 warning
1 successful appeal
2 page-level sanctions
3 moot/not violations
1 procedural error
1 inconclusive
1 not acted on for other reasons
Mar4d IP Apr. 30, 2017 -nil- NV Dismissed as a content dispute.
Tyler Durden IP Apr. 28, 2017 -nil- NV Thread deemed to be frivolous.
Ryanfoster99 AP2 May 01, 2017 Ryanfoster99: Block (72h), ban from post-1932 politics of the United States topic area[i] (6mo) Blk, TBan N/A
Volunteer Marek EE May 01, 2017 -nil- PE Edits at issue weren't about or on articles in the EE area.
Proximity1 SAQ May 03, 2017 Proximity1: Ban from SAQ area (6mo) TBan N/A
(IPv4 address starting 81.) TRB May 05, 2017 Lisburn: Semi-protection (indef)
Royal Hillsborough: Semi-protection (indef)
PLS x2 N/A
Ihardlythinkso AP2 May 10, 2017 Ihardlythinkso: Ban from post-1932 politics of the United States topic area[i] (indef with 6mo appeal intervals) TBan N/A
SPECIFICO AP2 May 11, 2017 -nil- NOR Formal sanctions considered disproportionate to the breach.
Problematics IP May 13, 2017 -nil- NV Subject indefinitely blocked independent of the thread as a sockpuppet.
FreeatlastChitchat IP May 14, 2017 FreeatlastChitchat: Warned to adhere to their topic ban. Warn N/A
No More Mr Nice Guy PIA3 May 15, 2017 No More Mr Nice Guy: Block (72h) Blk This block would be immediately appealed; see below.
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by No More Mr Nice Guy PIA3 May 18, 2017 No More Mr Nice Guy: Block reduced to time served. Acpt N/A
Kevin McE BLP May 23, 2017 -nil- STL Administrators couldn't come to a consensus on whether sanctions were needed.
215 1 block
3 topic-bans
1 warning
1 moot/not a violation
Malerooster AP2 May 23, 2017 -nil- NV Dismissed as a content disoute.
Snooganssnoogans AP2 May 24, 2017 Snooganssnoogans: Banned from making identifal edits to multiple pages in quick succession in the post-1932 politics of the United States topic area[i] (Indef with first appeal after 1 yr and further appeals 6mo after the previous one) TBan Edits in dispute were characterised as large-scale POV-pushing by copy-pasting the same content across a swathe of articles.
Archwayh AP2 May 25, 2017 Archwayh: Ban from post-1932 politics of the United States topic area[i] (1mo) TBan N/A
Keith-264 PIA May 25, 2017 Keith-264: Block (36h) Blk N/A
JGabbard AP2 May 31, 2017 JGabbard: Ban from Seth Rich topic area (6mo) TBan N/A
Gahgeer PIA3 June 01, 2017 Gahgeer: Formally warned of PIA sanctions Warn N/A
216 3 blocks
3 topic-bans
1 declined appeal
2 successful appeals
1 page-level sanction
1 moot/not a violation
2 procedural errors
1 withdrawn
(1 unlisted thread not counted as a duplicate)
Nishidani PIA June 01, 2017 Nishidani: Ban from PIA area (1mo) TBan There was some disagreement over whether the edits by themselves rose to the level of sanctions, but given Nishidani's history in the topic area a consensus emerged for a short-term topic ban.
Archwayh AP2 June 02, 2017 Archwayh: Existing ban extended to 6mo TBan Subject was also blocked independent of the thread.
Dbrote PIA June 02, 2017 -nil- NV Thread was a request to enforce 500/30, but the edits in question were talk page posts specifically not covered by it.
DHeyward AP2 June 04, 2017 -nil- PE Edits in dispute weren't about or to articles in the post-1932 politics of the United States topic area.
Al-Andalusi PIA June 08, 2017 Al-Andalusi: Ban from PIA area (6mo) TBan N/A
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by Md iet IP June 08, 2017 Md iet: Topic-ban from Dawoodi Bohra lifted wholesale. Acpt N/A
Al-Andalusi[2] PIA June 09, 2017 Al-Andalusi: Block (1w) Blk N/A
Carter Page AP2 June 09, 2017 Carter Page: 1RR terminated. Acpt Thread was an appeal against the 1RR on the article in question.
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by Al-Andalusi PIA June 10, 2017 Al-Andalusi: Block remains in place. Decl N/A
El C PIA June 14, 2017 -nil- PE Thread was a complaint about El C's conduct while enforcing Arbitration sanctions and a (malformed) appeal of a 72h topic-ban. Both were summarily rejected - the complaint of misuse of administrator tools was out-of-scope and most admins commenting noted that a 72h topic-ban is practically a slap on the wrist.
Ryanfoster99 AP2 June 16, 2017 Ryanfoster99: Block (1w) Blk N/A
FreeatlastChitchat IP June 18, 2017 FreeatlastChitchat: Block (2w)
User:FreeatlastChitchat/sandbox: Deleted
Blk, PLS Thread was about a sandbox in the subject's userspace that contained topic-ban-violating material.
Nableezy PIA June 19, 2017 -nil- WD Thread would have been summarily rejected had it not been withdrawn, as it was seeking enforcement of a "Consensus Required" sanction that had been recinded at Clarification/Amendment.
217 2 blocks
1 topic-ban
3 warnings
1 declined appeal
1 page-level sanction
1 miscellaneous
3 moot/not violations
1 procedural error
SashiRolls AP2 June 23, 2017 SashiRolls: Block (1yr + indef) Blk (N.B.: "1yr + indef" means the sanctioned user is blocked indefinitely, with the first year as enforcement.)
Razgriz301 AP2 June 29, 2017 Razgriz301: Warned against edit-warring
Breitbart News: Extended-confirmed protection (6mo)
Warn, PLS N/A
Quadrow AP2 June 30, 2017 Quadrow: Warned/advised that contentious topic areas are the worst places to learn how to edit Wikipedia Warn There was no consensus for hard sanctions, partly because Quadrow was new and partly because there was disagreement whether the sanctions on the article were enforceable.
Snooganssnoogans AP2 July 03, 2017 -nil- NV Snooganssnoogans defended their edit as a mistake, and responding administrators advised seeking help from ARCA due to the vagueness of the "consensus required" restriction in light of this and the Quadrow thread above.
NadirAli IP July 07, 2017 NadirAli: Warned against edit-warring Warn Stronger sanctions were foreclosed by the edits in dispute being unreasonably old, almost to the point of being stale.
The Rambling Man TRM July 08, 2017 -nil- NV Thread deemed to be frivolous.
Winsocker PIA July 11, 2017 Winsocker: Extended-confirmed userright revoked, ban from PIA area (indef) TBan, Misc N/A
Volunteer Marek AP2 July 13, 2017 -nil- NV This thread involved a sanction identical to the ones in the Snooganssnoogans and Quadrow threads above.
Neuwert AP2 July 13, 2017 Neuwert: Block (48h) Blk N/A
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by User:Hyper9 IP July 14, 2017 Hyper9: Ban from history of India topic area remains in place. Decl N/A
LesVegas -- July 15, 2017 -nil- PE Filer was seeking enforcement of a community-authorised sanction.
218 1 topic-ban
3 warnings
1 non-enforcement action
1 declined appeal
3 moot/not violations
1 procedural error
1 not acted on for other reasons
1 not counted as not a request
Playalake ACU July 16, 2017 Playalake: (sockpuppet of LesVegas): Block (indef, non-enforcement) NEA After the indefinite block, Checkusers confirmed the connexion between LesVegas and Playalake, leading to an indef for the former.
Debresser PIA July 17, 2017 Debresser: Ban from PIA area (2mo) TBan This would be appealed almost immediately; see the thread below.
Arbitration enforcement action appeal with Debresser PIA July 18, 2017 Debresser: Aforementioned ban remains in place. Decl N/A
Consensus Required restriction in American Politics AP2 July 25, 2017 -nil- -- Thread is a discussion about the "Consensus Required" restriction that led to the Quadrow, Snooganssnoogans, and Volunteer Marek threads in Archive 217. While there was a consensus among responding admins to deprecate it in favour of a simpler-to-understand 1RR restriction, Enforcement was considered to be the wrong venue for this discussion, with AN or a formal RfC being seen as better locations for this discussion.
Icantevennnnn BLP July 26, 2017 Icantevennnnn: Warned against casting aspersions Warn N/A
JFG AP2, EE July 26, 2017 -nil- NV Dismissed as a content dispute and as forum-shopping as there were threads at the Incidents and Reliable Sources noticeboards about the same matter.
The Banner TRB July 29, 2017 The Banner: Formally warned of TRB sanctions
Melbguy05: Formally warned of TRB sanctions
Warn x2 N/A
MBlaze Lightning IP July 30, 2017 -nil- PE Not only were edits in question not in or about pages in the IP area, they weren't even done by the subject.
MBlaze Lightning[2] IP July 30, 2017 -nil- NOR Formal sanctions considered counter-productive as MBlaze Lightning was making efforts to stop the edit-war at the heart of the filing. One of the responding admins were also suspicious of the filer, commenting that their edit history screams "autoconfirmed sleeper sock".
Kautilya3 IP July 30, 2017 -nil- NV The sanction being invoked had been amended recently, and the edits in question were in line with the sanction's new wording.
JFG[2] AP2 Aug. 03, 2017 -nil- NV Filer was seeking sanctions for breaches of a fictitious 1RR restriction.
219 5 blocks
3 topic-bans
1 declined appeal
1 page-level sanction
2 moot/not violations
2 procedural errors
1 withdrawn
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by Debresser PIA Aug. 04, 2017 Debresser: Block and PIA ban remain in place Decl N/A
E.M.Gregory BLP Aug. 08, 2017 E.M.Gregory: Ban from living Venezuelan politicos topic area (3mo) TBan N/A
Wickey-nl PIA Aug. 09, 2017 Wickey-nl: Block (3mo) Blk N/A
Nishidani PIA Aug. 09, 2017 2000 Ramallah lynching: Full-protection (72h) PLS N/A
The Diaz AP2 Aug. 15, 2017 -nil- NV Edits in question were stale.
Twitbookspacetube AP2, BLP Aug. 15, 2017 Twitbookspacetube: Ban from biographical content in the post-1932 politics of the United States topic area[i] (3mo) TBan Rendered moot almost a week later when Twitbookspacetube was found to be a sockpuppet of a previously-sanctioned user, leading to an indefinite block.
Wuerzele GMO Aug. 18, 2017 Wuerzele: Block (1w) Blk N/A
MehrdadFR PIA Sep. 18, 2017 MehrdadFR: Block (1w), ban from PIA area (6mo) Blk, TBan N/A
Tillman CC Sep. 25, 2017 Tillman: Block (1w) Blk N/A
Resnjari MAC Sep. 27, 2017 -nil- NV Comments in dispute deemed to be snark, not incivility.
E.M.Gregory[2] PIA Sep. 27, 2017 -nil- WD Withdrawn because subject self-reverted.
Avaya1 PIA Sep. 27, 2017 -nil- PE Edits in question weren't in or about the PIA area.
Psychonot PIA Sep. 28, 2017 -nil- PE Ditto.
TheAaliyahJones AP2 Sep. 29, 2017 TheAaliyahJones: Block (48h) Blk N/A
220 2 topic-bans
1 warning
2 non-enforcement actions
1 successful appeal
1 miscellaneous
2 moot/not violations
1 procedural error
2 withdrawn
1 not acted on for other reasons
Stormwatch GG Oct. 03, 2017 Stormwatch: Formally warned of GG sanctions Warn The previous alert was too old to justify sanctions.
Angel defender PIA3 Oct. 05, 2017 Angel defender: Block (indef, non-enforcement) NEA N/A
(IPv4 address starting 2.) TRB Oct. 08, 2017 (The aforementioned IPv4): Block (2mo, non-enforcement) NEA N/A
Volunteer Marek AP2 Oct. 12, 2017 -nil- NOR Sanction being invoked was a "1RR/Consensus required" sanction, but the issuing admin explicitly stated they had no intention of enforcing the (problematic and vague) "consensus required" requirement.
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by Lexers615 -- Oct. 17, 2017 -nil- PE Sanction being appealed was unrelated to Arbitration or enforcement.
Jytdog PIA Oct. 31, 2017 -nil- WD "...I am not going to sanction someone for edit-warring when the edits in question are a decade apart, and nor is anyone else."[emphasis in original] --Iridescent, 09:39 Oct. 31, 2017 (UTC). Filer withdrew the thread shortly after.
Collect COL Nov. 06, 2017 -nil- NV Edits in dispute were removing possible biographical violations and there was no agreement the article was in the US politics topic area.
Volunteer Marek[2] AP2 Nov. 15, 2017 James J. Lambden: Ban from Donald Trump topic area (1mo)
Volunteer Marek: Ban from Donald Trump topic area (1mo)
James J. Lambden, Volunteer Marek, TheTimesAreAChanging: Mutual interaction ban (Marek vs. James + TTAAC) (3mo)
TBan x2, Misc N/A
Huldra PIA3 Nov. 16, 2017 -nil- WD Withdrawn once admins made it clear they saw it as a content dispute.
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by Volunteer Marek AP2 Nov. 17, 2017 Volunteer Marek: Mutual interaction ban between him and TTAAC lifted. Acpt Appeals were specifically against the Marek-vs-TTAAC interaction ban on the grounds it was improperly levied. As both noted, there was no discussion of whether or not the interaction ban was justified, and administrators agreed that there was no legitimate basis for the ban and it was likely to be incredibly counterproductive. Both Marek and TTAAC appealed the ban, with Marek's appeal being accepted and TTAAC's being declared moot as a consequence of the other appeal succeeding.
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by TheTimesAreAChanging AP2 Nov. 17, 2017 -nil- NV

Footnotes

[edit]
  1. ^ a b c d e f g Until January 2021, the AP2 area was defined as "American politics after 1932".