Jump to content

User:Jéské Couriano/ArbEnfCount/ArchiveGroups/220s

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Legend
Blk TBan Warn NEA Decl Acpt PLS Misc NV PE STL WD NOR
Block Topic-ban Warning Non-enforcement Declined appeal Accepted appeal Page-level sanction Misc. Moot/not a violation Procedural error Inconclusive Withdrawn Other decline reason
Archive no. Sanctions total Thread Arb case Date of last post Sanctions applied Summary Notes
221 1 block
3 topic-bans
1 warning
1 procedural error
Thucydides411 AP2 Nov. 20, 2017 Thucydides411: Ban from US-Russia relations topic area (3mo) TBan N/A
Groupuscule GMO Nov. 21, 2017 Groupuscule: Ban from GMO area (indef with 3mo appeal intervals) TBan N/A
Favonian -- Nov. 26, 2017 -nil- PE "Request" was practically a bare template and the request involved behaviour out of Enforcement's remit. Filer would end up blocked indefinitely as a sockpuppet around the time the thread was closed.
Anythingyouwant AP2 Nov. 27, 2017 Anythingyouwant: 0RR in 2017 Alabama special election topic area (1mo) TBan N/A
NadirAli IP Nov. 30, 2017 NadirAli: Warned against judging an editor's contributions based on their (perceived) nationality Warn Request was essentially for Checkuser (and thus out of scope) and was defended by the filer with nationalistic comments.
James J. Lambden AP2 Dec. 01, 2017 James J. Lambden: Block (48h) Blk N/A
222 2 blocks
1 topic-ban
1 declined appeal
2 moot/not violations
2 procedural errors
1 withdrawn
1 not acted on for other reasons
Archwayh AP2 Dec. 01, 2017 Archwayh: Block (1mo) Blk N/A
DHeyward AP2, BLP Dec. 02, 2017 DHeyward: Ban from living/recently departed people active in American politics from 1932 onward[i] (1mo) TBan N/A
Nick.8.payne WE Dec. 05, 2017 -nil- NV Dismissed as a content dispute.
Atsme AP2, BLP Dec. 05, 2017 -nil- NOR Formal sanctions considered to be disproportionate to the breach. (In other words, the violation was so minor/technical in nature that formal sanctions were considered unjustifiable.)
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by Kingsindian AP2 Dec. 05, 2017 -nil- PE Appeal was against the wording on the AP2 sanctions template, and more specifically the persistently-problematic-to-enforce "consensus required" sanction. As part of this, Kingsindian proposed an alternative wording that was easier to understand. Commenting admins noted the proper place to wordsmith the template is that template's talk page, not Enforcement.
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by DHeyward AP2 Dec. 06, 2017 DHeyward: Ban from post-1932 American political biographies remains in place. Decl Declined in part because another appeal against the same sanction was on the administrators' noticeboard.
Vyacheslav84 -- Dec. 07, 2017 -nil- PE Thread was an attempt to relitigate a deletion debate that had already been endorsed at deletion review; the article wasn't in any known Arbitration-endorsed contentious topic.
Dank Chicken PIA3 Dec. 09, 2017 Dank Chicken: Block (1w) Blk N/A
DHeyward[2] AP2 Dec. 09, 2017 -nil- WD Withdrawn because the sanction had been poorly wordsmithed, leading to confusion on how to enforce it between the filer/original sanctioning admin and commenting users.
Seraphim System PIA3 Dec. 14, 2017 -nil- NV An informal warning was given, but the edit at issue was not considered to be a violation.
223 1 block
2 topic-bans
1 declined appeal
1 successful appeal
4 moot/not violations
1 withdrawn
Block appeal from (IPv4 starting 68.) AP2 Dec. 21, 2017 (The aforementioned IPv4): Block lifted Acpt N/A
MickPhil AP2 Dec. 27, 2017 -nil- WD None of the prerequisite steps had been carried out - user was not forewarned, no actual remedy had been invoked - and administrators pointed out it was a content dispute. The thread was withdrawn due to a discussion on the matter at ARCA.
Nishidani PIA Jan. 04, 2018 -nil- NV Thread deemed to be frivolous.
ScratchMarshall AP2 Jan. 04, 2018 -nil- NV Filer was seeking to enforce a "consensus required" restriction against talk page posts, which administrators noted is not how that sanction works. Administrators also heavily criticised the filer for their opinion on how much detail should be in the article, noting it had been rejected at the talk page ad nauseam.
KA$HMIR IP Jan. 04, 2018 KA$HMIR: Block (1w) Blk User was blocked in part due to reverting material as alleged copyright violations, but providing no evidence to back up this claim.
DHeyward AP2 Jan. 04, 2018 DHeyward: Ban from post-1932 politics of the United States topic area[i] (1mo) TBan N/A
MONGO AP2 Jan. 05, 2018 MONGO: Ban from post-1932 politics of the United States topic area[i] (3mo) TBan N/A
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by Rod (User:Dailey78) AnEg Jan. 05, 2018 Dailey78: Ban remains in place. Decl As before, ban appeal was declined as Dailey78 had hardly edited Wikipedia since the previous appeal.
The Rambling Man TRM Jan. 05, 2018 -nil- NV The Rambling Man struck/redacted the comment that led to this thread.
Volunteer Marek AP2 Jan. 10, 2018 -nil- NV Volunteer Marek almost talked themselves into a block, as the edits in controversy were deemed to be one contiguous revert.
224 2 blocks
3 topic-bans
1 warning
1 non-enforcement action
2 declined appeals
3 moot/not violations
1 not acted on for other reasons
(1 unlisted thread not counted as not a request)
DHeyward AP2 Jan. 12, 2018 -nil- NV Thread rendered moot by a successful appeal of DHeyward's sanction for being too vague to enforce.
Anmolbhat IP Jan. 12, 2018 -nil- NV Anmolbhat self-reverted the edit at the locus of this thread.
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by Raymond3023 IP Jan. 13, 2018 Raymond3023: Ban from IP area replaced with a suite of somewhat stringent restrictions: 1RR in area, cannot remove "Created by blocked/banned user" speedy tags, all content additions require sources, all edits challenged for poor sourcing must be defended, no source fraud. Duration remains 3 months from original sanction. TBan, Decl Rather than outright lift the ban, as requested, administrators instead changed it to one centred around sourcing due to the issues that led to the topic ban.
Anmolbhat[2] IP Jan. 14, 2018 -nil- NV Administrator who issued the sanction being invoked rescinded the civility restriction on it as too vague, making the thread moot.
Al-Andalus AP2 Jan. 17, 2018 Al-Andalus: Block (1w) Blk "Consensus Required" sanction invoked.
Sir Joseph AP2, BLP Jan. 19, 2018 -nil- NOR Formal sanctions considered disproportionate to the breach.
Greggens AP2 Jan. 19, 2018 Greggens: Ban from Elizabeth Warren topic area (6mo), ban from post-1932 politics of the United States topic area[i] (1mo) TBan x2 N/A
KU2018 AP2 Jan. 20, 2018 KU2018 (sockpuppet of Oscar248): Block (indef, non-enforcement) NEA N/A
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by Greggens AP2 Jan. 21, 2018 Greggens: Both aforementioned topic-bans remain in place. Decl Greggens was also forum-shopping both to get his bans removed and the administrator that levied them sanctioned. A few administrators proposed extending the bans on the grounds they were very lenient.
Ihardlythinkso AP2 Jan. 22, 2018 Ihardlythinkso: Block (1w) Blk N/A
Doncram DC Jan. 22, 2018 Doncram: Warned against making personal attacks and casting aspersions Warn There was little appetite for harder sanctions due to ArbCom suspending his interaction ban with SarekofVulcan, with some stating that any discussion of a new interaction ban should be taken to ARCA.
225 3 blocks
2 topic-bans
2 declined appeals</bnr>2 successful appeals
1 moot/not a violation
1 not acted on for other reasons
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by Avisnacks AP2 Jan. 23, 2018 Avisnacks: Block length reduced to 24h Acpt N/A
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by Anythingyouwant AP2 Jan. 23, 2018 Anythingyouwant: Topic-ban from Donald Trump area extended to 1mo Decl, TBan Prior to this appeal, the topic-ban in question had been reduced to 1w. The reset to its original duration was due to Anythingyouwant's attempts to game it.
The Rambling Man TRM Jan. 25, 2018 -nil- NV The edit that sparked the thread was criticism of the Arbitration Committee for in camera deliberations involving an administrator, and thus not a breach of his civility restriction.
Debresser PIA Jan. 25, 2018 Debresser: Block (2w) Blk N/A
Racassidy54 GMO Jan. 27, 2018 Racassidy54: Ban from chlordane topic area (indef) TBan N/A
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by Debresser PIA Jan. 27, 2018 Debresser: Block remains in place. Decl N/A
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by Signedzzz AP2 Jan. 29, 2018 Signedzzz: Probation lifted. Acpt The sanction issued was deemed to be ill defined (or not defined at all), which would have made enforcing it needlessly difficult and combative.
Doc9871 AP2 Jan. 30, 2018 Doc9871: Block (indef)
Ihardlythinkso: Block (2w + indef)
Blk x2 Doc's block was logged as enforcement, and was made due to Checkuser-confirmed block evasion via IP. Ihardlythinkso, meanwhile, was blocked for repeatedly posting a (link to the) list of opposes from GoldenRing's (one of the enforcing administrators) Request for Adminship, in what was described as a "suicide by admin" incident.
EEng AP2 Feb. 02, 2018 -nil- NOR The thread quickly became an examination of the filer's actions in the topic area as they were an administrator who was issuing sanctions despite their involvement in the topic area. The thread was more-or-less seen as lacking in terms of an explanation of how EEng breached his sanctions, and the filer opted to go on wikibreak rather than be scrutinised further.
226 2 blocks
3 topic-bans
2 declined appeals
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by TheTimesAreAChanging AP2 Feb. 03, 2018 TheTimesAreAChanging: Probation in post-1932 American politics[i] area remains in place. Decl There was some debate amongst admins in the thread as to whether or not probation should even be a usable remedy given the risk of confusion and the obscurity of it at this time.
Richard Arthur Norton (1958- ) RAN Feb. 06, 2018 Richard Arthur Norton (1958- ): Block (1mo) Blk N/A
TheTimesAreAChanging AP2 Feb. 07, 2018 TheTimesAreAChanging: Probation replaced by a hard topic-ban from the post-1932 American politics[i] topic area (indef with 6mo appeal intervals) TBan N/A
TripWire IP Feb. 13, 2018 TripWire: Block (48h) Blk N/A
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by Bachcell BLP Feb. 15, 2018 Bachcell: Block remains in place and reset of 3mo topic-ban from BLP edits as regards terrorism stands. Decl N/A
Hyper9 IP Feb. 26, 2018 Hyper9: Ban from Indian history and languages of India topic areas (indef with 6mo appeal intervals)
Nagadeepa (filer): Ban from languages of India topic area (indef with 6mo appeal intervals)
TBan x2 N/A
227 1 topic-ban
2 non-enforcement actions
1 declined appeal
1 moot/not a violation
2 not acted on for other reasons
MapSGV IP Mar. 01, 2018 MapSGV: Block (indef, non-enforcement) NEA MapSGV would be unblocked a day later after a successful block appeal.
The Rambling Man TRM Mar. 02, 2018 -nil- NV Thread deemed to be an attempt to weaponise AE.
Al-Andalusi PIA Mar. 04, 2018 Al-Andalusi: 1 edit/day per page in PIA area (6mo) TBan N/A
Mar4d IP Mar. 07, 2018 -nil- NOR "This entire report has become a wall of minutia, none of it actionable by itself, and frankly I'm left with the choice of doing nothing, or topic banning everyone who was foolish enough to participate in this mud slinging mess. ... Dismissing everything without action." --Dennis Brown, closing thread.
Born2cycle ATC Mar. 08, 2018 Born2cycle: Block (indef, non-enforcement) NEA N/A
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by ScratchMarshall BLP Mar. 08, 2018 ScratchMarshall: Ban from BLP area remains in place. Decl ScratchMarshall had also been blocked independent of the thread for forum-shopping and borderline harassment of another editor. An Incidents noticeboard thread was also used as evidence to decline the appeal.
Willard84 IP Mar. 08, 2018 -nil- NOR Thread closed without action to kerb partisan fighting.
228 1 block
1 warning
1 declined appeal
1 procedural error
1 withdrawn
Andrew Davidson IP Mar. 20, 2018 -nil- PE While subject was given an informal warning, the report itself lacked diffs and so couldn't be acted on.
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by B01010100 EE Mar. 22, 2018 B01010100: 1yr-Arbitration privilege stripped from indefinite block and talk page revoked Decl Appeal was against the block as out-of-process; the blocking admin instead revoked his talk page and converted the block to a standard administrative block (from a 1yr + indef AE block) as the account had only ever been disruptive.
Petitic AP2 Mar. 23, 2018 -nil- WD Filer withdrew since subject was not aware of AP2 sanctions.
Thewolfchild GC Mar. 25, 2018 Thewolfchild: Warned to stop casting aspersions and filibustering discussions Warn N/A
Zbrnajsem AP2 Mar. 30, 2018 Zbrnajsem: Block (72h) Blk N/A
229 2 blocks
1 topic-ban
1 warning
1 non-enforcement action
1 declined appeal
1 successful appeal
3 moot/not violations
1 not acted on for other reasons
Captain Occam R&I Apr. 04, 2018 Captain Occam: Block (indef w/email revoked, non-enforcement) NEA Filer was complaining about Occam's email use; while there was agreement this was out of scope for enforcement this was a break of unblock conditions Occam agreed to, leading to a standard indefinite block with email access revoked.
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by Roxy the dog IP Apr. 05, 2018 Roxy the dog: Block lifted. Acpt Block was deemed to be out-of-process.
Nishidani PIA Apr. 06, 2018 -nil- NV Dismissed as essentially a heated, but still manageable, ideological discussion.
R9tgokunks PIA Apr. 08, 2018 R9tgokunks: Formally warned of PIA sanctions Warn N/A
VendixDM PIA3 Apr. 08, 2018 VendixDM: Block (72h) Blk Blocked without further comment from any other party.
Neilen AP2 Apr. 09, 2018 Neilen: Ban from post-1932 American politics topic area[i] (indef) TBan N/A
Niteshift36 GC Apr. 09, 2018 -nil- NV Thread deemed to be frivolous.
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by iantresman PS Apr. 13, 2018 Iantresman: Ban from astrophysics and plasma physics topic areas remain in place. Decl N/A
Dagduba lokhande IP Apr. 16, 2018 Dagduba lokhande: Block (1w) Blk N/A
Scjessey AP2 Apr. 18, 2018 -nil- NOR Formal sanctions considered to be disproportionate to the breach.
Js82 IP Apr. 18, 2018 -nil- NV Subject blocked as a sockpuppet independent of the thread.
230 3 blocks
4 topic-bans
1 warning
1 non-enforcement action
1 declined appeal
1 moot/not a violation
No More Mr Nice Guy PIA Apr. 21, 2018 No More Mr Nice Guy: Block (1w) Blk N/A
Anythingyouwant AP2 Apr. 23, 2018 Anythingyouwant: Ban from post-1932 American politics topic area[i] (indef w/ 6mo appeal intervals) TBan A three-month topic ban from the Donald Trump topic area had been considered, but after finding signs that Anythingyouwant would just "wait out" any ban and go right back to his previous behaviour NeilN implemented an indefinite US politics topic-ban instead.
A. Katechis Mpourtoulis MAC Apr. 24, 2018 A. Katechis Mpourtoulis: Ban from Balkans topic area (indef) TBan N/A
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by No More Mr Nice Guy PIA Apr. 26, 2018 No More Mr Nice Guy: Block remains in place. Decl N/A
ApolloCarmb PIA3 Apr. 26, 2018 ApolloCarmb: Formally warned of PIA sanctions Warn N/A
GizzyCatBella EE Apr. 26, 2018 GizzyCatBella: Block (72h) Blk N/A
AmYisroelChai AP2 Apr. 26, 2018 AmYisroelChai: Ban from Donald Trump and Russian influence in 2016 American elections topic areas (1mo) TBan N/A
Phmoreno AP2 Apr. 29, 2018 Phmoreno: Block (72h) Blk Summarily blocked with no further admin input.
K.e.coffman AP2 Apr. 30, 2018 -nil- NV "Consensus required" thread. Responding administrators concluded K.e.coffman acted in good faith to enact what appeared to him to be a valid consensus.
The Banner GMO Apr. 30, 2018 The Banner: Ban from GMO area (indef w/6mo appeal intervals) TBan N/A
Andrewpostman93 BLP May 01, 2018 Andrewpostman93: Block (indef, non-enforcement) NEA N/A

Footnotes

[edit]
  1. ^ a b c d e f g h Until January 2021, the AP2 area was defined as "Post-1932 politics of the United States"