Jump to content

User:Jéské Couriano/ArbEnfCount/ArchiveGroups/190s

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Legend
Blk TBan Warn NEA Decl Acpt PLS Misc NV PE STL WD NOR
Block Topic-ban Warning Non-enforcement Declined appeal Accepted appeal Page-level sanction Misc. Moot/not a violation Procedural error Inconclusive Withdrawn Other decline reason
Archive no. Sanctions total Thread Arb case Date of last post Sanctions applied Summary Notes
191 3 blocks
5 topic-bans
1 warning
1 declined appeal
2 moot/not violations
(2 unlisted threads not counted as duplicates)
TeeVeeed PS Apr. 22, 2016 TeeVeeed: Ban from vaccination topic-area (indef) TBan N/A
STSC FG2 Apr. 27, 2016 STSC: Ban from FLG area (indef) TBan N/A
MjolnirPants PS Apr. 27, 2016 -nil- NV Thread deemed to be frivolous.
SailorHaumea LGV Apr. 29, 2016 Sailor Haumea: Ban from LGV area (indef) TBan "[...T]here are telltale signs that [Sailor Haumea] appears to be misusing multiple accounts. I will deal with that separately, acting as an individual administrator outside AE action." Zad68, closing the thread
Wikiwillkane PIA3 Apr. 30, 2016 Wikiwillkane: Warned to adhere to the 500/30 restriction Warn N/A
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by STSC FG2 May 02, 2016 STSC: Ban from FLG area remains in place. Decl N/A
Jonniefood TRB May 03, 2016 Jonniefood: Ban from The Troubles and Ulster Banner topic-areas (90d) TBan User was noted to be newer, which was a mitigating factor.
AmirSurfLera PIA May 07, 2016 AmirSurfLera: Block (3mo) Blk N/A
HughD AP2, CC, TPM May 08, 2016 HughD: Existing ban extended to indefinite and expanded to cover the entire CC area and post-1932 American politics[i], block (1mo) Blk, TBan HughD's defence was largely to pettifog around what was and was not covered by his existing topic ban, leading admins to cut the knot and topic-ban him from both the CC area and the (at the time) AP2 area.
MarkBernstein GG May 15, 2016 -nil- NV Subject blocked independent of the thread for breaching an unrelated sanction
192 3 topic-bans
2 warnings
1 successful appeal
2 moot/not violations
1 inconclusive
1 withdrawn
1 not acted on for other reasons
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by HughD TPM May 12, 2016 -nil- NV The result of "HughD" in Archive 191 made this appeal moot.
FreeatlastChitchat IP May 17, 2016 FreeatlastChitchat: Ban from IP area and Bangladesh topic-area (indef) TBan N/A
ArghyaIndian IP May 17, 2016 -nil- NOR Thread closed without action to kerb partisan fighting
Gala19000 AA2 May 18, 2016 Gala19000: Ban from Armenia and Turkish conflicts topic-areas (indef) TBan N/A
Abbatai AA2 May 19, 2016 Abbatai: Ban from AA2 area (30d) TBan N/A
AE sanction appeal regarding a 3 way topic ban between MarkBernstein, Thargor Orlando, and DHeyward GG May 19, 2016 MarkBernstein, Thargor Orlando, and DHeyward: Three-way mutual interaction ban lifted. Acpt Appeal filed by DHeyward; MarkBernstein was (at the time the thread closed) blocked. It was noted that there was never any conflict between Thargor and DHeyward, but both had had consistent problems with MarkBernstein, and the uneven way the sanction was handled was another strike against it.
Miles Creagh TRB May 20, 2016 -nil- NV Subject self-reverted the edits in dispute.
TripWire IP May 20, 2016 -nil- WD Filer withdrew the thread as it became obvious admins were considering sanctioning them for filing a frivolous AE request.
Tiptoethrutheminefield AA2 May 22, 2016 Tiptoethrutheminefield: Warned to remain civil
Volunteer Marek (filer): Warned to remain civil
Warn x2 N/A
Interfase AA2 May 25, 2016 -nil- STL No administrators participated in the thread.
193 2 blocks
1 topic-ban
2 warnings
1 non-enforcement action
1 page-level sanction
3 moot/not violations
2 procedural errors
Prioryman SCI May 26, 2016 -nil- NV Thread deemed to be frivolous
Oatitonimly AA2 May 28, 2016 Gala19000 (filer): Block (1yr) Blk Foot-shot; summarily closed as being filed in defiance of a topic-ban.
Volunteer Marek EE May 29, 2016 -nil- NV Thread deemed to be frivolous. Filer would be indefinitely blocked for sockpuppetry independent of the thread.
Tanbircdq PIA3 May 30, 2016 Tanbircdq: Block (indef, non-enforcement) NEA Subject blocked based on SPI results that determined he had been bypassing his sanctions while logged-out.
Sfarney SCI May 31, 2016 Sfarney: Ban from SCI area (1yr) TBan N/A
Galassi EE June 13, 2016 Galassi: Warned to adhere to his topic-ban Warn N/A
OptimusView AA2 June 13, 2016 -nil- NV Subject indefinitely blocked for sockpuppetry independent of the thread.
Jake vela GS/SCW June 13, 2016 -nil- PE Filer was seeking sanctions for breaches in a community-designated contentious topic.
Rms125a@hotmail.com TRB June 23, 2016 DanceHallCrasher: Formally warned of TRB sanctions Warn Thread otherwise rendered moot due to the dispute resolving amicably/going stale.
HughD CC June 28, 2016 HughD: Block (6mo) Blk "[HughD] committed 5 new violations while the previous violations were actively being discussed here, showing no intent to comply with the existing restriction." --The Wordsmith, closing thread
Debresser PIA July 04, 2016 Jerusalem: Requests for Comment required for any changes to article lede PLS This sanction was issued because of edit-warring over the article's lede in spite of a previous RfC on the exact same section.
Aaabbb11 FG2 July 05, 2016 -nil- PE Closed due to being filed in defiance of a topic-ban.
194 2 blocks
2 topic-bans
1 miscellaneous
3 moot/not violations
(1 unlisted thread not counted as a duplicate)
Monochrome Monitor PIA July 06, 2016 Monochrome Monitor: Ban from IPA area and Jews topic area (2mo), mentorship TBan, Misc. All sanctions were voluntarily offered by Monochrome Monitor and accepted.
Wuerzele GMO July 07, 2016 -nil- NV Subject went on extended hiatus, making the request moot.
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by Ranze GG July 15, 2016 -nil- NV Sanction in question had lapsed well before these threads were filed. This was because the sanctioning administrator, who'd intended the topic-ban to be indefinite, logged it instead as a yearlong topic-ban which expired April 2016 on its own terms.
Ranze GG July 15, 2016 -nil- NV
Khazen48 PIA3 July 19, 2016 Khazen48: Block (2w) Blk "The block can be lifted by any admin if they respond and agree to follow the 500/30 rule." --EdJohnston, announcing the block.
Sepsis II PIA3 July 21, 2016 Sepsis II: Ban from PIA area (indef) TBan N/A
SageRad GMO July 22, 2016 SageRad: Block (5d) Blk N/A
195 3 topic-bans
3 warnings
1 miscellaneous
1 procedural error
1 withdrawn
Neutrality AP2 July 23, 2016 -nil- PE Filed by an unregistered user. Thread was also deemed to be frivolous even if it had been filed by a named account.
TH1980 C&H July 25, 2016 -nil- WD N/A
Herr Gruber GC July 27, 2016 Herr Gruber: Formally warned of GC sanctions
Felsic2 (filer): Formally warned of GC sanctions
Warn x2 N/A
Debresser PIA July 27, 2016 Debresser: Ban from PIA area (3mo) TBan N/A
David Tornheim GMO July 28, 2016 David Tornheim: Ban from GMO area (indef)
EllenCT: Ban from GMO area (indef), aspersions restriction (indef)
Jusdafax: Warned against making frivolous or unfounded accusations
TBan x2, Warn, Misc. Thread was held in abeyance for a short time for a last-ditch appeal to ArbCom which failed.
(N.B.: An aspersions restriction means the sanctioned user may be summarily blocked if they make a comment that can be seen as casting aspersions on another editor without good cause.)
196 2 blocks
3 topic-bans
4 miscellaneous
TripWire IP July 29, 2016 TripWire: Ban from Balochistan topic-area (3mo), aspersions retriction (indef)
Kautilya3 (filer): Aspersions restriction (indef)
Editors in the IP area, writ large: Aspersions restriction (indef)
Unregistered editors in IP area, writ large: Aspersions restriction with regards to accusations of sockpuppetry (indef)
TBan, Misc x4 N/A
HappyWaldo AP2 July 31, 2016 HappyWaldo: Block (72h) Blk N/A
Doc9871 AP2 Aug. 02, 2016 Doc9871: Ban from pages in the Donald Trump topic-area (1mo) TBan N/A
(IPv4 address starting 62.) PIA3 Aug. 04, 2016 (The aforementioned IPv4): Block (72h) Blk The request was explicitly to enforce the extended-confirmed restriction.
Malik Shabazz PIA Aug. 13, 2016 Kamel Tebaast (filer): Ban from PIA area (1mo) TBan Foot-shot; thread deemed frivolous with respect to Malik Shabazz.
197 2 blocks
1 topic-ban
1 warning
1 moot/not a violation
Volunteer Marek and My very best wishes EE, AP2, PIA Aug. 15, 2016 -nil- NV Filer was accusing Volunteer Marek and My very best wishes of tag-team edit-warring, providing a (now-deleted) subpage of evidence to this end; the evidence was deemed to be unconvincing by most admins who read it (save Coffee), with one commenting that they'd need to see off-wiki evidence of intentional collaboration to make the case.
AmirSurfLera PIA Aug. 15, 2016 AmirSurfLera: Block (6mo) Blk N/A
JGabbard AP2 Aug. 27, 2016 JGabbard: Ban from post-1932 American politics topic-area[i] (6mo) TBan N/A
D.Creish AP2 Aug. 30, 2016 D.Creish: Warned against edit-warring Warn N/A
(IPv4 address starting 75.) BLP Aug. 31, 2016 (The aforementioned IPv4): Block (72h) Blk N/A
198 2 topic-bans
2 warnings
2 declined appeals
1 successful appeal
4 moot/not violations
1 not acted on for other reasons
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by No More Mr Nice Guy PIA Sep. 03, 2016 No More Mr Nice Guy: Enforcement ban in re PIA lifted. Acpt N/A
SashiRolls GMO, AP2 Sep. 03, 2016 SashiRolls: Ban from Jill Stein topic area (6mo) TBan The sanction was seen more as an AP2 one, with the GMO-related issues as an aggravating factor.
Orasis PIA Sep. 06, 2016 Orasis: Ban from PIA area (6mo) TBan "I will not appeal shit, I will change my IP. The fact that only the Israeli view is allowed here is apparent. I will return, eat shit." --Orasis, "defending" themself. They would be indefinitely blocked three weeks later for flagrant disregard of their topic-ban.
Sahrin GC Sep. 07, 2016 Sahrin: Warned against personal attacks. Warn N/A
Volunteer Marek AP2 Sep. 10, 2016 -nil- NV Thread deemed to be frivolous
Philip Cross PIA Sep. 11, 2016 -nil- NOR Formal sanctions considered disproportionate to the breach. (In other words, the violation was so minor/technical in nature that formal sanctions were considered unjustifiable.)
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by SashiRolls AP2 Sep. 12, 2016 SashiRolls: Ban from Jill Stein topic area remains in place. Decl SashiRolls' initial argument was a massive wall of text. When cut down at administrator request, the arguments were deemed to be an attempt to use AE to relitigate the underlying content dispute.
Makeandtoss PIA3 Sep. 13, 2016 Makeandtoss: Warned to stay away from the PIA area unless they're looking to commit suicide-by-administrator. Warn N/A
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by Kamel Tebaast PIA Sep. 14, 2016 -nil- NV Sanction being appealed lapsed on its own terms during the thread.
Bolter21 PIA Sep. 17, 2016 -nil- NV Subject self-reverted, and beyond that the thread was deemed an attempt to weaponise AE.
Monochrome Monitor PIA3 Sep. 17, 2016 -nil- NV Dismissed as a content dispute.
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by MarkBernstein GG Sep. 18, 2016 MarkBernstein: Block remains in place. Decl There was no consensus amongst responding admins to overturn the block.
199 1 block
2 topic-bans
1 warning
1 miscellaneous
Sanctions clarification request: 2016 US Election AE AP2 Sep. 19, 2016 Template:American politics AE: Edited to remove one word. Misc Thread was asking for a clarification on how sanctions should be applied.
Tiny Dancer 48 R&I Sep. 20, 2016 Tiny Dancer 48: Ban from R&I area (indef w/6mo appeal intervals) TBan N/A
Volunteer Marek AP2 Sep. 24, 2016 CFredkin (filer): Ban from post-1932 American politics topic area[i] (3mo) TBan Foot-shot; CFredkin was attempting to game the old wording of Template:American politics AE (see "Sanctions clarification requesr: 2016 US Election AE" above) and was caught out. Thread deemed to be frivolous with regards to Volunteer Marek.
Towns Hill IP Oct. 01, 2016 Towns Hill: Block (72h) Blk It was commented that Towns Hill appeared to be playing around the edges of their topic-ban to figure out where the line was.
Sean.hoyland PIA Oct. 03, 2016 Epson Salts: Warning not to stonewall discussions Warn Administrators noticed Epson Salts' behaviour was more problematic in the underlying content dispute, with sanctions being unjustifiable for Sean.hoyland.
200 4 blocks
3 topic-bans
1 warning
1 page-level sanction
2 moot/not violations
1 inconclusive
1 withdrawn
Nishidani PIA Oct. 07, 2016 All editors in the PIA area, writ large: STOP ACTING LIKE ARSEHOLES OR GET HAMMERED INTO THE GROUND. Warn Responding admins were at their wits' end with the constant complaints about civility, and so a warning writ large was issued that civility complaints would very quickly lead to hard sanctions.
ה-זפר[ii] PIA Oct. 08, 2016 ה-זפר: Ban from PIA area (indef) TBan ה-זפר refused to engage with the thread.
Marteau BLP, AP2 Oct. 07, 2016 -nil- STL No administrators responded to the thread.
MShabazz PIA Oct. 11, 2016 -nil- NV Thread deemed an attempt at weaponising AE, as MShabazz's edits were removing copyright violations.
Kamel Tebaast PIA Oct. 11, 2016 Kamel Tebaast: Block (1yr + indef), ban from PIA area (indef) Blk, TBan N/A
Simert Ove PIA Oct. 12, 2016 Simert Ove: Block (24h)
Chas. Caltrop: Block (24h)
Israel Shahak: Extended-confirmed protected (indef)
Blk x2, PLS N/A
Volunteer Marek AP2 Oct. 18, 2016 -nil- WD Dispute was over the lede on Donald Trump; Volunteer Marek reverted to a version which seemed to have consensus while a contentious RfC started at the same time was underway against it. Filer withdrew once another unrelated editor closed the RfC as problematic.
Shy Twinkling PIA Oct. 22, 2016 Shy Twinkling: Block (72h), ban from PIA area (indef) Blk, TBan N/A
Anythingyouwant AP2 Oct. 20, 2016 -nil- NV Edits in dispute were removing potential biographical violations.

Footnotes

[edit]
  1. ^ a b c Until January 2021, the AP2 topic area was defined as "American politics after 1932".
  2. ^ he: Haazephyr