Jump to content

User:Jéské Couriano/ArbEnfCount/ArchiveGroups/180s

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Legend
Blk TBan Warn NEA Decl Acpt PLS Misc NV PE STL WD NOR
Block Topic-ban Warning Non-enforcement Declined appeal Accepted appeal Page-level sanction Misc. Moot/not a violation Procedural error Inconclusive Withdrawn Other decline reason
Archive no. Sanctions total Thread Arb case Date of last post Sanctions applied Summary Notes
181 1 block
1 topic-ban
1 warning
1 non-enforcement action
3 declined appeals
3 moot/not violations
2 procedural errors
PraetorianFury AP2 Sep. 15, 2015 PraetorianFury: Ban from same-sex marriage topic area (indef) TBan N/A
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by A Quest For Knowledge CC Sep. 16, 2015 -nil- NV Sanction being appealed lapsed on its own terms while thread was ongoing.
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by BenMcLean GG Sep. 20, 2015 BenMcLean: Ban from GG area remains in place. Decl The entire appeal was full of personal attacks against Gamaliel and extremely hyperbolic claims as to the article text. Admins took note of this and almost summarily declined the appeal.
Arbitration enforcement request by IP editor GG Sep. 22, 2015 -nil- PE The request was filed by an unregistered user and malformed. Even if it had been properly filed, it demanded that multiple users be subjected to Checkuser as a potential sockpuppet based off of what appears to be little more than a #chan-based conspiracy theory and would have been rejected for the privacy implications.
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by Soham321 IP Sep. 22, 2015 Soham321: Ban from India topic-area remains in place Decl Admins noted that their edits on Talk:Voltaire were attempts to import the banned topic-area into the article.
Lanlan lanwan PIA Sep. 23, 2015 Lanlan lanwan: Block (1w) Blk N/A
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by Unbiasedpov IP Sep. 26, 2015 Unbiasedpov: Ban from 2002 Gujarat riots topic-area remains in place. Decl N/A
19999o MAC Sep. 28, 2015 19999o: Block (48h, non-enforcement) NEA N/A
Gob Lofa TRB Sep. 28, 2015 -nil- NV N/A
DHeyward BLP Oct. 01, 2015 DHeyward: Formally warned of BLP sanctions Warn N/A
EllenCT AP2 Oct. 01, 2015 -nil- NV Edits at issue were stale.
John sargis -- Oct 01, 2015 -nil- PE Filer was seeking sanctions for breaches of a community-authorised sanction.
182 1 block
1 warning
1 successful appeal
1 inconclusive
HughD TPM Oct. 11, 2015 HughD: Warned to adhere to their topic ban Warn N/A
VictorD7 AP2 Oct. 11, 2015 -nil- STL Admins had issue with the complaint, as it was mainly presented as a wall of text coupled with a back-and-forth between filer and subject. Discussion ultimately petered out.
BenMcLean GG Oct. 13, 2015 BenMcLean: Block (24h) Blk BenMcLean talked himself into a block.
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by Slovenski Volk MAC Oct. 14, 2015 Slovenski Volk: Ban from Balkans topic-area lifted. Acpt N/A
183 2 topic-bans
1 warning
2 non-enforcement actions
1 declined appeal
5 page-level sanctions
1 moot/not a violation
1 withdrawn
Bachcell BLP Oct. 15, 2015 Bachcell: Ban from Ahmed Mohamed topic-area (indef) TBan Gamaliel issued a topic-ban immediately given the extreme nature of the BLP violations, with consensus later being to make the sanction indefinite.
Burridheut MAC Oct. 18, 2015 Burridheut: Ban from Spiro Koleka topic-area (indef) TBan EdJohnston expressed concern that Burridheut was likely right on the content issues (though criticised his behaviour) and that the content at issue - Koleka's ethnicity - was not going to be easy to address given his birthplace was a ethnically-diverse (and contested) region. He also noted that the German Wikipedia outright removed Koleka's ethnicity from their article on him for this reason.
DenisGusinje MAC Oct. 21, 2015 DenisGusinje: Block (48h, non-enforcement), formally warned of MAC sanctions Warn, NEA N/A
Caste articles and talk pages IP Oct. 22, 2015 Nair (and its talk page), Jat people, Vanniyar, and Bhumihar: Extended-confirmed restriction (indef) PLS x5 While WP:GS/CASTE was in effect at this time, the filer wanted authorisation to put 500/30 restrictions per IP and not the general sanctions regime as the Arbitration remedy would be more difficult to unilaterally reverse. This was granted along with the page-level sanctions.
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by Kyohyi GG Oct. 25, 2015 Kyohyi: Appeal of ban from GG area withdrawn. WD N/A
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by Burridheut MAC Oct. 29, 2015 Burridheut: Ban from Spiro Koleka topic-area remains in place. Decl N/A
(IPv4 address starting 74.) PIA Oct. 28, 2015 (The aforementioned IPv4): Block (1w, non-enforcement) NEA N/A
E.M.Gregory PIA Nov. 02, 2015 -nil- NV Dismissed as a content dispute.
184 1 topic-ban
1 warning
1 non-enforcement action
1 declined appeal
1 successful appeal
2 moot/not violations
1 procedural error
1 inconclusive
HistoneSebas PIA Nov. 02, 2015 Battle of Karameh: Full-protected (1w, non-enforcement) NEA HistoneSebas' actions weren't deemed to be breaches of the 1RR. but it was noted there was a slow-motion edit-war going on, prompting the full-protection to stamp it out.
Anticyclone à banias PIA Nov. 02, 2015 -nil- NV Anticyclone à banias opted to stop editing, making the request moot. They would, a month later, be indefinitely blocked as a sockpuppet.
Justlettersandnumbers -- Nov. 02, 2015 -nil- PE Retaliatory filing unrelated to any Arbitration over being admonished for copyright violations.
Richard Arthur Norton (1958- ) RAN Nov. 09, 2015 -nil- NV Matter referred to ARCA as it wasn't clear if Richard Arthur Norton (1958- )'s sanctions extended to replacing redirects with articles. (Arbitrators stated that they did.)
Appeal of discretionary sanction topic ban violation block of HughD TPM Nov. 10, 2015 HughD: Block remains in place. Decl N/A
Nocturnalnow BLP Nov. 15, 2015 -nil- STL Admins couldn't reach a consensus on any sanctions.
Lvivske EE Nov. 13, 2015 Lvivske: Ban from Azov Battalion topic-area (indef) TBan N/A
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by Yossiea~enwiki PIA Nov. 18, 2015 Yossiea: Block duration reduced to time served (i.e. block lifted) Acpt While Yossiea's initial block was deemed to be justified, the subsequent extension of it to indefinite was not.
Onefortyone 141 Nov. 24, 2015 Onefortyone: Warned against making personal attacks and edit-warring. Warn N/A
185 3 topic-bans
2 warnings
1 moot/not a violation
2 withdrawn
Jaakobou PIA Nov. 26, 2015 Jaakobou: Warned to adhere to their topic-ban Warn Jaakobou attempted to get a carveout for his topic-ban for the edits at issue, which was declined.
S Marshall EC Nov. 29, 2015 QuackGuru (filer): Ban from EC area (6mo) TBan Foot-shot; thread deemed frivolous with regards to S Marshall and deemed to be part of QuackGuru's efforts to hound him from the EC area.
Realskeptic PS Dec. 06, 2015 Realskeptic: Ban from vaccination and autism topic-areas (indef) TBan N/A
TruthIsDivine GC Dec. 07, 2015 TruthIsDivine: Ban from GC area (indef) TBan Subject would also be blocked independent of the thread; said block would be extended to an indefinite block due to confirmed sockpuppetry.
HughD TPM Dec. 07, 2015 -nil- NV Edits at issue were deemed to not be covered by his topic-ban.
Request for Full Protection --->via the ARB to exercising its defined Discretionary Powers regarding Electronic Cigarettes[sic] EC Dec. 12, 2015 -nil- WD Request is also malformed, and amounts to demanding ArbCom issue a discretionary sanction.
JzG GMO Dec. 18, 2015 -nil- WD Had it not been withdrawn, the thread would likely have been considered moot due to JzG self-reverting.
DrChrissy GMO Dec. 21, 2015 DrChrissy: Warned to adhere to topic ban Warn The comments at issue were struck by DrChrissy.
186 2 topic-bans
4 warnings
1 successful appeal
1 page-level sanction
1 not acted on for other reasons
Mystery Wolff EC Dec. 22, 2015 Mystery Wolff: Warned not to personalise content disputes with other editors Warn A topic-ban was initially put in place, but rescinded almost immediately after by the sanctioning admin as unjustified.
CFCF EC Dec. 23, 2015 CFCF: Warned against edit-warring Warn N/A
Vergilden GMO Dec. 24, 2015 Vergilden: Warned to adhere to 1RR in GMO area
jps[i]: Warned to adhere to 1RR in GMO area
Talk:Precautionary principle: 1RR notice appended
Warn x2, PLS N/A
Ollie231213 LGV Dec. 24, 2015 Ollie231213: Ban from LGV area (indef) TBan N/A
Nocturnalnow AP2 Dec. 24, 2015 Nocturnalnow: Ban from post-1932 American politics topic-area (indef) TBan Nocturnalnow defended themselves with a massive wall of text that also threw accusations at others. This defence wound up being a factor in imposing the indefinite topic-ban.
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by Winkelvi BLP Dec. 26, 2015 Winkelvi: Topic-ban from Rick Alan Ross rescinded Acpt Appeal accepted by the sanctioning administrator after Winkelvi removed the page from his watchlist.
Minor4th GMO Jan. 06, 2016 -nil- NOR Thread became stale.
187 2 blocks
2 topic-bans
1 non-enforcement action
2 moot/not violations
1 not acted on for other reasons
Volunteer Marek-personal attacks and incivility EE Jan. 07, 2016 -nil- NOR Thread deemed to be an attempt to weaponise AE
930310 LGV Jan. 07, 2016 930310: Ban from LGV area (indef) TBan N/A
HughD TPM Jan. 07, 2016 HughD: Block (1w) Blk N/A
Mystery Wolff EC Jan. 09, 2016 Mystery Wolff: Ban from EC area (indef w/ 6mo appeal intervals) TBan N/A
SageRad GMO Jan. 07, 2016 -nil- NV Thread deemed to be frivolous
Athenean MAC Jan. 07, 2016 -nil- NV Dismissed as a content dispute.
Scjessey AP2 Jan. 07, 2016 Mouse001 (filer): Block (indef, non-enforcement) NEA Foot-shot; filer blocked for relentless POV-pushing, BLP violations, and for being a likely sockpuppet
Jytdog GMO Jan. 06, 2016 DrChrissy (filer): Block (1w) Blk Foot-shot; thread deemed to be frivolous with respect to Jytdog and was filed in violation of an interaction ban
188 4 topic-bans
1 warning
2 declined appeals
4 moot/not violations
1 procedural error
1 not acted on for other reasons
Arbitration enforcement appeal by User:HughD AP2 Jan. 11, 2016 HughD: Block remains in place. Decl N/A
NewsAndEventsGuy (reported by NewsAndEventsGuy) CC Jan. 11, 2016 -nil- NV Subject/filer self-reported their own topic-ban violation. Admins declined to take further action as they recognised the issue and were working to correct it.
Kachelus LGV Jan. 14, 2016 -nil- NV Subject took a hiatus from en.wp, making the request moot.
Wiking PIA Jan. 12, 2016 -nil- PE Subject not formally alerted to PIA sanctions.
Lugnuts LGV Jan. 12, 2016 Legacypac (filer): Warned against weaponising AE Warn Foot-shot; thread deemed to be an attempt to weaponise AE
RolandR PIA3 Jan. 12, 2016 -nil- NV Thread deemed to be frivolous
Richard Arthur Norton (1958- ) RAN Jan. 14, 2016 -nil- NOR Formal sanctions were considered to be counterproductive, as Richard was participating in a related discussion at the Incidents noticeboard.
GreatGreen LGV Jan. 17, 2016 GreatGreen: Ban from LGV area (indef) TBan N/A
Dicklyon and Darkfrog24 ATC Jan. 22, 2016 Darkfrog24: Ban from project-level discussions about quotation marks and styles (indef w/6mo appeal intervals)
Dicklyon: Strongly encouraged to "voluntarily" accept a ban from project-level discussions about quotation marks and styles (indef w/6mo appeal intervals)
TBan x2 " I encourage Dicklyon to hold themselves to the [indefinite discussion topic-ban], but I'm not formally topic banning them at this point. However, Dickylon should note that this is without prejudice to a new AE action against them if anyone wishes." -Thryduulf, 14:46 Jan 22, 2016
BjörnBergman LGV Jan. 21, 2016 BjörnBergman: 1RR in LGV area (6mo) TBan N/A
TFBCT1 LGV Jan. 22, 2016 -nil- NV Subject stopped making the edits at the locus of the thread
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by Mystery Wolff EC Jan. 22, 2016 Mystery Wolff: Ban from EC area remains in place. Decl Mystery Wolff's entire argument was that the sanctioning administrator was involved; this argument was frivolous and resulted in an almost summary decline.
189 10 blocks
7 topic-bans
2 warnings
3 declined appeals
1 accepted appeal
9 moot/not violations
1 procedural error
3 inconclusive
4 not acted on for other reasons
I was topic-banned from RT News for 6 months for "disruptive edits" and I challenge this assertion[sic] EE Jan. 22, 2016 -nil- PE Request is grossly malformed.
Canada Jack LGV Jan. 22, 2016 -nil- STL The one responding admin seemed inclined to dismiss it as a content dispute.
NorthBySouthBaranof GG Jan. 25, 2016 -nil- NV "We're not going to block someone for submitting a terrible BLP to AFD. Nobody cares about this except GG partisans on both sides. Please edit the encyclopedia or find another website to use to argue." -Gamaliel, hatting thread
AJB43 PIA3 Feb. 02, 2016 -nil- NV Subject voluntarily agreed to adhere to the 500/30 restriction on the disputed page.
HistoryWrite PIA3 Feb. 03, 2016 HistoryWrite: Block (indef) Blk Indefinite block was marked as enforcement. It would be lifted in October following an appeal by email to the sanctioning administrator.
Darkfrog24 ATC Feb. 04, 2016 Darkfrog24: Ban expanded to the entire Manual of Style and related project-level discussions as regards quotation marks and styles (indef w/ annual appeal intervals) TBan N/A
Jaqeli AA2 Feb. 06, 2016 Jaqeli: Ban from AA2 area (indef) TBan N/A
(IPv4 address starting in 96.) PIA3 Feb. 09, 2016 (The aforementioned IPv4): Block (1w) Blk N/A
CFCF EC Feb. 09, 2016 -nil- STL Thread became stale.
Prokaryotes GMO Feb. 05, 2016 Prokaryotes: Ban from GMO area (indef) TBan N/A
SageRad GMO Feb. 12, 2016 SageRad: Voluntary ban from Bhopal disaster, Yvette d'Entremont, and Charles Eisenstein topic-areas (indef) TBan N/A
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by Ollie231213 LGV Feb. 15, 2016 Ollie231213: Ban from LGV area remains in place Decl N/A
Darkfrog24[2] ATC Feb. 15, 2016 Darkfrog24: Block (1w) Blk N/A
Galassi EE Feb. 17, 2016 -nil- NV Informal warning given to be more careful about their topic-ban, as Galassi had restored banned material inadvertantly with a revert.
Semitransgenic GMO Feb. 18, 2016 Semitransgenic: Ban from GMO area (indef) TBan Subject retired during the thread (and has not returned).
(IPv6 address starting 2604:2000:) PIA3 Feb. 24, 2016 (The aforementioned IPv6): Warned to stay off PIA articles
(2 more IPv6 addresses): Block
(IPv4 address): Block
Blk x3, Warn N/A
Catflap08 C&H Feb. 21, 2016 Catflap08: Block (1w)
Hijiri88 (filer): Warned to adhere to their interaction ban with Catflap08
Blk, Warn While the filing was a breach of Hijiri88's interaction ban, leniency was given as he had been told to file at AE.
Athenean EE Feb. 21, 2016 CometEncke (filer): Block (indef) Blk Foot-shot; subject blocked as an obvious sockpuppet created specifically to pick fights
Darkfrog24[3] ATC Mar. 01, 2016 Darkfrog24: Block (1yr + indef) Blk (N.B.: "1yr + indef" means the sanctioned user is indefinitely blocked, with the first year as Arbitration enforcement.)
Arminden PIA Mar. 02, 2016 -nil- NOR Formal sanctions considered disproportionate to the breach. (In other words, the violation was so minor/technical in nature that formal sanctions were considered unjustifiable.)
Markus2685 AA2 Mar. 04, 2016 -nil- NOR Admins deemed the situation was better dealt with at other venues, particularly SPI and AfD.
Konullu AA2 Mar. 03, 2016 -nil- NV Subject struck AfD comments at locus of thread.
Malik Shabazz AP2 Mar. 04, 2016 -nil- NOR Filer was seeking sanctions for actions taken in responce to deliberate provocation.
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by Sir Joseph AP2 Mar. 05, 2016 Sir Joseph: Ban from Bernie Sanders remains in place. Decl The topic-ban in question was only for 1w, and would lapse on its own terms two days after the appeal was formally closed.
Jytdog GMO Mar. 10, 2016 -nil- NV Subject self-reverted the edit in dispute.
Gaijin42 GC Mar. 16, 2016 -nil- NV Thread deemed to be frivolous
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by Volunteer Marek AP2 Mar. 15, 2016 Volunteer Marek: Ban from Bernie Sanders lifted wholesale. Acpt Administrators responding to the appeal found the ban to be completely unjustifiable, as Marek had only made one revert to the page and justified it on the talk page.
Felsic2 GC Mar. 15, 2016 -nil- NV Dismissed as a heated content dispute.
Scjessey AP2 Mar. 16, 2016 -nil- NV Thread deemed to be frivolous.
Mrbrklyn PIA3 Mar. 20, 2016 -nil- NOR Filer was attempting to reopen a loophole ArbCom closed in the 500/30 restriction; admins were unwilling to entertain this.
I9Q79oL78KiL0QTFHgyc GMO Mar. 21, 2016 -nil- STL Consensus was that Enforcement could not grant the sanctions sought, and encouraged the filer to take it to ArbCom. Short Brigade Harvester Boris made a serious suggestion to blanket-topic-ban all belligerents in the GMO area for six months, with any breaches being met with a siteban for the offender for the remainder of the ban; while this was liked it was seen as too extreme for AE.
Chesdovi PIA Mar. 25, 2016 Chesdovi: Ban from Zionism and Western Wall topic-areas and from introducing new Palestine-related material to articles that didn't have any to begin with (indef) TBan N/A
Sinceouch2422 FG2 Mar. 25, 2016 Sinceouch2422: Block (indef) Blk Subject indefinitely blocked as a topic-ban would result in effectively the same thing.
Beautifulpeoplelikeyou PS Mar. 25, 2016 Beautifulpeoplelikeyou: Ban from electronic harassment topic-area (indef) TBan N/A
Nableezy PIA Mar. 31, 2016 -nil- NV Diffs used were stale.
190 2 blocks
4 topic-bans
1 warning
3 moot/not violations
2 inconclusive
1 withdrawn
GHCool PIA Mar. 28, 2016 -nil- STL Discussion stalled out.
Conzar PS Apr. 04, 2016 Conzar: Ban from vaccination topic-area (indef) TBan N/A
ԱշոտՏՆՂ[ii] AA2 Apr. 05, 2016 ԱշոտՏՆՂ: Block (72h), formally warned of AA sanctions Blk, Warn N/A
FreeatlastChitchat IP Apr. 04, 2016 FreeatlastChitchat: Block (1w) Blk There was also discussion of a 0RR, but that was rendered moot for the time being by the block, with no prejudice to reopening that discussion if behaviour after the block didn't improve.
Askahrc PS Apr. 01, 2016 Askahrc: Ban from Deepak Chopra topic area (indef) TBan In responce to a request for evidence from another editor, Askahrc had posted material on his talk page that required suppression due to WP:OUTING concerns (though the other editor noted he found none of the evidence provided, including the contents of the suppressed edits, credible),
Cirt C&J Apr. 07, 2016 -nil- WD No administrators replied before the thread was withdrawn, but a third-party editor called out the thread as frivolous
No More Mr Nice Guy PIA Apr. 10, 2016 -nil- STL Thread became stale.
HughD TPM Apr. 12, 2016 -nil- NV Thread dismissed as frivolous. It was noted there was a parallel discussion on the Incidents noticeboard about putting a mutual interaction ban in place between HughD and the filer.
MarkBernstein GG Apr. 14, 2016 MarkBernstein: Ban from GG area (indef) TBan N/A
TripWire IP Apr. 22, 2016 -nil- NV Dismissed as a content dispute.
Monochrome Monitor PIA Apr. 22, 2016 -nil- NV Dismissed as a content dispute/out of scope.
HughD[2] TPM Apr. 25, 2016 HughD: Existing ban extended to 6mo and expanded to include all conservative American politics regardless of article TBan N/A

Footnotes

[edit]
  1. ^ User exercised right to vanish
  2. ^ hy: Asholtngh (approx.)