Wikipedia:Featured and good topic candidates/Failed log/September 2009

edit2006
April	1 promoted	6 not promoted
October	0 promoted	1 not promoted
November	4 promoted	1 not promoted
December	1 promoted	2 not promoted	1 sup.
2007
January	2 promoted	7 not promoted
February	1 promoted	2 not promoted	0 sup.	1 demoted
March	1 promoted	4 not promoted	0 sup.	1 demoted
April	2 promoted	1 not promoted
May	2 promoted	4 not promoted	2 sup.	1 kept
June	3 promoted	2 not promoted
July	0 promoted	0 not promoted
August	1 promoted	0 not promoted
September	4 promoted	6 not promoted	1 sup.
October	4 promoted	1 not promoted
November	2 promoted	0 not promoted	2 sup.
December	3 promoted	1 not promoted
2008
January	3 promoted	0 not promoted	2 sup.	2 demoted
February	2 promoted	1 not promoted
March	4 promoted	2 not promoted	1 sup.
April	5 promoted	4 not promoted	0 sup.	1 kept
May	5 promoted	1 not promoted	1 sup.
June	2 promoted	0 not promoted	1 sup.	2 demoted
July	3 promoted	4 not promoted	1 sup.
August	7 promoted	5 not promoted	2 sup.
September	10 FT, 7 GT	14 not promoted	3 sup.
October	2 FT, 7 GT	7 not promoted	3 sup.	1 kept
November	2 FT, 5 GT	3 not promoted	4 sup.
December	7 FT, 11 GT	5 not promoted	2 sup.
2009
January	2 FT, 4 GT	5 not promoted	2 sup.
February	7 FT, 6 GT	1 not promoted	2 sup.	1 kept, 1 demoted
March	2 FT, 3 GT	2 not promoted	1 sup.	1 kept
April	3 FT, 1 GT	3 not promoted	0 sup.
May	2 FT, 3 GT	0 not promoted	0 sup.	1 demoted
June	4 FT, 9 GT	2 not promoted	3 sup.	3 demoted
July	2 FT, 6 GT	5 not promoted	3 sup.	2 demoted
August	2 FT, 6 GT	2 not promoted	1 sup.
September	3 FT, 2 GT	1 not promoted	2 sup.	2 kept
October	3 FT, 4 GT	0 not promoted	1 sup.	2 kept, 6 demoted
November	1 FT, 1 GT	1 not promoted	0 sup.	1 kept
December	1 FT, 5 GT	1 not promoted	0 sup.
2010
January	1 FT, 3 GT	1 not promoted	2 sup.	2 demoted
February	0 FT, 3 GT	2 not promoted	3 sup.	2 kept, 2 demoted
March	5 FT, 4 GT	3 not promoted	1 sup.	1 kept, 5 demoted
April	1 FT, 8 GT	3 not promoted	4 sup.
May	0 FT, 7 GT	0 not promoted	1 sup.
June	2 FT, 3 GT	0 not promoted	0 sup.	1 demoted
July	5 FT, 3 GT	2 not promoted	2 sup.	2 demoted
August	1 FT, 6 GT	0 not promoted	1 sup.
September	1 FT, 1 GT	4 not promoted	0 sup.
October	3 FT, 18 GT	4 not promoted	1 sup.	2 kept, 2 demoted
November	0 FT, 2 GT	0 not promoted	0 sup.	2 kept, 1 demoted
December	2 FT, 7 GT	1 not promoted	1 sup.	1 kept, 1 demoted
2011
January	2 FT, 5 GT	3 not promoted	0 sup.	0 kept, 1 demoted
February	1 FT, 11 GT	1 not promoted	0 sup.	1 kept, 1 demoted
March	0 FT, 4 GT	2 not promoted	0 sup.	1 kept, 0 demoted
April	1 FT, 9 GT	1 not promoted	1 sup.	0 kept, 0 demoted
May	1 FT, 4 GT	0 not promoted	0 sup.	0 kept, 2 demoted
June	1 FT, 2 GT	2 not promoted	0 sup.	0 kept, 0 demoted
July	2 FT, 2 GT	1 not promoted	0 sup.	0 kept, 2 demoted
August	1 FT, 8 GT	2 not promoted	0 sup.	0 kept, 1 demoted
September	2 FT, 2 GT	2 not promoted	1 sup.	0 kept, 0 demoted
October	4 FT, 6 GT	0 not promoted	2 sup.	0 kept, 0 demoted
November	1 FT, 2 GT	1 not promoted	0 sup.	0 kept, 1 demoted
December	1 FT, 4 GT	1 not promoted	0 sup.	0 kept, 1 demoted
2012
January	1 FT, 3 GT	0 not promoted	0 sup.	0 kept, 0 demoted
February	0 FT, 11 GT	0 not promoted	1 sup.	0 kept, 0 demoted
March	2 FT, 0 GT	0 not promoted	0 sup.	0 kept, 0 demoted
April	0 FT, 6 GT	1 not promoted	0 sup.	1 kept, 0 demoted
May	1 FT, 5 GT	0 not promoted	0 sup.	1 kept, 0 demoted
June	0 FT, 2 GT	0 not promoted	0 sup.	0 kept, 0 demoted
July	0 FT, 14 GT	1 not promoted	1 sup.	0 kept, 4 demoted
August	2 FT, 0 GT	0 not promoted	0 sup.	0 kept, 0 demoted
September	1 FT, 6 GT	0 not promoted	0 sup.	2 kept, 0 demoted
October	1 FT, 3 GT	0 not promoted	0 sup.	0 kept, 0 demoted
November	2 FT, 4 GT	0 not promoted	0 sup.	0 kept, 0 demoted
December	1 FT, 6 GT	0 not promoted	1 sup.	0 kept, 0 demoted
2013
January	0 FT, 3 GT	0 not promoted	0 sup.	0 kept, 0 demoted
February	0 FT, 3 GT	0 not promoted	1 sup.	0 kept, 0 demoted
March	2 FT, 2 GT	1 not promoted	1 sup.	0 kept, 1 demoted
April	2 FT, 4 GT	1 not promoted	0 sup.	2 kept, 0 demoted
May	0 FT, 5 GT	0 not promoted	0 sup.	0 kept, 0 demoted
June	1 FT, 0 GT	0 not promoted	0 sup.	1 kept, 1 demoted
July	1 FT, 8 GT	0 not promoted	0 sup.	3 kept, 2 demoted
August	1 FT, 2 GT	0 not promoted	0 sup.	0 kept, 0 demoted
September	0 FT, 4 GT	0 not promoted	0 sup.	1 kept, 0 demoted
October	4 FT, 1 GT	0 not promoted	1 sup.	0 kept, 0 demoted
November	1 FT, 1 GT	1 not promoted	0 sup.	0 kept, 0 demoted
December	0 FT, 4 GT	1 not promoted	0 sup.	0 kept, 1 demoted
2014
January	1 FT, 2 GT	0 not promoted	2 sup.	0 kept, 0 demoted
February	0 FT, 3 GT	1 not promoted	0 sup.	1 kept, 0 demoted
March	0 FT, 3 GT	1 not promoted	0 sup.	0 kept, 1 demoted
April	1 FT, 0 GT	0 not promoted	0 sup.	0 kept, 0 demoted
May	1 FT, 0 GT	0 not promoted	0 sup.	0 kept, 1 demoted
June	2 FT, 4 GT	1 not promoted	2 sup.	0 kept, 0 demoted
July	1 FT, 3 GT	0 not promoted	0 sup.	1 kept, 0 demoted
August	4 FT, 1 GT	2 not promoted	2 sup.	0 kept, 1 demoted
September	1 FT, 5 GT	0 not promoted	0 sup.	0 kept, 0 demoted
October	1 FT, 2 GT	1 not promoted	1 sup.	0 kept, 2 demoted
November	1 FT, 1 GT	0 not promoted	1 sup.	0 kept, 0 demoted
December	1 FT, 0 GT	1 not promoted	0 sup.	0 kept, 1 demoted
2015
January	0 FT, 2 GT	0 not promoted	0 sup.	0 kept, 1 demoted
February	0 FT, 1 GT	0 not promoted	0 sup.	0 kept, 1 demoted
March	1 FT, 1 GT	0 not promoted	0 sup.	0 kept, 0 demoted
April	0 FT, 2 GT	1 not promoted	0 sup.	0 kept, 1 demoted
May	2 FT, 3 GT	1 not promoted	2 sup.	0 kept, 0 demoted
June	0 FT, 0 GT	0 not promoted	0 sup.	0 kept, 0 demoted
July	1 FT, 3 GT	0 not promoted	1 sup.	1 kept, 1 demoted
August	1 FT, 3 GT	0 not promoted	0 sup.	0 kept, 0 demoted
September	2 FT, 2 GT	0 not promoted	1 sup.	0 kept, 0 demoted
October	0 FT, 0 GT	1 not promoted	0 sup.	0 kept, 0 demoted
November	1 FT, 2 GT	0 not promoted	0 sup.	0 kept, 0 demoted
December	1 FT, 2 GT	0 not promoted	0 sup.	0 kept, 0 demoted
2016
January	1 FT, 1 GT	0 not promoted	2 sup.	0 kept, 0 demoted
February	0 FT, 0 GT	0 not promoted	0 sup.	0 kept, 0 demoted
March	1 FT, 3 GT	0 not promoted	1 sup.	0 kept, 0 demoted
April	0 FT, 0 GT	0 not promoted	0 sup.	1 kept, 0 demoted
May	0 FT, 3 GT	1 not promoted	2 sup.	0 kept, 0 demoted
June	1 FT, 2 GT	0 not promoted	2 sup.	0 kept, 2 demoted
July	1 FT, 2 GT	1 not promoted	0 sup.	0 kept, 0 demoted
August	1 FT, 3 GT	0 not promoted	0 sup.	1 kept, 1 demoted
September	0 FT, 7 GT	0 not promoted	0 sup.	0 kept, 1 demoted
October	0 FT, 3 GT	0 not promoted	3 sup.	0 kept, 0 demoted
November	0 FT, 4 GT	0 not promoted	1 sup.	1 kept, 2 demoted
December	0 FT, 1 GT	1 not promoted	0 sup.	0 kept, 1 demoted
2017
January	2 FT, 3 GT	1 not promoted	1 sup.	0 kept, 1 demoted
February	0 FT, 3 GT	2 not promoted	0 sup.	0 kept, 0 demoted
March	4 FT, 2 GT	0 not promoted	0 sup.	1 kept, 0 demoted
April	1 FT, 3 GT	0 not promoted	2 sup.	0 kept, 2 demoted
May	1 FT, 6 GT	0 not promoted	0 sup.	0 kept, 0 demoted
June	0 FT, 2 GT	0 not promoted	1 sup.	0 kept, 0 demoted
July	0 FT, 4 GT	0 not promoted	1 sup.	0 kept, 0 demoted
August	0 FT, 1 GT	1 not promoted	0 sup.	0 kept, 0 demoted
September	0 FT, 1 GT	0 not promoted	0 sup.	0 kept, 0 demoted
October	0 FT, 1 GT	0 not promoted	1 sup.	0 kept, 0 demoted
November	1 FT, 0 GT	1 not promoted	0 sup.	1 kept, 0 demoted
December	1 FT, 2 GT	0 not promoted	0 sup.	0 kept, 0 demoted
2018
January	1 FT, 4 GT	0 not promoted	1 sup.	0 kept, 0 demoted
February	0 FT, 1 GT	0 not promoted	0 sup.	0 kept, 0 demoted
March	0 FT, 1 GT	0 not promoted	0 sup.	0 kept, 1 demoted
April	1 FT, 5 GT	0 not promoted	0 sup.	1 kept, 0 demoted
May	1 FT, 4 GT	0 not promoted	0 sup.	0 kept, 1 demoted
June	1 FT, 2 GT	1 not promoted	1 sup.	0 kept, 0 demoted
July	1 FT, 4 GT	1 not promoted	0 sup.	0 kept, 0 demoted
August	1 FT, 2 GT	0 not promoted	0 sup.	0 kept, 0 demoted
September	0 FT, 3 GT	2 not promoted	1 sup.	1 kept, 0 demoted
October	1 FT, 1 GT	0 not promoted	0 sup.	0 kept, 0 demoted
November	0 FT, 1 GT	0 not promoted	0 sup.	0 kept, 0 demoted
December	0 FT, 3 GT	0 not promoted	0 sup.	0 kept, 0 demoted
2019
January	1 FT, 1 GT	4 not promoted	4 sup.	0 kept, 2 demoted
February	0 FT, 3 GT	0 not promoted	0 sup.	0 kept, 0 demoted
March	1 FT, 3 GT	2 not promoted	2 sup.	0 kept, 0 demoted
April	0 FT, 0 GT	0 not promoted	0 sup.	0 kept, 1 demoted
May	0 FT, 4 GT	0 not promoted	0 sup.	0 kept, 1 demoted
June	0 FT, 1 GT	1 not promoted	0 sup.	0 kept, 0 demoted
July	1 FT, 2 GT	1 not promoted	0 sup.	0 kept, 1 demoted
August	1 FT, 5 GT	1 not promoted	0 sup.	0 kept, 0 demoted
September	0 FT, 0 GT	0 not promoted	1 sup.	0 kept, 0 demoted
October	1 FT, 2 GT	1 not promoted	0 sup.	0 kept, 3 demoted
November	0 FT, 1 GT	1 not promoted	2 sup.	0 kept, 1 demoted
December	1 FT, 0 GT	0 not promoted	0 sup.	0 kept, 0 demoted
2020
January	0 FT, 0 GT	0 not promoted	0 sup.	0 kept, 0 demoted
February	1 FT, 5 GT	0 not promoted	2 sup.	0 kept, 5 demoted
March	3 FT, 1 GT	1 not promoted	0 sup.	1 kept, 0 demoted
April	0 FT, 0 GT	0 not promoted	1 sup.	1 kept, 1 demoted
May	1 FT, 2 GT	1 not promoted	3 sup.	2 kept, 4 demoted
June	0 FT, 8 GT	0 not promoted	2 sup.	0 kept, 0 demoted
July	0 FT, 2 GT	2 not promoted	1 sup.	0 kept, 0 demoted
August	1 FT, 2 GT	2 not promoted	1 sup.	0 kept, 0 demoted
September	0 FT, 3 GT	0 not promoted	0 sup.	0 kept, 2 demoted
October	0 FT, 5 GT	1 not promoted	2 sup.	0 kept, 1 demoted
November	1 FT, 0 GT	2 not promoted	0 sup.	0 kept, 0 demoted
December	0 FT, 0 GT	0 not promoted	1 sup.	0 kept, 1 demoted
2021
January	0 FT, 3 GT	1 not promoted	0 sup.	0 kept, 0 demoted
February	1 FT, 1 GT	1 not promoted	0 sup.	0 kept, 0 demoted
March	0 FT, 4 GT	1 not promoted	1 sup.	0 kept, 1 demoted
April	0 FT, 1 GT	0 not promoted	0 sup.	0 kept, 1 demoted
May	0 FT, 4 GT	1 not promoted	0 sup.	0 kept, 0 demoted
June	2 FT, 1 GT	0 not promoted	0 sup.	0 kept, 2 demoted
July	1 FT, 1 GT	0 not promoted	0 sup.	0 kept, 0 demoted
August	0 FT, 4 GT	0 not promoted	2 sup.	1 kept, 0 demoted
September	1 FT, 1 GT	0 not promoted	0 sup.	0 kept, 1 demoted
October	1 FT, 0 GT	0 not promoted	0 sup.	0 kept, 1 demoted
November	0 FT, 0 GT	0 not promoted	0 sup.	0 kept, 0 demoted
December	0 FT, 0 GT	1 not promoted	0 sup.	2 kept, 1 demoted
2022
January	0 FT, 4 GT	0 not promoted	2 sup.	2 kept, 3 demoted
February	1 FT, 0 GT	0 not promoted	0 sup.	0 kept, 0 demoted
March	0 FT, 2 GT	1 not promoted	1 sup.	0 kept, 3 demoted
April	1 FT, 1 GT	0 not promoted	2 sup.	0 kept, 1 demoted
May	1 FT, 1 GT	0 not promoted	0 sup.	0 kept, 1 demoted
June	2 FT, 0 GT	0 not promoted	0 sup.	0 kept, 0 demoted
July	0 FT, 0 GT	0 not promoted	1 sup.	0 kept, 0 demoted
August	0 FT, 2 GT	0 not promoted	2 sup.	0 kept, 3 demoted
September	2 FT, 3 GT	0 not promoted	0 sup.	0 kept, 1 demoted
October	1 FT, 5 GT	0 not promoted	2 sup.	0 kept, 2 demoted
November	0 FT, 1 GT	1 not promoted	1 sup.	0 kept, 1 demoted
December	0 FT, 0 GT	0 not promoted	1 sup.	0 kept, 0 demoted
2023
January	0 FT, 0 GT	0 not promoted	0 sup.	0 kept, 1 demoted
February	0 FT, 1 GT	0 not promoted	1 sup.	0 kept, 4 demoted
March	0 FT, 2 GT	0 not promoted	2 sup.	0 kept, 0 demoted
April	0 FT, 0 GT	0 not promoted	1 sup.	0 kept, 1 demoted
May	0 FT, 1 GT	0 not promoted	0 sup.	0 kept, 1 demoted
June	1 FT, 1 GT	0 not promoted	0 sup.	0 kept, 1 demoted
July	0 FT, 1 GT	0 not promoted	0 sup.	0 kept, 2 demoted
August	2 FT, 3 GT	0 not promoted	3 sup.	0 kept, 2 demoted
September	1 FT, 4 GT	0 not promoted	1 sup.	0 kept, 0 demoted
October	1 FT, 0 GT	0 not promoted	0 sup.	0 kept, 0 demoted
November	1 FT, 0 GT	0 not promoted	0 sup.	0 kept, 0 demoted
December	0 FT, 0 GT	0 not promoted	0 sup.	0 kept, 0 demoted
2024
January	2 FT, 6 GT	2 not promoted	7 sup.	0 kept, 5 demoted
February	0 FT, 0 GT	0 not promoted	0 sup.	0 kept, 0 demoted
March	1 FT, 1 GT	0 not promoted	0 sup.	0 kept, 0 demoted
April	1 FT, 7 GT	0 not promoted	0 sup.	1 kept, 1 demoted
May	0 FT, 4 GT	0 not promoted	0 sup.	0 kept, 0 demoted
June	3 FT, 5 GT	2 not promoted	0 sup.	0 kept, 0 demoted
July	0 FT, 5 GT	0 not promoted	5 sup.	0 kept, 0 demoted
August	2 FT, 1 GT	1 not promoted	1 sup.	0 kept, 1 demoted
September	0 FT, 2 GT	0 not promoted	0 sup.	1 kept, 0 demoted
October	0 FT, 5 GT	1 not promoted	2 sup.	0 kept, 2 demoted
November	1 FT, 2 GT	0 not promoted	0 sup.	0 kept, 0 demoted
December	0 FT, 2 GT	0 not promoted	0 sup.	0 kept, 1 demoted

Discographies of Young Divas members

4 articles

File:Young Divas at Kmart 2 Crop.jpg

Ricki-Lee Coulter

Paulini Curuenavuli

Jessica Mauboy

This is a featured topic nomination. Singers Ricki-Lee Coulter, Paulini Curuenavuli and Jessica Mauboy are former members of the pop group the Young Divas, their discography articles are featured lists. Singers Kate DeAraugo and Emily Williams are current members of the pop group, however their discography articles have been deleted, for they were ineligible for featured list status, due to their limited subject matter. (DeAraugo's FLC and Williams' PR and subsequent AFD) Subtopics of the each member's discography (containing their releases) and the addition of Kate DeAraugo and Emily Williams discographies to this topic are possible improvements. Also, Young Divas discography was not promoted to featured list status, due to limited subject matter, and so has subsequently been peer reviewed. Furthermore, all lists within the topic are linked together using a template, Template:Young Divas. Thanks! Alex Douglas (talk) 03:13, 6 September 2009 (UTC)[reply]

Oppose main list should me merged into the group article. Nergaal (talk) 18:16, 6 September 2009 (UTC)[reply]
Comment - I think this topic is a bit disjointed. The lead article in no way mentions the individual discographies of the members of the band, and hence the lead is somewhat unconnected from the other articles. Also I find it ironic that the 3 members whose discography articles are included are the 3 who have left the band, whilst the 2 who have not left do not have articles - this is not IMO a reason to oppose (unlike the first reason), but it adds to the disjointedness a little - rst20xx (talk) 18:48, 6 September 2009 (UTC)[reply]
Oppose for now It's a nice idea and, if the lead were more connected to the other articles and were FL status, I would support. However, I would say wait until Young Divas have released a bit more material. -- EA Swyer ^Talk _{Contributions} 01:32, 7 September 2009 (UTC)[reply]
Close with no consensus to promote - rst20xx (talk) 16:00, 21 September 2009 (UTC)[reply]