Jump to content

Talk:List of radio dramas based on Marvel Comics publications

Page contents not supported in other languages.
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Draft Review

[edit]

I'm unsure whether this article really passes WP:NLIST with the current title. I doesn't appear that the current sources call these shows "radio dramas". It looks like "Audio Storytelling", "Audio Series", "Audio Entertainment", "Scripted/Unscripted Series", "Script/Unscripted Programs", and "Podcast" are all mentioned throughout the current sources, but never "Radio Drama". The lede currently states that the "list includes radio dramas, podcasts, and rock operas", are any of these broadcast on the radio? Is the spiderman series the only "rock opera"? List of comic book and superhero podcasts might be a good place to merge this content, however, I made that list a while back and I'm not even sure if that really passes WP:NLIST now that I've gained a little more experience with list articles. It also appears that most of these sources are very WP:ROUTINE announcements about the launch of individual series rather than the subject having "been discussed as a group or set by independent reliable sources". For instance, List of history podcasts and List of book podcasts clearly have sources that discuss the subject as a group because most of the sources explicitly include lists of history podcasts and book podcasts (disclaimer: I made those lists as well). I'm commenting here on the talk page instead of reviewing the article because I'm less comfortable with the requirements related to the notability of lists, but I'm interested in seeing the outcome of this particular draft. TipsyElephant (talk) 16:24, 12 December 2021 (UTC)[reply]

I'm also concerned about the length of this list. It looks like the Wastelanders is a single show with different seasons, which leaves a total of five items on the list--two of which don't even have Wikipedia pages. TipsyElephant (talk) 16:32, 12 December 2021 (UTC)[reply]