Jump to content

Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive index

Page contents not supported in other languages.
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia


Report generated based on a request from Wikipedia talk:Notability (music). It matches the following masks: Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive <#>, Wikipedia talk:Notability (music).
This page was last edited by Legobot (talk | contribs) 3 months ago. (Update timer)

Discussion Topic Replies (estimated) Archive Link
Guideline questions 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 1#Guideline questions
large and small countries 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 1#large and small countries
Historical importance 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 1#Historical importance
Genres 7 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 1#Genres
Record labels 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 1#Record labels
Suggested guidline for musicians 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 1#Suggested guidline for musicians
Top 100 hit 4 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 1#Top 100 hit
Other Wikipedia guidelines 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 2#Other Wikipedia guidelines
TV Talent Shows 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 2#TV Talent Shows
IF IT WERE AT ALL POSSIBLE... 4 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 1#IF IT WERE AT ALL POSSIBLE...
Intro "disclaimer" 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 2#Intro "disclaimer"
College bands/groups and notability 3 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 1#College bands/groups and notability
Concerns 8 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 1#Concerns
Criterion 4 4 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 1#Criterion 4
Does verifiability not subsume this guideline? 6 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 2#Does verifiability not subsume this guideline?
Music genres 4 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 1#Music genres
Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion/Proposal/3-C 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 2#Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion/Proposal/3-C
Vocal profile controversy 12 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 2#Vocal profile controversy
Local scene of a city? 3 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 2#Local scene of a city?
Managers 3 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 2#Managers
Tour 5 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 2#Tour
Indie labels and 2 album test 4 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 2#Indie labels and 2 album test
Regular performers 5 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 2#Regular performers
Classical music performers 4 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 2#Classical music performers
top 100? 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 2#top 100?
Song guidelines 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 2#Song guidelines
Types of gigs 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 2#Types of gigs
Major Music Media? 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 2#Major Music Media?
Self-published CDs 4 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 2#Self-published CDs
Minor Change to Text 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 2#Minor Change to Text
list of real Genres? 3 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 2#list of real Genres?
What about artistically significant, poorly circulated albums, recent and otherwise? 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 2#What about artistically significant, poorly circulated albums, recent and otherwise?
What about stopping all this endless timewasting, and using the perfectly workable rules we already have? 22 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 2#What about stopping all this endless timewasting, and using the perfectly workable rules we already have?
Local bands 5 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 2#Local bands
Dr. Demento 6 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 2#Dr. Demento
Proposed additions 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 2#Proposed additions
Unreleased, unfinished, or scheduled albums 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 2#Unreleased, unfinished, or scheduled albums
Bias 9 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 2#Bias
random thoughts 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 2#random thoughts
The "outside mass media" guidelines 4 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 2#The "outside mass media" guidelines
Requested move 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 2#Requested move
Night Stalker 3 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 2#Night Stalker
Recent AfD for KOMPRESSOR 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 2#Recent AfD for KOMPRESSOR
Pop Idol/X-Factor: What would count as placed? 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 2#Pop Idol/X-Factor: What would count as placed?
Please comment guideline changes 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 2#Please comment guideline changes
Propose we remove the "notable" in "notable musical venues" 4 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 2#Propose we remove the "notable" in "notable musical venues"
"A band that is otherwise extremely notable" 4 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 2#"A band that is otherwise extremely notable"
Music wikicities 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 2#Music wikicities
Speedy deletion 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 2#Speedy deletion
notably unnotable 4 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 2#notably unnotable
drop "extremely" for side projects 3 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 3#drop "extremely" for side projects
Indie bands/labels/etc. 24 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 3#Indie bands/labels/etc.
Notability Proportional to Genre? 6 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 3#Notability Proportional to Genre?
Proposed change 17 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 3#Proposed change
Videos 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 3#Videos
Notability of genre 5 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 3#Notability of genre
Placed in major award show? 5 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 3#Placed in major award show?
Examples of media 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 3#Examples of media
Genre notabilty guidelines proposal 10 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 3#Genre notabilty guidelines proposal
{{db-band}} 4 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 3#{{db-band}}
Festivals 7 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 3#Festivals
Albums criteria 3 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 3#Albums criteria
Classical music 3 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 3#Classical music
Stop discriminating against notable independent artists 7 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 3#Stop discriminating against notable independent artists
"prominent representative of a notable style" 32 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 3#"prominent representative of a notable style"
Competitions 5 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 3#Competitions
Gold Criteria and Country Size 4 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 3#Gold Criteria and Country Size
Deletion 11 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 3#Deletion
Place for mentioning candidates for deletion 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 3#Place for mentioning candidates for deletion
"Two or more albums for a major label" 6 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 3#"Two or more albums for a major label"
Useless standard 7 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 3#Useless standard
Possible methods of Pin-Pointing a Local Musician/Band is "Notable" 10 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 3#Possible methods of Pin-Pointing a Local Musician/Band is "Notable"
American Idol Underground question 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 3#American Idol Underground question
Satellite 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 3#Satellite
Completely discriminatory 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 3#Completely discriminatory
iTunes? 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 3#iTunes?
Separate entries for band members? 4 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 3#Separate entries for band members?
Notability for Recordings 8 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 3#Notability for Recordings
Under the Shadow 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 3#Under the Shadow
Send me an angel 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 3#Send me an angel
Session musicians 6 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 4#Session musicians
Albums for sale on amazon.com, barnes and noble, etc. 6 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 4#Albums for sale on amazon.com, barnes and noble, etc.
My revert 4 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 4#My revert
Certified Gold 4 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 4#Certified Gold
Media Exposure 4 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 4#Media Exposure
Headliners vs. support acts 43 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 4#Headliners vs. support acts
"is notable if" 7 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 4#"is notable if"
"National or international "vs "significant" tours 30 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 4#"National or international "vs "significant" tours
What constitutes a "major award" 6 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 4#What constitutes a "major award"
Adding section for albums 14 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 4#Adding section for albums
"King of the Road"? 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 4#"King of the Road"?
Albums 10 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 4#Albums
Historical Notability 7 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 4#Historical Notability
Additional Resources 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 4#Additional Resources
Can someone define 'Chart' please? 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 4#Can someone define 'Chart' please?
Jazz Artists & Idiotic Challenges To Their "Notability" 5 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 4#Jazz Artists & Idiotic Challenges To Their "Notability"
Is this a guideline? 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 4#Is this a guideline?
Notability (comics) 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 4#Notability (comics)
What the? 3 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 4#What the?
Notability:Others 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 4#Notability:Others
Problem 15 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 4#Problem
Problem? 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 4#Problem?
Notability of "reality television" contestants? 12 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 4#Notability of "reality television" contestants?
size of country 3 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 4#size of country
Notable or not? 5 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 4#Notable or not?
Bullets --> numbers 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 4#Bullets --> numbers
Proposed merge of WP:SINGLE and WP:LP 3 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 4#Proposed merge of WP:SINGLE and WP:LP
User:Fang Aili is not following the rules 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 4#User:Fang Aili is not following the rules
Help requested with m-flo 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 4#Help requested with m-flo
Mere tours and opening acts 21 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 4#Mere tours and opening acts
anti-indie 3 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 4#anti-indie
Members of orchestras 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 4#Members of orchestras
Question 3 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 4#Question
Music charts 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 4#Music charts
Determining notability for music in minority groups 4 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 4#Determining notability for music in minority groups
Multi purpose chemical 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 4#Multi purpose chemical
National Tour 12 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 5#National Tour
DJs and "touring" 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 5#DJs and "touring"
Disputed tag regarding album notability 8 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 5#Disputed tag regarding album notability
"a song or composition which has won or placed in a major music competition" 13 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 5#"a song or composition which has won or placed in a major music competition"
Non-English sources 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 5#Non-English sources
Massive changes reverted 7 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 5#Massive changes reverted
Lists of musicians 7 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 5#Lists of musicians
Disputed tag 11 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 5#Disputed tag
Notability of albums proposition 19 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 5#Notability of albums proposition
Reverting wars 6 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 5#Reverting wars
Bands with trademarked names 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 5#Bands with trademarked names
Niche Markets + New and Emerging Artists 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 4#Niche Markets + New and Emerging Artists
Reversed change 37 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 5#Reversed change
Reverting to old version 14 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 5#Reverting to old version
Reverted changes for discussion 5 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 5#Reverted changes for discussion
The Hatta Scandal and why the imposed guidelines are errant nonsense, complete foolishness and beneath contempt 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 5#The Hatta Scandal and why the imposed guidelines are errant nonsense, complete foolishness and beneath contempt
hit on any national music chart footnote 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 5#hit on any national music chart footnote
Looking ahead 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 5#Looking ahead
Musicians - artists or not? 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 5#Musicians - artists or not?
Bootleg albums - notable, not notable, or need independent sources? 3 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 5#Bootleg albums - notable, not notable, or need independent sources?
Note on albums 5 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 5#Note on albums
Album/single reviews 14 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 5#Album/single reviews
Major Distributors equal to Major Labels 3 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 5#Major Distributors equal to Major Labels
National Charts 3 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 5#National Charts
Does this qualify as notable? 6 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 5#Does this qualify as notable?
Question re: notability 4 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 5#Question re: notability
Mixtapes 5 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 5#Mixtapes
Please evaluate 8 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 5#Please evaluate
My concern about WP:Music 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 5#My concern about WP:Music
Fan club CDs? 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 5#Fan club CDs?
College a cappella groups 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 5#College a cappella groups
Charts 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 5#Charts
Minor criteria 3 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 5#Minor criteria
General notability guideline template 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 5#General notability guideline template
PNC tag 76 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 5#PNC tag
Protected 28 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 5#Protected
Protection (again) 14 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 5#Protection (again)
The Memory Will Never Die 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 5#The Memory Will Never Die
Possible resolution 18 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 5#Possible resolution
Blood for Blood 15 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 5#Blood for Blood
Template:pnc nominated for deletion 21 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 5#Template:pnc nominated for deletion
Inclusion of tribute bands in articles about notable acts 6 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 5#Inclusion of tribute bands in articles about notable acts
Proposed policy change at Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 5#Proposed policy change at Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons
Protected yet again 7 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 5#Protected yet again
Evaluating consensus for inclusion of WP:N wording here 17 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 5#Evaluating consensus for inclusion of WP:N wording here
Wikipedia:Notability (music)/rewrite potentially a fresh start 36 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 5#Wikipedia:Notability (music)/rewrite potentially a fresh start
Leaks 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 6#Leaks
Wikipedia:Notability (songs) 17 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 6#Wikipedia:Notability (songs)
Albums? 37 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 6#Albums?
Songs 8 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 6#Songs
Can you get rid of Criterion 1? 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 6#Can you get rid of Criterion 1?
Criterion 13 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 6#Criterion 13
Criterion 17 10 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 6#Criterion 17
Shorter version (Jeff's) 11 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 6#Shorter version (Jeff's)
Music festivals 9 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 6#Music festivals
Unreleased albums 8 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 6#Unreleased albums
Any one of the following criteria!?!?!? 18 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 6#Any one of the following criteria!?!?!?
individual songs 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 6#individual songs
Record labels 4 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 6#Record labels
Touring? 5 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 6#Touring?
Genres 6 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 6#Genres
Help needed 4 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 6#Help needed
Notability of concert tours 5 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 6#Notability of concert tours
Criteria and Verification 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 6#Criteria and Verification
Songs section 29 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 6#Songs section
Songs 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 6#Songs 2
work of media that is notable 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 6#work of media that is notable
Country size 4 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 6#Country size
Independent loophole 7 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 6#Independent loophole
STRONGLY DISAGREE 18 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 6#STRONGLY DISAGREE
An Improved Proposal 5 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 6#An Improved Proposal
Discogs.com 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 6#Discogs.com
Define "major award" 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 6#Define "major award"
Restrictions on albums section 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 6#Restrictions on albums section
Notability of band members 7 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 6#Notability of band members
Proposal 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 6#Proposal
Problems with this guideline 3 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 6#Problems with this guideline
Tour Page 8 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 6#Tour Page
Ivan Ilic 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 6#Ivan Ilic
New essay 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 6#New essay
Guidelines For Discographies 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 6#Guidelines For Discographies
Tribute albums 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 6#Tribute albums
Criterion 5 - why two or more albums needed for notability? 5 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 6#Criterion 5 - why two or more albums needed for notability?
Songs section redux 7 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 6#Songs section redux
AFD 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 6#AFD
criteria number 5 8 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 9#criteria number 5
Examples of "major music competition" 3 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 6#Examples of "major music competition"
Upcoming albums 4 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 6#Upcoming albums
Classical Music 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 6#Classical Music
Unbalanced Enforcement 3 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 6#Unbalanced Enforcement
Criteria Question 10 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 6#Criteria Question
"Major music competition" 2 3 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 7#"Major music competition" 2
DJ's 3 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 7#DJ's
Contestants 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 7#Contestants
Three separate stubs, or one bigger article? 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 7#Three separate stubs, or one bigger article?
Criterion 9 6 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 7#Criterion 9
Criteria for musicians and ensembles #11. 5 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 7#Criteria for musicians and ensembles #11.
Query on "national music charts" 5 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 7#Query on "national music charts"
Specifying what non-trivial means 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 7#Specifying what non-trivial means
Rfc: C4 International concert tour 49 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 7#Rfc: C4 International concert tour
Symphonies 3 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 7#Symphonies
Removal of WP:ATT link 3 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 7#Removal of WP:ATT link
Non-broadcast radio networks 4 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 7#Non-broadcast radio networks
Major labels 82 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 7#Major labels
Amazon MP3 Download frequency list = National Chart? 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 7#Amazon MP3 Download frequency list = National Chart?
Unreleased albums 3 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 7#Unreleased albums
Unreleased Album, Demos, Mixtapes ETC.. 44 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 7#Unreleased Album, Demos, Mixtapes ETC..
Dispute 3 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 7#Dispute
Tours? 23 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 8#Tours?
Template:Notable Concerts 4 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 7#Template:Notable Concerts
Clarification for "unreleased" 7 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 7#Clarification for "unreleased"
Instruction creep in guideline 6 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 7#Instruction creep in guideline
Albums and songs 60 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 7#Albums and songs
Opera Singers 3 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 7#Opera Singers
{{Policycontroversy}}? 3 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 7#{{Policycontroversy}}?
Still no agreement on albums and songs 9 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 7#Still no agreement on albums and songs
Album Notability 30 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 7#Album Notability
More on unreleased albums 14 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 7#More on unreleased albums
Actual single-page discography proposal 31 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 7#Actual single-page discography proposal
Songs Notability 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 7#Songs Notability
Merzbow 3 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 7#Merzbow
Band names 3 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 7#Band names
Individual Notability 14 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 8#Individual Notability
More on "More on unreleased albums" 3 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 8#More on "More on unreleased albums"
Tribute albums 4 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 8#Tribute albums
Track times in album articles? 4 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 8#Track times in album articles?
Question about notability for musicians 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 8#Question about notability for musicians
Caught in a Mosh notability? 9 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 8#Caught in a Mosh notability?
Number of Albums 15 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 8#Number of Albums
Edit warring on singles 7 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 8#Edit warring on singles
The notability of a song? 3 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 8#The notability of a song?
A charted hit on any national music chart - What's a hit? 7 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 8#A charted hit on any national music chart - What's a hit?
Contemporary worship music 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 8#Contemporary worship music
Major Competition 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 8#Major Competition
Criterion 6, Limitations 6 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 8#Criterion 6, Limitations
Are karaoke versions notable? 3 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 8#Are karaoke versions notable?
Mixtapes 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 8#Mixtapes
Is a "single" a "song"? 10 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 8#Is a "single" a "song"?
Asserting Notability 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 8#Asserting Notability
Concern 4 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 8#Concern
Notability of musical singles 14 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 8#Notability of musical singles
Spamming? 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 8#Spamming?
Lists of B-sides and unreleased material. 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 8#Lists of B-sides and unreleased material.
Chart/Notability 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 8#Chart/Notability
Recording versus Song 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 8#Recording versus Song
Supergroups 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 8#Supergroups
Proposed change to the wording. Need consensus. 33 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 8#Proposed change to the wording. Need consensus.
Record labels 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 8#Record labels
Osvaldo Barrios 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 8#Osvaldo Barrios
I have an idea!!!!! 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 8#I have an idea!!!!!
Strengthen wording? 6 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 8#Strengthen wording?
Emo as a B Class Article 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 8#Emo as a B Class Article
Reissue label 4 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 8#Reissue label
Singles 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 8#Singles
RFC: Clarifying "notable single" 12 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 8#RFC: Clarifying "notable single"
Clarification 15 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 9#Clarification
Question about notability of a composition. 7 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 9#Question about notability of a composition.
Does this really constitute undue weight? 5 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 9#Does this really constitute undue weight?
Criterion 6 for musicians and ensembles 8 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 9#Criterion 6 for musicians and ensembles
Notability of Independent Musicians & Ensaumbles 7 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 9#Notability of Independent Musicians & Ensaumbles
Song stubs 5 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 9#Song stubs
Notability of soundtracks 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 9#Notability of soundtracks
The Iron Maidens 4 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 9#The Iron Maidens
Albums (and bands that make them) from non-English speaking countries - How to 4 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 9#Albums (and bands that make them) from non-English speaking countries - How to
Humorous page relating to this 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 9#Humorous page relating to this
Manual of Style 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 9#Manual of Style
"fill in" musicians 3 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 9#"fill in" musicians
WP:Music#Criteria for musicians and ensembles #12 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 9#WP:Music#Criteria for musicians and ensembles #12
Criteria for musicians and ensembles - proposed addition/change discussion 26 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 9#Criteria for musicians and ensembles - proposed addition/change discussion
Criterion 4 5 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 9#Criterion 4
Record labels and speedies 8 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 9#Record labels and speedies
Reign (album) 5 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 9#Reign (album)
Notability and {{future single}} tag 6 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 9#Notability and {{future single}} tag
Musical Key in Notable Songs 8 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 9#Musical Key in Notable Songs
Suitability of individual charts 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 9#Suitability of individual charts
Proposal for new notability criterion 3 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 9#Proposal for new notability criterion
Notability criterion with respect to songs is being completely ignored re: the Beatles 10 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 9#Notability criterion with respect to songs is being completely ignored re: the Beatles
The Future Of Wikipedia 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 10#The Future Of Wikipedia
Sampling as indicia of notability 12 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 10#Sampling as indicia of notability
Removing or changing criteria #5 5 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 10#Removing or changing criteria #5
Work of media that is notable. 8 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 10#Work of media that is notable.
We7 3 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 10#We7
Question about WP:MUSICBIO 4 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 10#Question about WP:MUSICBIO
Circular notability argument? 13 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 10#Circular notability argument?
"Importance" of record label Sudden Death Records 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 10#"Importance" of record label Sudden Death Records
Mixtape Discrimination 3 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 10#Mixtape Discrimination
Criterion 6 for musicians and ensembles 68 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 10#Criterion 6 for musicians and ensembles
GMA Dove Award 7 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 10#GMA Dove Award
The Purpose and Potential of Wikipedia: 7 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 11#The Purpose and Potential of Wikipedia:
Francisco Mora Catlett 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 10#Francisco Mora Catlett
Transitive Notability 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 10#Transitive Notability
Hypothetical question concerning circular notability 5 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 10#Hypothetical question concerning circular notability
Mixx 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 11#Mixx
Local sources 3 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 11#Local sources
Record Labels 7 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 11#Record Labels
Joe Brooks AfD no consensus, why's 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 11#Joe Brooks AfD no consensus, why's
Tightening up Musician/Ensemble Criteria Loopholes 50 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 11#Tightening up Musician/Ensemble Criteria Loopholes
Endorsements 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 11#Endorsements
Psycho T. Records 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 11#Psycho T. Records
Interviews 5 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 11#Interviews
The Validity of Youtube as a Source of Notability 10 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 11#The Validity of Youtube as a Source of Notability
record labels 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 11#record labels 2
Adding deletion discussion notices to prod pages 4 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 11#Adding deletion discussion notices to prod pages
Esser 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 11#Esser
Which tag? 3 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 11#Which tag?
Interviews 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 11#Interviews 2
Question re a song's notability 4 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 11#Question re a song's notability
Open Grave Records 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 11#Open Grave Records
Notability of labels 8 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 11#Notability of labels
Notability for singles/songs 7 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 11#Notability for singles/songs
The criterion 5 loophole again 10 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 11#The criterion 5 loophole again
Classical music 5 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 11#Classical music
Michig revert 10 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 11#Michig revert
C6 Again 59 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 11#C6 Again
CD Singles 10 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 11#CD Singles
Songs 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 11#Songs
Laruso 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 11#Laruso
Meaning of criteria #6 7 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 12#Meaning of criteria #6
ZoneMusicReporter as Criteria 2 3 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 12#ZoneMusicReporter as Criteria 2
C10 - compilation albums 17 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 12#C10 - compilation albums
Not famous enough for Wikki 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 12#Not famous enough for Wikki
Major Awards 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 12#Major Awards
Question RE: tours 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 12#Question RE: tours
Propose a listing of 'important indie labels' 6 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 12#Propose a listing of 'important indie labels'
Musicals 6 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 12#Musicals
Reviews / Review Sites 4 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 12#Reviews / Review Sites
Record labels 3 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 12#Record labels
Deletion 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 12#Deletion
Notability criteria for songs 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 12#Notability criteria for songs
Clarify "National Chart" 13 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 12#Clarify "National Chart"
Tours 4 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 12#Tours
Removal of reviews from the album infobox 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 12#Removal of reviews from the album infobox
MOS discussion regarding Lady Gaga's name 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 12#MOS discussion regarding Lady Gaga's name
Nutshell 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 12#Nutshell
Gods Child albums 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 12#Gods Child albums
WP:BAND criteria 7 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 12#WP:BAND criteria
Are GMA awards considered "major" awards? 7 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 12#Are GMA awards considered "major" awards?
RS? 3 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 12#RS?
Criteria for musicians and ensembles 9 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 12#Criteria for musicians and ensembles
Composers and performers outside mass media traditions 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 12#Composers and performers outside mass media traditions
Don't stick stickers 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 12#Don't stick stickers
Ongoing discussion of a proposed merge per WP:NSONGS 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 12#Ongoing discussion of a proposed merge per WP:NSONGS
Complete crap 4 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 12#Complete crap
Re-created songs? 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 12#Re-created songs?
WP:NSONGS should include singles 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 12#WP:NSONGS should include singles
Proposal to change notability criteria for singles 26 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 12#Proposal to change notability criteria for singles
Interaction of this guideline with general WP:Notability guidline 10 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 12#Interaction of this guideline with general WP:Notability guidline
P.B.G(PRETTY BOY GANG) 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 12#P.B.G(PRETTY BOY GANG)
Pages about artists to be created 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 12#Pages about artists to be created
DFTBA Records as a "more important indie label"? 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 12#DFTBA Records as a "more important indie label"?
Demos in Albums, singles and songs section 21 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 12#Demos in Albums, singles and songs section
Demo album debate 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 12#Demo album debate
Subtle change to WP:NALBUMS related to above 11 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 12#Subtle change to WP:NALBUMS related to above
Criteria for musicians and ensembles 3 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 12#Criteria for musicians and ensembles 2
URGENT: Clarification and renewel of notability policy 27 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 12#URGENT: Clarification and renewel of notability policy
Userspace rework of this Guideline 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 13#Userspace rework of this Guideline
Drum and bass / Jungle music pages 3 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 13#Drum and bass / Jungle music pages
Deletion of bands is the dumbest thing you could do 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 13#Deletion of bands is the dumbest thing you could do
Dom & Roland versus Dom and Roland 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 13#Dom & Roland versus Dom and Roland
Every Pink Floyd song has an article? 4 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 13#Every Pink Floyd song has an article?
"..performed independently by several notable artists ..." 13 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 13#"..performed independently by several notable artists ..."
Oh, this new modern age! 6 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 13#Oh, this new modern age!
Notability of singles 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 13#Notability of singles
Notability of Derek Murawski 4 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 13#Notability of Derek Murawski
Notability is showing its ugly head again. 9 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 13#Notability is showing its ugly head again.
Recording studio 4 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 13#Recording studio
Record label notability standards 3 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 13#Record label notability standards
"Members of notable bands are redirected" -- developed in error 10 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 13#"Members of notable bands are redirected" -- developed in error
"The Flamin' Oh's" 3 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 13#"The Flamin' Oh's"
Live performance 5 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 13#Live performance
Albums, singles and songs proposal 6 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 13#Albums, singles and songs proposal
Is there a specific definition of "a country's national music chart?" 3 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 13#Is there a specific definition of "a country's national music chart?"
Single or album 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 13#Single or album
Session musicians 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 13#Session musicians
allmusic 4 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 13#allmusic
Ted Christopher 4 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 13#Ted Christopher
Support for a new CSD category for yet-to-be-released singles? 14 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 13#Support for a new CSD category for yet-to-be-released singles?
Quick question regarding notability 3 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 13#Quick question regarding notability
Album Notability Standards 15 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 13#Album Notability Standards
Important discussion about Mixtapes! 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 13#Important discussion about Mixtapes!
Point 2 7 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 13#Point 2
Interview 4 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 13#Interview
Professional symphony orchestras 5 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 13#Professional symphony orchestras
Newport (Ymerodraeth State of Mind) 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 13#Newport (Ymerodraeth State of Mind)
The main criterion barely parses 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 13#The main criterion barely parses
C6: Group with notable members; person in notable bands 15 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 13#C6: Group with notable members; person in notable bands
Music criticism 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 13#Music criticism
Record Labels 3 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 13#Record Labels
Consistency 4 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 13#Consistency
Michael Lockwood (guitarist) 9 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 13#Michael Lockwood (guitarist)
Song notability 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 13#Song notability
Nomination for deletion of Template:Polar Music Prize 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 13#Nomination for deletion of Template:Polar Music Prize
Label criteria 5 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 13#Label criteria
Non-criteria for musicians and ensembles? 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 13#Non-criteria for musicians and ensembles?
Criteria for indie record labels? 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 13#Criteria for indie record labels?
Chart notability 9 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 13#Chart notability
Question 3 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 13#Question
Album reviews 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 13#Album reviews
Does this page meet criteria? 7 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 13#Does this page meet criteria?
Does a song... 7 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 13#Does a song...
Concert tours 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 13#Concert tours
Criterion 5 of WP:BAND, elecronic music bias 4 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 13#Criterion 5 of WP:BAND, elecronic music bias
Performer Notability 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 14#Performer Notability
RFC nearing end 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 14#RFC nearing end
Notability of specific albums 8 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 14#Notability of specific albums
Requiring feature articles to establish notability 8 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 14#Requiring feature articles to establish notability
sales of albums by digital download 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 14#sales of albums by digital download
Gold record can mean 3,000 copies to 1 million copies 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 14#Gold record can mean 3,000 copies to 1 million copies
Notability of singles 3 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 14#Notability of singles
Covers 3 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 14#Covers
Substantive edits versus refinement and specification 3 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 14#Substantive edits versus refinement and specification
Number 6 9 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 14#Number 6
May vs. May (not will) 9 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 14#May vs. May (not will)
Traditional songs Notability: tweaking the verbiage 4 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 14#Traditional songs Notability: tweaking the verbiage
A discussion concerning Sputnik Music 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 14#A discussion concerning Sputnik Music
Hip Hop Subgenre 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 14#Hip Hop Subgenre
Band Tryad got deleted because it doesn't has these criterias? 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 14#Band Tryad got deleted because it doesn't has these criterias?
Query 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 14#Query
Delete "Every album by notable musician gets own article" guideline? 69 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 14#Delete "Every album by notable musician gets own article" guideline?
RfC "Every album by notable musician gets own article" guideline? 125 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 14#RfC "Every album by notable musician gets own article" guideline?
Should Criteria 11 include music television stations? 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 15#Should Criteria 11 include music television stations?
The Music Network 3 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 15#The Music Network
Writing a page Wiki page for Spanish/Uk based band The Breakdowns 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 15#Writing a page Wiki page for Spanish/Uk based band The Breakdowns
What's the deal with charting? 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 15#What's the deal with charting?
RFC : Notability of foreign language works 11 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 15#RFC : Notability of foreign language works
Contestants in American Idol, and its progeny 20 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 15#Contestants in American Idol, and its progeny
Criterion #9 of WP:MUSICBIO 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 15#Criterion #9 of WP:MUSICBIO
Names 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 15#Names
Proposed modification to Others category 7 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 15#Proposed modification to Others category
Roxx Gang 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 15#Roxx Gang
inherent notability via chart 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 15#inherent notability via chart
Chart notability 6 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 15#Chart notability
One-off group that won Eurovision Song Contest 20 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 15#One-off group that won Eurovision Song Contest
Working towards some notability guidelines for record labels? 10 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 15#Working towards some notability guidelines for record labels?
Remove mixtapes from 'Unreleased material' section? 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 15#Remove mixtapes from 'Unreleased material' section?
Clarifying notability for contestant artists 13 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 15#Clarifying notability for contestant artists
St. Jimmy 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 15#St. Jimmy
Discussion about the treatment of EPs in chronologies 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 15#Discussion about the treatment of EPs in chronologies
Songs v. Singles 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 15#Songs v. Singles
Clarify what "composition" means 7 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 15#Clarify what "composition" means
Notability of tours 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 15#Notability of tours
RFC about iTunes as a source for release histories 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 15#RFC about iTunes as a source for release histories
Merging of non-notable albums 47 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 15#Merging of non-notable albums
NSONG 71 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 15#NSONG
Charts 51 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 16#Charts
"Major" and discrimination against independent publishing 5 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 16#"Major" and discrimination against independent publishing
Wikipedia:Miscellany for deletion/Wikipedia:WikiProject Songs Cover-versions and multiple-renditions 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 16#Wikipedia:Miscellany for deletion/Wikipedia:WikiProject Songs Cover-versions and multiple-renditions
WP:SONGCOVER 15 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 16#WP:SONGCOVER
Merging of non-notable albums redux 19 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 16#Merging of non-notable albums redux
RfC: Proposal for rewording NSONG 34 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 16#RfC: Proposal for rewording NSONG
What is the purpose of Wikipedia? 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 16#What is the purpose of Wikipedia?
Notability of music; not songs, records, singers, bands, concert tours ... 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 16#Notability of music; not songs, records, singers, bands, concert tours ...
notable? 3 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 16#notable?
Clarification of coverage audience 4 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 16#Clarification of coverage audience
Proposal 7 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 16#Proposal
Major award 3 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 16#Major award
WP:MUSICBIO and "national music chart" 3 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 16#WP:MUSICBIO and "national music chart"
13th criterion for musicians 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 16#13th criterion for musicians
How to write a non-notable compilation 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 16#How to write a non-notable compilation
Boldly changing criterion wording 3 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 16#Boldly changing criterion wording
Point #5 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 16#Point #5
Clarification about criteria 1 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 16#Clarification about criteria 1
'Others' 5 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 16#'Others'
Virginia US artist 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 16#Virginia US artist
question on article submission 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 16#question on article submission
Albums with collaberations 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 16#Albums with collaberations
BAND and internet radio 3 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 16#BAND and internet radio
Ignoring NSONG 5 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 16#Ignoring NSONG
Need a table of dictionaries and encyclopedias 4 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 16#Need a table of dictionaries and encyclopedias
Pakistan Idol 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 16#Pakistan Idol
Deletion Discussion for Italian occult psychedelia 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 16#Deletion Discussion for Italian occult psychedelia
NSONG clarification 8 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 17#NSONG clarification
Wording proposal for "WP:NALBUMS" 6 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 17#Wording proposal for "WP:NALBUMS"
Wording proposal for WP:NSONGS 3 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 17#Wording proposal for WP:NSONGS
AfD: Fescal 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 16#AfD: Fescal
About NMUSICBIO 7 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 17#About NMUSICBIO
C2 criterion 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 17#C2 criterion
Legal vacuum 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 17#Legal vacuum
Weight of the songwriter's opinion of his own song? 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 17#Weight of the songwriter's opinion of his own song?
Definition of "Placed" 11 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 17#Definition of "Placed"
Albums are sub-topics 10 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 17#Albums are sub-topics
Notability of allmusic review 6 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 17#Notability of allmusic review
A New Editor Needs Some Help 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 17#A New Editor Needs Some Help
Record Label section request 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 17#Record Label section request
Famousbirthdays.com 3 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 17#Famousbirthdays.com
Why so much emphasis on notability? 20 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 17#Why so much emphasis on notability?
IMVDb notable or not? 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 17#IMVDb notable or not?
Caves of Glass notable? 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 17#Caves of Glass notable?
Remixes 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 17#Remixes
Certification or chart success? A clear way to establish notability is needed. 37 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 17#Certification or chart success? A clear way to establish notability is needed.
Wikipedia resources to help establish notability (or to buy time to do so) 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 17#Wikipedia resources to help establish notability (or to buy time to do so)
help with Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chris Wardman 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 17#help with Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chris Wardman
On the presumption of notability and SNG criteria 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 17#On the presumption of notability and SNG criteria
Question regarding notability of scene specific indie music 5 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 17#Question regarding notability of scene specific indie music
Proposed inclusion of Beatport, for genre-specific notability guidelines 47 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 18#Proposed inclusion of Beatport, for genre-specific notability guidelines
did the criteria for albums change? 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 18#did the criteria for albums change?
India 5 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 18#India
The "Chinese Democracy" exception 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 18#The "Chinese Democracy" exception
20 Rihanna songs nominated for deletion 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 18#20 Rihanna songs nominated for deletion
WP:NSONG needs re-evaluating and re-wording 48 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 18#WP:NSONG needs re-evaluating and re-wording
What constitutes a "national" chart 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 18#What constitutes a "national" chart
Work Song 5 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 18#Work Song
Do all of these guidelines imply GNG or are they stand-alone? 21 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 18#Do all of these guidelines imply GNG or are they stand-alone?
Question 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 18#Question
Notability standard for record labels 9 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 18#Notability standard for record labels
iTunes 3 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 18#iTunes
WP:NTOUR needs clarification about concert reviews 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 18#WP:NTOUR needs clarification about concert reviews
Wiki should develop a set of notability guidelines for special interest music of past and antique eras 6 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 18#Wiki should develop a set of notability guidelines for special interest music of past and antique eras
Notability for non-Western Music 4 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 18#Notability for non-Western Music
Genre-specific charts 7 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 18#Genre-specific charts
Proposal to remove "Has won or placed in a major music competition." from "from Criteria for musicians and ensembles" 65 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 19#Proposal to remove "Has won or placed in a major music competition." from "from Criteria for musicians and ensembles"
Number of criteria to pass 3 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 18#Number of criteria to pass
A close call on draft article 5 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 18#A close call on draft article
# 189? 7 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 18## 189?
Concerts in the Park (Sacramento) 4 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 18#Concerts in the Park (Sacramento)
Yoga (Janelle Monáe song) article 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 18#Yoga (Janelle Monáe song) article
Ambiguity: "A few years" 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 19#Ambiguity: "A few years"
SPA issue 7 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 19#SPA issue
Clarification request on "national rotation" criterion 8 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 19#Clarification request on "national rotation" criterion
Remove "charting" from WP:NSONG? 3 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 19#Remove "charting" from WP:NSONG?
Single charting criterion 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 19#Single charting criterion
Another suggested change 14 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 19#Another suggested change
Question about WP:NALBUMS 3 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 19#Question about WP:NALBUMS
Duplication of meaning in "criteria for musicians and ensembles" #1 9 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 19#Duplication of meaning in "criteria for musicians and ensembles" #1
Request to define "album" for criteria 4 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 19#Request to define "album" for criteria
Popular bands only 4 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 19#Popular bands only
Indie music at AfC 9 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 19#Indie music at AfC
Songwriters 3 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 19#Songwriters
Bias against notability of artists from early recordings 22 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 19#Bias against notability of artists from early recordings
Strange sentence in NSONGS 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 19#Strange sentence in NSONGS
Music awards from radio stations / online magazines 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 19#Music awards from radio stations / online magazines
Cover of a song used in an advertising campaign 4 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 19#Cover of a song used in an advertising campaign
Three NSONGS changes proposed. 47 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 20#Three NSONGS changes proposed.
My recent removal 4 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 20#My recent removal
Recordings vs Songs 10 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 20#Recordings vs Songs
Modifications to conform with WP:GNG 23 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 20#Modifications to conform with WP:GNG
Sunflower Bean 3 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 20#Sunflower Bean
Notability: Others 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 20#Notability: Others
Question about notability 7 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 20#Question about notability
Notability of pre-1923 songs 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 20#Notability of pre-1923 songs
RFC on Discogs.com 27 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 20#RFC on Discogs.com
RFC: "Songs written by" categories 6 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 20#RFC: "Songs written by" categories
Peter Gutteridge problem 3 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 20#Peter Gutteridge problem
Nigerian artists and music 4 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 20#Nigerian artists and music
Notability? 3 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 20#Notability?
Featured artists or only main artists? 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 20#Featured artists or only main artists?
So musicians can inherit notability from their more famous collegues? 7 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 20#So musicians can inherit notability from their more famous collegues?
NSONGS edited for clarity 10 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 20#NSONGS edited for clarity
Nomination of Craig Gill at AfD 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 20#Nomination of Craig Gill at AfD
Marcellino foster 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 20#Marcellino foster
Members of only one notable band - slight reword proposal 7 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 21#Members of only one notable band - slight reword proposal
Question about "featuring" musician 4 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 20#Question about "featuring" musician
the blizzard (song) 3 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 20#the blizzard (song)
YouTube & notability 41 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 20#YouTube & notability
Producers 63 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 21#Producers
GNG and subject-specific notability guidelines 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 21#GNG and subject-specific notability guidelines
Question about criteria #10 and #7 25 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 21#Question about criteria #10 and #7
Proposed changes in the notability for music guideline 6 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 21#Proposed changes in the notability for music guideline
Demo albums by artists that later became notable 4 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 21#Demo albums by artists that later became notable
Music Releases as Sources 4 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 21#Music Releases as Sources
Only official mainstream being Wiki-worthy? 5 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 21#Only official mainstream being Wiki-worthy?
Notability when most coverage of a person is for non-musical activity 3 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 21#Notability when most coverage of a person is for non-musical activity
Change word major to notable 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 21#Change word major to notable
Request for comment on "Top Down Approach to Notability" 27 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 21#Request for comment on "Top Down Approach to Notability"
Proposed criteria for record labels 9 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 21#Proposed criteria for record labels
Billboard 28 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 22#Billboard
Top 10 singles 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 21#Top 10 singles
Classical Music 4 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 21#Classical Music
Criteria 2: Has had a single or album on any country's national music chart. 9 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 22#Criteria 2: Has had a single or album on any country's national music chart.
Nomination for major award? 7 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 22#Nomination for major award?
Tour criteria 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 21#Tour criteria
RFC: Notability of some compilation albums 25 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 22#RFC: Notability of some compilation albums
Non-notable concert tours 3 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 22#Non-notable concert tours
Does an engineer on a Grammy-winning record reach the notability requirements if that's his only award? 25 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 22#Does an engineer on a Grammy-winning record reach the notability requirements if that's his only award?
Individual notability of reality series finalists 8 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 22#Individual notability of reality series finalists
Is a top ten song automatically notable? 3 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 22#Is a top ten song automatically notable?
@Anyone: Question about whether or not this person satisfies the notability criteria (specifically, WP:MUSICBIO criterion 1) 9 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 22#@Anyone: Question about whether or not this person satisfies the notability criteria (specifically, WP:MUSICBIO criterion 1)
Concert tour AfDs 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 22#Concert tour AfDs
Bubbling Under means notable? 4 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 22#Bubbling Under means notable?
Is The APX notable? 4 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 22#Is The APX notable?
Notability guidelines for composers... 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 22#Notability guidelines for composers...
Miss Krystle 3 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 22#Miss Krystle
Greatest Hits 5 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 22#Greatest Hits
WP:BAND item 7 3 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 22#WP:BAND item 7
Album 3 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 22#Album
WP:NSONG AfDs 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 22#WP:NSONG AfDs
RfC about independent sources for academic biographies 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 22#RfC about independent sources for academic biographies
Shapes (band) 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 22#Shapes (band)
Reviewed album makes an artist notable? 8 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 22#Reviewed album makes an artist notable?
Band that has had three songs on two different major network TV shows? 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 22#Band that has had three songs on two different major network TV shows?
Proposal to permanently remove hatnote to Wikipedia:WikiProject Classical music/Guidelines 8 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 22#Proposal to permanently remove hatnote to Wikipedia:WikiProject Classical music/Guidelines
The Classical Musician Notability Question 12 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 22#The Classical Musician Notability Question
Same intro 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 22#Same intro
Local coverage for bands? 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 22#Local coverage for bands?
Are lists of performances a thing? 4 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 22#Are lists of performances a thing?
Discussion 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 22#Discussion 4
Charts-related lists in song and album article "See also" sections 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 22#Charts-related lists in song and album article "See also" sections
MusicBrainz is a user-generated database? 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 22#MusicBrainz is a user-generated database?
Internet charts - Is it time for us to change guideline 2? 8 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 22#Internet charts - Is it time for us to change guideline 2?
Tracklisting albums. To merge or not 4 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 22#Tracklisting albums. To merge or not
WP:NMUSICIAN #6 scope clarification 4 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 22#WP:NMUSICIAN #6 scope clarification
SNGs and GNG 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 22#SNGs and GNG
Musicians who committed suicide categories at CfD 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 22#Musicians who committed suicide categories at CfD
Notability of cover versions 4 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 22#Notability of cover versions
Individual members, reality television performers 8 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 23#Individual members, reality television performers
Active AfD discussions 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 22#Active AfD discussions
Question 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 23#Question
MUSICBIO vs GNG 16 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 23#MUSICBIO vs GNG
Question about a jazz drummer named Hugh Elliott 3 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 23#Question about a jazz drummer named Hugh Elliott
Notability of albums - at what time is an album notable? 6 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 23#Notability of albums - at what time is an album notable?
Best websites to check "certified gold", "national music chart", "Grammy", etc. 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 23#Best websites to check "certified gold", "national music chart", "Grammy", etc.
List of live performances 32 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 23#List of live performances
Sound designers covered under NMUSICBIO? 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 23#Sound designers covered under NMUSICBIO?
Question: If a musician was decorated (precisely with the Grand Cross of the Order of May 2 - Madrid), could he have a page? 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 23#Question: If a musician was decorated (precisely with the Grand Cross of the Order of May 2 - Madrid), could he have a page?
WP:NSONG 5 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 23#WP:NSONG
Discographies vs. list of articles 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 23#Discographies vs. list of articles
Entertainer page 3 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 23#Entertainer page
Album with Cult following 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 23#Album with Cult following
Which standard applies to Singles? 5 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 23#Which standard applies to Singles?
Recent addition 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 23#Recent addition
Do we have a notability policy guideline for music producers on albums? 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 23#Do we have a notability policy guideline for music producers on albums?
Concert set lists 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 23#Concert set lists
Really, a cover can never have an independent article? 20 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 23#Really, a cover can never have an independent article?
"placed in rotation" 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 23#"placed in rotation"
Streaming statistics? 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 23#Streaming statistics?
English versus British 8 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 23#English versus British
WP:NSONG 15 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 23#WP:NSONG 2
Pre-LP era acts and their notability 3 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 23#Pre-LP era acts and their notability
Local musicians 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 23#Local musicians
Suggestion for guideline 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 23#Suggestion for guideline
FUTUREALBUMS wording 16 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 23#FUTUREALBUMS wording
Acceptable sources for discography entries 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 23#Acceptable sources for discography entries
Notability of Music Awards 4 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 23#Notability of Music Awards
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Aguilera Tour 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 23#Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Aguilera Tour
Eurovision 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 23#Eurovision
Application of NMUSIC vs NCORP for recording labels and recording studios 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 23#Application of NMUSIC vs NCORP for recording labels and recording studios
21st century update? 9 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 23#21st century update?
Content dispute 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 23#Content dispute
Compositions: no criteria set for musical compositions 4 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 23#Compositions: no criteria set for musical compositions
Notable covers are eligible for standalone articles, provided that the article on the cover can be reasonably-detailed based on facts independent of the original. 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 23#Notable covers are eligible for standalone articles, provided that the article on the cover can be reasonably-detailed based on facts independent of the original.
N:BAND #5 concerns 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 23#N:BAND #5 concerns
Does UK "Classical Artist Albums Chart number ones" make notable? 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 23#Does UK "Classical Artist Albums Chart number ones" make notable?
Suggestion for a new page about an English band 6 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 23#Suggestion for a new page about an English band
WP:REALITYSINGER 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 23#WP:REALITYSINGER
Clarity needed for criterion #11 with respect to internet radio 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 23#Clarity needed for criterion #11 with respect to internet radio
Major music award 3 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 23#Major music award
New criterion or modification to #6? 7 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 23#New criterion or modification to #6?
For the record 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 23#For the record
Grammy? 5 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)/Archive 23#Grammy?
Notable bands bar too high 6 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)#Notable bands bar too high
template message 2 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)#template message
Notification of discussion 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)#Notification of discussion
An extremely short article referencing a closed Billboard rating 8 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)#An extremely short article referencing a closed Billboard rating
Survival Records 1 Wikipedia talk:Notability (music)#Survival Records

Start a discussion