| Discussion Topic |
Replies (estimated) |
Archive Link
|
| Thoughts on Inclusion of Professors |
23 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 1#Thoughts on Inclusion of Professors
|
| Professors ain't professors |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 1#Professors ain't professors
|
| Internal criteria (let Academia decide who is notable) |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 1#Internal criteria (let Academia decide who is notable)
|
| professorial publishing not inherently notable |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 1#professorial publishing not inherently notable
|
| Proposal by Tony Sidaway |
14 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 1#Proposal by Tony Sidaway
|
| Precedents |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 1#Precedents
|
| Full professors and notability |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 1#Full professors and notability
|
| Yet another proposal |
15 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 1#Yet another proposal
|
| A Pragmatic Suggestion |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 1#A Pragmatic Suggestion
|
| Rough Guidelines |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 1#Rough Guidelines
|
| New version |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 1#New version
|
| A few points |
12 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 1#A few points
|
| Recognize areas of expertise |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 1#Recognize areas of expertise
|
| The porn star standard |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 1#The porn star standard
|
| Too tough |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 1#Too tough
|
| Peer Review |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 1#Peer Review
|
| Redirects for quasi-notable children and students of notable academics |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 1#Redirects for quasi-notable children and students of notable academics
|
| failure to meet any of the criteria |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 1#failure to meet any of the criteria
|
| Common arguments |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 1#Common arguments
|
| Alternate proposal for notability |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 1#Alternate proposal for notability
|
| WP:PROFTEST |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 1#WP:PROFTEST
|
| Instruction creep |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 1#Instruction creep
|
| India and other developing countries |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 1#India and other developing countries
|
| This is confusing, unecessary and a bad case of instruction creep |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 1#This is confusing, unecessary and a bad case of instruction creep
|
| Survey |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 1#Survey
|
| Please! No More RuleCruft! |
43 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 1#Please! No More RuleCruft!
|
| JSTOR test? |
12 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 1#JSTOR test?
|
| One problem with non-notable people |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 1#One problem with non-notable people
|
| "High quality academic work" |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 1#"High quality academic work"
|
| New Point System Proposal |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 1#New Point System Proposal
|
| Journals |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 1#Journals
|
| Academic leadership? |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 1#Academic leadership?
|
| Exam Books |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 1#Exam Books
|
| Citations |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 1#Citations
|
| Public Figures |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 1#Public Figures
|
| Extra examples |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 1#Extra examples
|
| Thoughts |
10 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 1#Thoughts
|
| Test case |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 1#Test case
|
| Changed Criteria to discuss |
15 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 1#Changed Criteria to discuss
|
| simple criterion |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 1#simple criterion
|
| Idiotic proposal |
22 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 1#Idiotic proposal
|
| What about administrators? |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 1#What about administrators?
|
| Subject difference in standards |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 1#Subject difference in standards
|
| test case for the prof test |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 1#test case for the prof test
|
| inactive? |
11 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 1#inactive?
|
| Example articles |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 1#Example articles
|
| academic journals? |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 1#academic journals?
|
| Quick vote |
12 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 1#Quick vote
|
| proposed => accepted |
10 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 1#proposed => accepted
|
| Why this is not instruction creep and should be a guideline |
13 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 1#Why this is not instruction creep and should be a guideline
|
| Merging logistics |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 1#Merging logistics
|
| Too restrictive? Too permissive? |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 1#Too restrictive? Too permissive?
|
| Merge vs. don't |
10 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 1#Merge vs. don't
|
| From the edit log |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 1#From the edit log
|
| Definition of terms? |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 1#Definition of terms?
|
| Need to change the IncGuide template |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 1#Need to change the IncGuide template
|
| General notability guideline template |
48 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 2#General notability guideline template
|
| The discussion so far |
16 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 2#The discussion so far
|
| Template:pnc nominated for deletion |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 2#Template:pnc nominated for deletion
|
| Proposed policy change at Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 2#Proposed policy change at Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons
|
| More notable than Average gone from WP:BIO? |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 2#More notable than Average gone from WP:BIO?
|
| Heads of Oxbridge colleges |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 2#Heads of Oxbridge colleges
|
| It's crowded in here |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 2#It's crowded in here
|
| Prods |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 2#Prods
|
| Above average? |
16 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 2#Above average?
|
| Guidelines are not overly clear |
26 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 2#Guidelines are not overly clear
|
| Proposal |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 2#Proposal
|
| h-index |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 2#h-index
|
| notability criteria for scholars/scientists |
11 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 2#notability criteria for scholars/scientists
|
| Merge to Wikipedia:Notability WP:BIO |
163 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 3#Merge to Wikipedia:Notability WP:BIO
|
| The role of WP:PROF with respect to WP:N |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 4#The role of WP:PROF with respect to WP:N
|
| Merge tag |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 4#Merge tag
|
| WP:FLAG-SCL |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 4#WP:FLAG-SCL
|
| Time to reconsider the guidelines |
22 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 4#Time to reconsider the guidelines
|
| Proposed revisions of the guideline |
21 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 4#Proposed revisions of the guideline
|
| Over average |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 4#Over average
|
| Festschrift -- criteria? |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 5#Festschrift -- criteria?
|
| WP:PROF revision draft - revisited |
41 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 5#WP:PROF revision draft - revisited
|
| Adding a reminder for a core policy on independent sources |
183 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 11#Adding a reminder for a core policy on independent sources
|
| general discussion |
13 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 5#general discussion
|
| Recent (now resolved) mass A7 deletion of academics |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 5#Recent (now resolved) mass A7 deletion of academics
|
| Proceeding with the replacement? |
15 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 5#Proceeding with the replacement?
|
| Move to proceed with the replacement |
10 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 5#Move to proceed with the replacement
|
| Replaced |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 5#Replaced
|
| Vanity of vanities, all is vanity |
10 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 5#Vanity of vanities, all is vanity
|
| Relation to the general notability guideline |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 6#Relation to the general notability guideline
|
| Essay Rant about H-indexes |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 6#Essay Rant about H-indexes
|
| Books published by leading academic publishing companies |
17 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 6#Books published by leading academic publishing companies
|
| "Independent?" |
14 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 6#"Independent?"
|
| FYI |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 6#FYI
|
| New reference for impact analysis in computer science |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 6#New reference for impact analysis in computer science
|
| My concerns about WP: PROF |
15 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 6#My concerns about WP: PROF
|
| I'm finding this page really helpful. |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 6#I'm finding this page really helpful.
|
| UK use of professor |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 6#UK use of professor
|
| Law school deans (in the U.S.) |
38 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 6#Law school deans (in the U.S.)
|
| Criterion 5: named/personal chair? |
12 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 6#Criterion 5: named/personal chair?
|
| Notability guideline for academic journals |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 6#Notability guideline for academic journals
|
| Presidents/chancellors of smaller schools |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 6#Presidents/chancellors of smaller schools
|
| Presidents of academic societies |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 6#Presidents of academic societies
|
| will these do for notability? |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 6#will these do for notability?
|
| Article of interest |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 6#Article of interest
|
| Membership to Norwegian Academy of Science and Letters and WP:PROF#C3 |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 6#Membership to Norwegian Academy of Science and Letters and WP:PROF#C3
|
| Hooshang Heshmat |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 6#Hooshang Heshmat
|
| Connes on citation counts |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 6#Connes on citation counts
|
| Criteria for becoming a Professor in the UK |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 6#Criteria for becoming a Professor in the UK
|
| h-index |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 6#h-index
|
| RfC Using citation totals in articles on academics |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 6#RfC Using citation totals in articles on academics
|
| Academic society |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 6#Academic society
|
| Fundamentally flawed |
18 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 6#Fundamentally flawed
|
| Cited as an expert in main-stream press |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 6#Cited as an expert in main-stream press
|
| Google scholar |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 6#Google scholar
|
| unclear |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 6#unclear
|
| Criterion 1 and H-index |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 6#Criterion 1 and H-index
|
| Helpful (?) reformatting of criteria |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 6#Helpful (?) reformatting of criteria
|
| WP:AUTH |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 6#WP:AUTH
|
| About routine coverage |
12 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 6#About routine coverage
|
| International Math Olympiad and Criterion 2 |
16 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 6#International Math Olympiad and Criterion 2
|
| Clarification of criterion #6 |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 6#Clarification of criterion #6
|
| Amos Megged |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 6#Amos Megged
|
| "Never use self-published sources" vs praise by established experts in blogs |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 6#"Never use self-published sources" vs praise by established experts in blogs
|
| Another question on Criterion 5 |
35 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 6#Another question on Criterion 5
|
| Citation numbers in regards to notability |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 6#Citation numbers in regards to notability
|
| Proposal to Delete Criterion 5 |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 6#Proposal to Delete Criterion 5
|
| Existence of sources |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 6#Existence of sources
|
| Please see |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 6#Please see
|
| Too strict criteria |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 6#Too strict criteria
|
| Charles V. Hamilton |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 6#Charles V. Hamilton
|
| Plank high |
18 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 6#Plank high
|
| notability question |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 6#notability question
|
| published |
21 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 6#published
|
| How many citations are needed to pass WP:Prof#C1? |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 6#How many citations are needed to pass WP:Prof#C1?
|
| Minor comment about "major" |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 6#Minor comment about "major"
|
| Existence vs publication |
35 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 6#Existence vs publication
|
| Rewrite of notability standard |
11 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 6#Rewrite of notability standard
|
| Proposed changes |
57 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 7#Proposed changes
|
| Logical unfathomability |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 6#Logical unfathomability
|
| General Notes & Caveats |
38 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 7#General Notes & Caveats
|
| Looking at the problem in another way... (Musicologists) |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 7#Looking at the problem in another way... (Musicologists)
|
| Notes to specific criteria: 1 |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 7#Notes to specific criteria: 1
|
| Notability of learned societies with weak coverage |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 7#Notability of learned societies with weak coverage
|
| Does editing a book count like authoring a book for WP:AUTHOR#3? |
17 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 7#Does editing a book count like authoring a book for WP:AUTHOR#3?
|
| UK/USA Professor difference |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 7#UK/USA Professor difference
|
| Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Stanislav George Djorgovski |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 7#Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Stanislav George Djorgovski
|
| Heads up |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 7#Heads up
|
| Establishing criterion 1 |
23 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 7#Establishing criterion 1
|
| IEEE Fellows are notable? |
48 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 7#IEEE Fellows are notable?
|
| Add this to the nutshell section |
10 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 7#Add this to the nutshell section
|
| Proposed addition |
35 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 7#Proposed addition
|
| Academic journals |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 7#Academic journals
|
| Inclusion of Pulitzer Prize for History |
50 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 7#Inclusion of Pulitzer Prize for History
|
| Balancing -- three discussions... |
25 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 7#Balancing -- three discussions...
|
| Three Specific Points on awards |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 7#Three Specific Points on awards
|
| When will consensus finally arrive |
10 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 7#When will consensus finally arrive
|
| A very simple proposal |
22 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 7#A very simple proposal
|
| C6 Clarification (Presidents) |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 7#C6 Clarification (Presidents)
|
| AfDs for two academic awards |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 7#AfDs for two academic awards
|
| PROF qualified main topic articles written as biographies |
19 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 7#PROF qualified main topic articles written as biographies
|
| This guideline in academic research and mainstream media |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 7#This guideline in academic research and mainstream media
|
| Academic Organization notability guideline |
59 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 8#Academic Organization notability guideline
|
| Is a high h-index good enough? |
62 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 8#Is a high h-index good enough?
|
| Discoverers of asteroids and other astronomical bodies |
17 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 8#Discoverers of asteroids and other astronomical bodies
|
| .9 + .9 + .9 = 0 or 1? |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 8#.9 + .9 + .9 = 0 or 1?
|
| interesting article on writing about intellectuals |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 8#interesting article on writing about intellectuals
|
| Is having a honorary degrees enough for WP:N? |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 8#Is having a honorary degrees enough for WP:N?
|
| On the presumption of notability and SNG criteria |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 8#On the presumption of notability and SNG criteria
|
| Notable work done by a non notable person |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 8#Notable work done by a non notable person
|
| Relevant category-renaming discussion |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 8#Relevant category-renaming discussion
|
| RFC on Academic ranks |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 8#RFC on Academic ranks
|
| Request for Comment: paid fellowships as an academic notability criterion |
10 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 8#Request for Comment: paid fellowships as an academic notability criterion
|
| Web of Knowledge free index |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 8#Web of Knowledge free index
|
| Department chairs |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 8#Department chairs
|
| Criterion #3 |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 8#Criterion #3
|
| Named chairs |
12 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 8#Named chairs
|
| Relevant discussion |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 8#Relevant discussion
|
| Further note about GScholar |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 8#Further note about GScholar
|
| Eyes needed on a few articles... |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 8#Eyes needed on a few articles...
|
| Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Norm Houghton (historian) |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 8#Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Norm Houghton (historian)
|
| can an academic meet WP:GNG but fail WP:NACADEMIC? |
10 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 8#can an academic meet WP:GNG but fail WP:NACADEMIC?
|
| Input wanted on a batch of bios |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 8#Input wanted on a batch of bios
|
| Clarifying relationship between WP:PROF and the GNG |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 8#Clarifying relationship between WP:PROF and the GNG
|
| Common outcomes and Festschriften |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 8#Common outcomes and Festschriften
|
| Debates |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 8#Debates
|
| How does Wikipedia define scholar for sources |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 8#How does Wikipedia define scholar for sources
|
| Further on h-index... |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 8#Further on h-index...
|
| What qualifies as a "major academic institution"? |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 8#What qualifies as a "major academic institution"?
|
| Too inclusive? |
31 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 8#Too inclusive?
|
| Suggestion for the illustrations of criterion 8 |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 8#Suggestion for the illustrations of criterion 8
|
| notability of a otherwise undistinguished taxon author |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 8#notability of a otherwise undistinguished taxon author
|
| Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kanwal Ameen |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 8#Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kanwal Ameen
|
| Systemic bias |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 8#Systemic bias
|
| Asking for some other opinions |
35 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 8#Asking for some other opinions
|
| University websites are not proof of notability |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 8#University websites are not proof of notability
|
| Adding to criterion 1 (significant impact) demonstrated by Ph.D. advisees hired by other universities |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 8#Adding to criterion 1 (significant impact) demonstrated by Ph.D. advisees hired by other universities
|
| Academics or administrators? |
41 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 8#Academics or administrators?
|
| Proposal to remove administrators from C6 criterion |
38 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 9#Proposal to remove administrators from C6 criterion
|
| Academics and the GNG |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 9#Academics and the GNG
|
| Use the same language? |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 9#Use the same language?
|
| WP:NOTDIRECTORY, WP:PROMO |
56 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 9#WP:NOTDIRECTORY, WP:PROMO
|
| Young scientist AFD - Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hari Bhimaraju |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 9#Young scientist AFD - Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hari Bhimaraju
|
| Citations for Distinguished Professors |
29 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 9#Citations for Distinguished Professors
|
| Citation metrics |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 9#Citation metrics
|
| Criterion 10: AUTHOR? |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 9#Criterion 10: AUTHOR?
|
| Edwin Ross Williams -- does this subject really warrant an article? |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 9#Edwin Ross Williams -- does this subject really warrant an article?
|
| Content question for professor article |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 9#Content question for professor article
|
| Addition to description of Criteria 1 |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 9#Addition to description of Criteria 1
|
| Modification of the last paragraph in the lead |
155 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 9#Modification of the last paragraph in the lead
|
| Suggestion to avoid CV-like pages |
23 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 10#Suggestion to avoid CV-like pages
|
| Jean Monnet Chair |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 9#Jean Monnet Chair
|
| Suggestion |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 9#Suggestion
|
| Beginnings of an idea |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 9#Beginnings of an idea
|
| Fulbright Scholars? |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 9#Fulbright Scholars?
|
| Related discussion |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 9#Related discussion
|
| Request for comment on an AfD |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 10#Request for comment on an AfD
|
| Peter Hillmen |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 10#Peter Hillmen
|
| RS Question |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 10#RS Question
|
| National Academies of Sciences of other countries |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 10#National Academies of Sciences of other countries
|
| Recent revert |
34 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 10#Recent revert
|
| Scopus and Web of Science |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 10#Scopus and Web of Science
|
| Michael Efroimsky |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 10#Michael Efroimsky
|
| Acting chancellor |
10 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 10#Acting chancellor
|
| Editors here need to know about this |
17 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 10#Editors here need to know about this
|
| Sergiu P. Pașca |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 10#Sergiu P. Pașca
|
| Help with notability for Ann Bowling |
20 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 10#Help with notability for Ann Bowling
|
| Some possible food for thought... |
20 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 10#Some possible food for thought...
|
| Sabine Brunswicker |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 10#Sabine Brunswicker
|
| Royal Society of Canada's College of New Scholars, Artists and Scientists |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 10#Royal Society of Canada's College of New Scholars, Artists and Scientists
|
| Expand criterion 5 to cover any tenured professor at a major institution of higher education and research |
10 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 10#Expand criterion 5 to cover any tenured professor at a major institution of higher education and research
|
| Authored vs. Wrote |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 10#Authored vs. Wrote
|
| Proposal for addition to specific WP:PROF notability criteria |
74 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 10#Proposal for addition to specific WP:PROF notability criteria
|
| Draft:Katrin Meissner (scientist) - query on notability |
10 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 10#Draft:Katrin Meissner (scientist) - query on notability
|
| Draft:Nira Yuval-Davis |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 10#Draft:Nira Yuval-Davis
|
| List for major institutes where being a distinguished prof is criteria for notability |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 10#List for major institutes where being a distinguished prof is criteria for notability
|
| Draft:Christine Mitchell |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 10#Draft:Christine Mitchell
|
| Draft:Quentin Summerfield |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 10#Draft:Quentin Summerfield
|
| MIT Technology Review TR100 |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 10#MIT Technology Review TR100
|
| Michael Zinigrad |
11 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 10#Michael Zinigrad
|
| Notability Criterion 3 and the Indian Academy of Sciences |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 10#Notability Criterion 3 and the Indian Academy of Sciences
|
| Criterion 2: Marquis Who's Who |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 10#Criterion 2: Marquis Who's Who
|
| Confusing structure and vague metrics |
41 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 10#Confusing structure and vague metrics
|
| Notability of taxonomists |
40 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 10#Notability of taxonomists
|
| Law school Deans. Med school Deans. Are they notable? |
17 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 10#Law school Deans. Med school Deans. Are they notable?
|
| equivalent position to distinguished professor outside US |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 10#equivalent position to distinguished professor outside US
|
| Habilitation |
23 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 10#Habilitation
|
| Recent change to verifiability policy |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 10#Recent change to verifiability policy
|
| Fukuoka Prize |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 12#Fukuoka Prize
|
| Criteria 1 recognition of collaborative achievements |
69 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 12#Criteria 1 recognition of collaborative achievements
|
| Revisiting the purpose of NPROF (split from above) |
45 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 11#Revisiting the purpose of NPROF (split from above)
|
| RfC about independent sources for academic notability (withdrawn) |
42 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 11#RfC about independent sources for academic notability (withdrawn)
|
| C9 |
14 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 12#C9
|
| RfC about independent sources for academic notability |
116 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 12#RfC about independent sources for academic notability
|
| Michael Zinigrad |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 12#Michael Zinigrad
|
| Notable academic award |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 12#Notable academic award
|
| How to check if a professor would match the guideline? |
13 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 12#How to check if a professor would match the guideline?
|
| Criteria #5 |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 12#Criteria #5
|
| Feedback on who qualifies as an academic |
16 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 12#Feedback on who qualifies as an academic
|
| Lead copyedits |
16 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 12#Lead copyedits
|
| Recent study: "Who Counts as a Notable Sociologist on Wikipedia?" |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 12#Recent study: "Who Counts as a Notable Sociologist on Wikipedia?"
|
| Move section "General notes" before "Criteria" |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 12#Move section "General notes" before "Criteria"
|
| Proposed edits to General Notes section |
11 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 12#Proposed edits to General Notes section
|
| We should dump criterion 9 |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 12#We should dump criterion 9
|
| Mark Alan Hershkovitz |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 12#Mark Alan Hershkovitz
|
| John Charles Polanyi Prizes |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 12#John Charles Polanyi Prizes
|
| Quick sanity check |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 12#Quick sanity check
|
| Government grants |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 12#Government grants
|
| FGS |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 12#FGS
|
| Editors who have access to The Chronicle of Higher Education |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 12#Editors who have access to The Chronicle of Higher Education
|
| Professors with endowed chairs are automatically notable? Criterion 5 is probably too generous. |
32 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 12#Professors with endowed chairs are automatically notable? Criterion 5 is probably too generous.
|
| American Physiological Society "Living History" subjects |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 12#American Physiological Society "Living History" subjects
|
| What makes for a notable science communicator? |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 12#What makes for a notable science communicator?
|
| Proposed change to criterion 4 (several textbooks) |
37 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 12#Proposed change to criterion 4 (several textbooks)
|
| Tomas Cerny |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 12#Tomas Cerny
|
| Discussion |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 12#Discussion 2
|
| Quantifiable metric for WP:NACADEMIC |
47 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 13#Quantifiable metric for WP:NACADEMIC
|
| We need to relax criteria for academics |
39 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 12#We need to relax criteria for academics
|
| Question: Notability |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 13#Question: Notability
|
| Notability opinion |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 13#Notability opinion
|
| SNG and GNG |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 13#SNG and GNG
|
| Regius Professors |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 13#Regius Professors
|
| Establishing notability through textbooks and handbook articles |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 13#Establishing notability through textbooks and handbook articles
|
| Rhodes scholar |
10 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 13#Rhodes scholar
|
| How strict are the current notability criteria for academics |
38 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 13#How strict are the current notability criteria for academics
|
| University Presidents - Minor? |
16 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 13#University Presidents - Minor?
|
| Massive fail |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 13#Massive fail
|
| Sub-labeling the criteria |
13 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 13#Sub-labeling the criteria
|
| Comparing co-authors citations |
14 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 13#Comparing co-authors citations
|
| Has any AfD nomination resulted in "keep" based ONLY on C1(b)? |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 13#Has any AfD nomination resulted in "keep" based ONLY on C1(b)?
|
| Revisiting some deleted mathematicians |
10 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 13#Revisiting some deleted mathematicians
|
| Possible BIAS against non-university academics? |
19 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 13#Possible BIAS against non-university academics?
|
| Living, vs recently deceased, vs historical |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 13#Living, vs recently deceased, vs historical
|
| Weird case needing input from experienced editors |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 13#Weird case needing input from experienced editors
|
| Interim/Acting University presidents |
10 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 13#Interim/Acting University presidents
|
| What is the justification for NPROF being above/separate to WP:GNG? |
66 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 13#What is the justification for NPROF being above/separate to WP:GNG?
|
| Is it worth revisiting #5 - "Distinguished Professor"? |
26 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 13#Is it worth revisiting #5 - "Distinguished Professor"?
|
| Need someone to help me assess the notability |
12 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 13#Need someone to help me assess the notability
|
| Help me assess notability please |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 13#Help me assess notability please
|
| Notable? |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 13#Notable?
|
| Is this person notable? |
11 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 13#Is this person notable?
|
| Citation metrics |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 13#Citation metrics
|
| Notability of Draft:Kara Federmeier |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 13#Notability of Draft:Kara Federmeier
|
| Draft:Jaap Mansfeld |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 13#Draft:Jaap Mansfeld
|
| interim/acting? |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 13#interim/acting?
|
| Application of BLP1E to academics |
13 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 13#Application of BLP1E to academics
|
| Notability of David M. Nisson |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 13#Notability of David M. Nisson
|
| Academic ranks |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 13#Academic ranks
|
| "The person has held a highest-level elected or appointed administrative post at a major academic institution" |
23 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 14#"The person has held a highest-level elected or appointed administrative post at a major academic institution"
|
| Please check |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 14#Please check
|
| Article creation at scale discussion |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 14#Article creation at scale discussion
|
| Publication lists |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 14#Publication lists
|
| Is it time we reviewed the NPROF criteria? |
82 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 14#Is it time we reviewed the NPROF criteria?
|
| Google Scholar citation count discrepancy, gift authorship, and the case of PIs |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 14#Google Scholar citation count discrepancy, gift authorship, and the case of PIs
|
| Academy of Social Sciences (UK) |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 14#Academy of Social Sciences (UK)
|
| "Drosophila genetics" |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 14#"Drosophila genetics"
|
| Criteria 1a |
23 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 14#Criteria 1a
|
| Early career awards |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 14#Early career awards
|
| Bio-notability of a "rosh yeshiva" |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 14#Bio-notability of a "rosh yeshiva"
|
| Criteria 3 |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 14#Criteria 3
|
| American Academy of Arts & Science for criteria 3 |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 14#American Academy of Arts & Science for criteria 3
|
| Major conference organizer |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 14#Major conference organizer
|
| Citations |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 14#Citations
|
| Discussion re notability of academics at a different location |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 14#Discussion re notability of academics at a different location
|
| Fellowships |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 14#Fellowships
|
| proposal for modification of guidelines |
24 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 14#proposal for modification of guidelines
|
| Acceptable references for facts in professor articles |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 14#Acceptable references for facts in professor articles
|
| Community College Presidents and Interim-Presidents...Notable? |
25 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 14#Community College Presidents and Interim-Presidents...Notable?
|
| Applicability of this guideline to university funding lines rather than to people |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 14#Applicability of this guideline to university funding lines rather than to people
|
| Named chair positions tied to administrator positions |
10 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 14#Named chair positions tied to administrator positions
|
| Wikiacademics |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 14#Wikiacademics
|
| notability of the " professorial chair" endowment |
18 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 14#notability of the " professorial chair" endowment
|
| Criterion 6 Re-Write |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 14#Criterion 6 Re-Write
|
| Carolina Chang (and h-index) |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 14#Carolina Chang (and h-index)
|
| Citation counts becoming less reliable as a marker of academic success |
64 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 15#Citation counts becoming less reliable as a marker of academic success
|
| Deans, vice-presidents, vice-chancellors, etc |
15 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 14#Deans, vice-presidents, vice-chancellors, etc
|
| Question |
13 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 15#Question
|
| Would this academic pass? |
10 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 14#Would this academic pass?
|
| Notable? |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 14#Notable?
|
| Jeff Da Costa |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 15#Jeff Da Costa
|
| Proposed addition in C6 explanation |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 15#Proposed addition in C6 explanation
|
| Proposed deletion of C5 |
41 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)#Proposed deletion of C5
|
| Clarify C8 |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)/Archive 14#Clarify C8
|
| Clarify C8 |
12 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)#Clarify C8
|
| C1,4,7 vs C2,3,5,6,8 |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)#C1,4,7 vs C2,3,5,6,8
|
| Clarify/quantify C1 with regards to Citation Metrics |
15 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)#Clarify/quantify C1 with regards to Citation Metrics
|
| Selected publication section in professor articles |
51 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)#Selected publication section in professor articles
|
| Notability of Mark Kotter |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics)#Notability of Mark Kotter
|
