Wikipedia:Wikipedia Signpost/2008-07-21/SPV
 |
|---|
|
| ||
| Volume 4, Issue 30 | 21 July 2008 | About the Signpost |
|
| ||
| (← Prev) | 2008 archives | (Next →) |
|
| ||
|
| |
| Home | Archives | Newsroom | Tip Line | Shortcut : WP:POST/A |
|
| |
WikiWorld: "Cartoon physics"
- This comic originally appeared on March 12, 2007.
This week's WikiWorld comic uses text from "Cartoon physics" and "Hammerspace". The comic is released under the Creative Commons Attribution ShareAlike 2.5 license for use on Wikipedia and elsewhere.
News and notes
Michael Snow selected as Board Chair
At a Board meeting in Alexandria, prior to the opening of Wikimania 2008, the Board of Trustees formally appointed Ting Chen to the Board to fill the spot of Florence Devouard, who declined to seek re-election. To fill Devouard's spot as Chairperson, meanwhile, the Board unanimously chose Michael Snow for a one-year term as Chair.
Snow, who was born in Germany, currently resides in Seattle, where he practices law. Snow was appointed to the Board in February 2008. He becomes the third Chair in the history of the Foundation, after Jimmy Wales, who served as Chair from the board's inception in 2003 through October 2006, and Devouard.
Chen, meanwhile, is the first Chinese Wikimedian, and the first Wikimedian born in Asia, to serve on the Board. Chen was born in Shanghai, China, but currently lives in Germany, where he works as an IT specialist. He is the 14th person to become a member of the Board.
Two compromised accounts desysopped, blocked
The accounts of inactive administrators Zoe and RickK were desysopped and blocked this week, after the passwords to both accounts were apparently obtained by other users. Kelly Martin alleged on Wikipedia Review that both accounts had the same guessable password, a claim that was apparently proven when another user (purportedly Gmaxwell) logged into both accounts and posted onto the administrators' noticeboard to notify the community of their compromise. The accounts were desysopped almost immediately afterward by Drini, a steward and English Wikipedia administrator.
Briefly
- This week, the three-millionth media file was uploaded to Wikimedia Commons. The milestone file was Image:Haishan-Station.JPG, an image of Haishan Station, a Taipei railway station.
- The Hungarian Wikipedia has reached 100,000 articles.
- The Russian Wikipedia has reached 300,000 articles.
- The Danish Wikipedia has reached 90,000 articles.
- The Persian Wikipedia has reached 40,000 articles.
- The Czech Wikisource has reached 5,000 pages.
- The Romanian Wiktionary has reached 15,000 articles.
- The Icelandic Wiktionary has reached 14,000 entries.
- The Esperanto Wikipedia has reached 6,000 users.
Dispatches: History of the featured article process
The first process of recognizing quality articles on the English Wikipedia was spearheaded by now-retired editor Bmills. Under his proposal, users were encouraged to list articles they believed to be of high quality at Wikipedia:Brilliant Prose. In June 2003, Eloquence proposed that the system be modified to be more like the one that had been developed on the German Wikipedia. In the new consensus-gathering process, users could still nominate any article for Brilliant Prose status, although self-nominations were required to be seconded. If no objections were registered within a week, the article would be promoted. On July 6, 2003, the first three articles were promoted simultaneously to "Brilliant Prose" status as part of this new process:[1]
- Aztalan State Park, a self-nomination by JohnOwens
- Same-sex marriage, nominated by Eloquence; the primary contributor at the time was Montrealais
- MKULTRA, nominated by Eloquence; the primary contributors were The Anome, Kwertii, and Maury Markowitz .
In November 2003, Fuzheado proposed that the system be changed to be more similar to Wikipedia processes such as RfA and AFD. Rather than simply avoiding objections, a candidate would be required to gain support before it could be promoted to Featured article (FA). This process evolved into our current Featured article candidacy (FAC) system. At the suggestion of Kingturtle, the predecessor to the Featured article review (FAR) process was initiated in December 2003.
In December 2003, Raul654 proposed that new featured articles be recognized with a prominent spot on the Main Page. The next month, the main page was revamped from text only to a version similar to its current look. For several months, Raul654 was the primary contributor to the process of choosing featured articles for exposure on the main page; in August 2004, he was officially ratified as Featured Article Director.
Originally, nominations were expected to be by uninvolved editors who often had no investment in the nomination. In some cases, reviewers would fix issues that they or other editors had noticed in the articles; in others, the issues were never fixed and the nomination would eventually fail. This led to a gradual shift in nomination practices, and by the end of 2004 almost all nominations were by significant contributors to the article, who would then be more likely to respond to objections and comments.
Around June 2004, partly in response to the FAC nomination of Fuck, which turned into a lively debate, the FAC guidelines were changed to note that objections must be "actionable"; thus, objections needed to provide some guidance to the nominator on how the article could be improved, and objections on the basis of morality or "I don't like it" would no longer be considered when closing a nomination. Even with the change, Fuck was not promoted, in the face of objections including length and the quality of the prose.
As the number of nominations increased, the FAC process adapted to keep up. The original process had kept all nominations and their discussion on one page, at times divided into "Opposed" and "Unopposed" sections. By December 2004, the page was groaning under the weight of nominations and reviews, and nominations were instead placed on their own individual pages (for example, {{Wikipedia:Featured article candidates/name of nominated article}}) and transcluded onto the main FAC page. As the process matured, along with Wikipedia, standards gradually rose. Among the changes was a new insistence on sourcing, spearheaded by mav. Beginning in August 2004, most FAs were expected to have a references section listing the sources used. At the time, very few WP articles listed sources, and most older FAs did not meet our modern criteria (especially the verifiability and citations aspects). These articles were slowly taken to FAR, where they were typically demoted. As of April 2005, Pcb21 estimated that only 25 of the 110 articles that had been featured in August 2001 (the earliest data available), were still featured. (The August 15 internet archive version of the Brilliant Prose page is the closest available to the end of August 2001.) In response to the continual rise in standards required for promotion, more of these original FAs have been delisted, and today only five of the articles listed on the first version of the FA page from December 2001 retain their bronze star—Comet, Rudyard Kipling, Greek Mythology, Punk rock and Byzantine Empire.
The criteria were further refined with the addition of a stability criterion in January 2005. This was expanded to specifically forbid edit wars in September 2005 as a result of conflict during the nomination of Terri Schiavo.
At the suggestion of Filiocht, a separate process for determining featured lists was created in May 2005. By August, regular reviewers at FAC and FLC were debating how to determine a list from an article. This debate is ongoing. Another process, featured topics, was created in August 2005 to recognize groups of featured articles and lists.
By June 2006, the standard had again increased, and featured articles were expected to have some form of inline citations, either footnotes or Harvard style. This was partially due to the December 2005 introduction of cite.php, which allowed the method of referencing that is most widely used on WP today. At the time, there was much disagreement about whether this requirement should be applied retroactively. Very few articles at the time (even featured articles), had inline citations. Ultimately, it was decided that all featured articles should be held to the new standard requiring inline citations, regardless of when they were promoted. In mid-2006, Marskell proposed that the old Featured article removal candidates (FARC) be merged with the Featured article review. It was revamped to allow at least a month in review and more time for older articles to meet current standards, including the addition of citations; the modern FAR process was implemented in June 2006 and tweaked to its current form a month later.
In June 2006, the English Wikipedia noted the promotion of its net 1000th featured article. Tombseye and Khoikhoi were the significant contributors to the highlighted article, Iranian peoples.[2] Less than two years later, on April 10, 2008, the 2000th FA was promoted. Five articles were promoted simultaneously and shared the honor: Walter de Coventre, Maximian, El Señor Presidente, Lord of the Universe, and Red-billed Chough.
For just over a year, spanning 2004–05, Featured articles represented just over 0.1000% (one in a thousand) of all articles on Wikipedia. As the total number of articles on Wikipedia has increased, this percentage dropped to a low of 0.0762% (fewer than one in 1300) in February 2007; since then, it has slowly yet steadily increased to 0.087% (one in 1140), the current proportion. An examination of the promoted and archived FA nominations showed that in February–July 2006, roughly 35% of all articles nominated for FA were promoted—an average of 44 articles were promoted to FA each month. In the same period in 2007, 56 articles were promoted monthly, some 53% of nominations. While that pass-rate that has remained steady into 2008, the higher nomination rate we now see has boosted the number of monthly promotions to an average of 72 a month in the first third of 2008.
See also
Notes
- ^ All have since been delisted.
- ^ Iranian peoples was reviewed in June 2006 and remains featured.
Features and admins
Administrators
No users were granted admin status via the Requests for Adminship process this week.
Bots
Ten bots or bot tasks were approved to begin operating this week: RockfangBot (task request), OverlordQBot (task request), DinoBot2 (task request), Milk's Favorite Bot II (task request), WilhelmBot (task request), Vini 17bot5 (task request), Chris G Bot 3 (task request), Amirobot (task request), MystBot (task request), and PseudoBot (task request).
Featured pages
Eight articles were promoted to featured status this week: Greater Manchester (nom), Forksville Covered Bridge (nom), Roman–Persian Wars (nom), Sunderland Echo (nom), Geography and ecology of the Everglades (nom), History of the National Hockey League (1917–1942) (nom), New York State Route 308 (nom), and Pulmonary contusion (nom).
Twelve lists were promoted to featured status this week: NBA Defensive Player of the Year Award (nom), List of submissions for the 77th Academy Award for Best Foreign Language Film (nom), List of songs in Guitar Hero: Aerosmith (nom), NBA Most Improved Player Award (nom), List of tallest buildings in Indianapolis (nom), List of Ottawa Senators players (nom), List of numbered highways in Maryland (nom), The Mars Volta discography (nom), Lost (season 4) (nom), NBA Rookie of the Year Award (nom), NBA Sixth Man of the Year Award (nom), and Mark Lanegan discography (nom).
No topics were promoted to featured status this week.
No portals were promoted to featured status this week.
The following featured articles were displayed this week on the Main Page as Today's featured article: FairTax, The Quatermass Experiment, Guitar Hero (video game), Puerto Ricans in World War II, Thomas Playford IV, Minneapolis, Minnesota, and Jay Chou.
Former featured pages
Two articles were delisted this week: Prime Minister of the United Kingdom (nom) and Trigonometric functions (nom).
No lists were delisted this week.
No topics were delisted this week.
Featured media
The following featured pictures were displayed this week on the Main Page as picture of the day: Beer Street and Gin Lane, Mark Twain, Japanese Squirrel, Hurrcaine Felix (2007), Postman Butterfly, Tacoma Narrows Bridge, and Welding.
Two sounds were featured this week: Inaugural address of John F. Kennedy (nom) and After-dinner speech by Arthur Sullivan at the Little Menlo, London (nom).
No featured pictures were demoted this week.
Nine pictures were promoted to featured status this week and are shown below.
Bugs, Repairs, and Internal Operational News
This is a summary of recent technology and site configuration changes that affect the English Wikipedia. Note that not all changes described here are necessarily live as of press time; the English Wikipedia is currently running version 1.44.0-wmf.8 (f08e6b3), and changes to the software with a version number higher than that will not yet be active. Configuration changes and changes to interface messages, however, become active immediately.
Fixed bugs
- The paging links in Special:Prefixindex now work correctly on pages with ampersands in their names. (r37704, bug 13949)
- Special:Userlogout now doesn't show broken unified-logout images for a user who does not have a global account. (r37772, bug 14842)
New features
- The information in Special:UnwatchedPages is now available to administrators via the API (using list=allpages with apfilterwatched). (r37748, bug 14020)
Other technology news
- The EasyTimeline extension (used to add timelines in some wiki pages) was broken recently, causing pages with timelines in them to become inaccessible; it has been reverted to an older version temporarily pending a fix.
Ongoing news
- Internationalisation has been continuing as normal; help is always appreciated! See mw:Localisation statistics for how complete the translations of languages you know are, and post any updates to bugzilla or use Betawiki.
The Report on Lengthy Litigation
The Arbitration Committee did not open or close any cases this week, leaving two currently open.
Voting phase
- Geogre-William M. Connolley: A case involving wheel warring between Geogre and William M. Connolley. William M. Connolley inappropriately extended a block on Giano II, while Geogre inappropriately reversed the block, and reversed page protection on Giano's talk page. The case is currently in the voting phase; proposed remedies include:
- Four different versions of a remedy modifying or removing remedy 2.2 in IRC. All versions are supported by two to three arbitrators, and opposed by one to two arbitrators.
- A remedy suspending Geogre's administrative privileges for two weeks is supported by two arbitrators, and opposed by two.
- Currently passing is a remedy prohibiting Geogre and Connolley from taking any administrative action with respect to Giano II.
Motion to close
- C68-FM-SV: A case involving disputes between Cla68, FeloniousMonk, SlimVirgin, JzG, and others. The case, which has seen little-to-no public input from arbitrators, is currently subject to a motion to dismiss, with the support of one arbitrator, and the opposition of one.