Jump to content

Wikipedia:No open proxies/Poll

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

This poll is currently not active. Please do not comment in it.

Inactive indefinitely.

Straw poll (not active)

[edit]
Due to the elusive nature of consensus in the discussion of Wikipedia:No open proxies (WP:NOP), it has become apparent that an informal straw poll may be the best way to extract some sort of consensus. (This is often done with hotly disputed policies.) This poll will not directly decide the destiny of WP:NOP, since it is not a ballot. If consensus cannot be parsed, this poll will be ignored.

If you are unfamiliar with the dispute, please review:

In addition, much conversation about the issues occurred on the wikien-l Mailing List. The threads "Editing with open proxies" and "Trojan admins, is it a real problem?" are particularly relevant.

Also related to NOP's status as a policy:

If you are unfamiliar with straw polls, please review:

This poll is divided into two sections; the first is about the state of the policy itself, and the second is about how to go about blocking open proxies.

Please add your opinion on the matter in each section, in this format:

*'''<opinion>''' <rationale> ~~~~

Major opinions are listed below each section, and it is strongly suggested that you write a rationale for your opinion. Any discussion about this straw poll itself may be added to Wikipedia talk:No open proxies/Poll.

Finally, please be civil; concentrate on the issues at hand rather than other users; and the and do not be disruptive for sake of making a point.

Comments about policy

[edit]

Main opinions on this issue include:

Poll

Discussion

[edit]

Comments about open proxies

[edit]

Main opinions on this issue include:

  • "Hard-block open proxies": this means that open proxies should be blocked in such a way that a blocked open proxy cannot be used for editing.
  • "Soft-block open proxies": this means that open proxies should be blocked in such a way that a blocked open proxy cannot be used for editing without a registered account.
  • "Do not block open proxies": this means that open proxies should not be blocked at all, and that anyone can edit through them with or without an account.
  • "Other": please delineate.
Poll

Discussion

[edit]