Wikipedia:Good article mentorship
| Main | Criteria | Instructions | Nominations | October 2024 Backlog Drive | Mentorship | Discussion | Reassessment | Report |
Good article mentors provide assistance and feedback to editors who are new to reviewing. If you are interested in reviewing but are not sure where to start, requesting a mentor can make the process easier. To request a mentor, press the button below and follow the instructions.
|
This page has archives. Sections older than 7 days may be automatically archived by Lowercase sigmabot III. |
Mentors can:
- Help find an article suitable for a new reviewer to review
- Explain any of the good article criteria and how to assess them
- Check a review to make sure it was done correctly
- Answer any other questions about how to review a good article nomination
Mentors are not expected to complete any part of the review. Mentorship is optional, and you do not have to request a mentor to begin reviewing.
Mentors ()
|
|---|
|
This is a list of users who have volunteered to be good article mentors. If you wish to choose a specific mentor, you can leave a message on one of their talk pages. Remember that not all of them might be active or be able to help at any given time. If you're an experienced reviewer, you can add your name! You do not need to be on this list to answer a request for mentorship. Mentors are encouraged to add the mentorship page to their watchlist.
|
Current requests
[edit]Hello, this was my first review and I decided to come here per WP:GAI to have someone look over it. I quick-failed the article, however I believe that it's justified under the criteria; was I being too harsh? Thanks for your time! The review: Talk:Mixtape/GA1 Leafy46 (talk) 19:45, 1 November 2024 (UTC)
- Leafy46, I personally fully concur with that quickfail. I think you did an excellent job of pointing out what needs to be improved, and what didn't meet the GA criteria. Thank you for your good work; I hope we'll see you around doing more GANRs in the future! Fritzmann (message me) 20:45, 1 November 2024 (UTC)
I'm going to do a GA review for the first time. May someone mentor me in writing a review?
It's for a 2024 Philippine pop song, so better if a Filipino might review this for familiarity.
Article: Cherry on Top (Bini song); 2024 single by Bini
Article was nominated earlier for GA, but was rejected. Some feedback was followed, some wasn't. I tried providing a response, but I'm not yet confident on doing it right and giving a verdict.