Wikipedia:Featured article candidates/Space Shuttle Columbia disaster/archive1
A major bit of history and a tragic event. Deserves to be on the frontpage for a day - User:Tom_walker
- Object. While the subject is certainly worthy of someday being on the frontpage, the article does not currently meet featured article criteria such as citing its references. --Allen3 talk 12:54, 20 November 2005 (UTC)
- Object. It could be great, but there are several problems that are sticking out currently:
- Image:TIME_feb_2003.jpg has no fair use rationale.
- Lead is very short for the size of the article.
- References are missing. What was used as sources to write this article? Newspaper articles, books, etc?
- Layout could do with some working, all of the images are of different sizes and it looks messy.
- 'Response from the President' section is a bit short.
- A few sentences in the Memorial section are sort of choppy, it doesn't provide a nice flow.
I couldn't spot anything else from my look at the article. You might want to refer it to WP:Peer review for more comments/suggestions. — Wackymacs 19:46, 20 November 2005 (UTC)