Jump to content

Wikipedia:Featured and good topic candidates/Triple Gold Club

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Triple Gold Club

[edit]
Co-nominators: Scorpion0422 and Maxim

In the immortal words of Groundskeeper Willie: "I told ya I'd be bahck!" A lot sooner than I thought too. The topic now includes both the articles on the championships and the lists of winners. I suppose that if anyone wanted, it could be limited to just the championships, but I think including the winners makes it more complete. -- Scorpion0422 00:02, 14 March 2009 (UTC)[reply]

I think either way would make a topic. "Triple Gold Club Awards" and "Triple Gold club members". Renaming this as a preemtive disambiguation might be useful, but not essential as long as it is the only one, imo.YobMod 16:15, 17 March 2009 (UTC)[reply]
This topic is about a club, when reading the lead article, it does not go into the three awards and who won them, rather it focuses on who is a member of the club. With the other topics named, the lead is a summary and the other artilces are sublists. In this one the lead is a sublist of parts (individuals of a team) of the non-lead articles. This is upside down. Zginder 2009-03-18T16:33Z (UTC)
Hmm, you do have a point. What if I added a brief summary of all three awards to the Triple Gold Club page? -- Scorpion0422 16:39, 18 March 2009 (UTC)[reply]
Like this? -- Scorpion0422 17:16, 18 March 2009 (UTC)[reply]
The article is now better, but I still think that the topic is not appropriate. Zginder 2009-03-24T18:28Z (UTC)
Then what do you want to see done? How about giving me some actual suggestions? -- Scorpion0422 18:52, 24 March 2009 (UTC)[reply]
I opposed because This topic should be about who got in the club not how to get in. The improvements to the lead are good, ut they do not address my problem with the topic. Zginder 2009-03-24T19:38Z (UTC)
I don't know how I can make it any less about the members, short of removing every mention of them. This is simply a topic with a limited definition. Per your logic, the Carnivàle FT should contain every actor and the creators because the lead of Carnivàle goes into detail about them. But that topic works with just the core articles and so does this one. -- Scorpion0422 21:04, 24 March 2009 (UTC)[reply]