Wikipedia:Contentious topics/2021-22 review/Implementation/To do

If you cross off an item, give yourself (or whomever did it) credit. Your help in the meatball:BarnRaising shouldn't go unrecognized!

Directives

• Status: not done, not blocking Create a "subpage of the contentious topics procedure listing relevant information" (10) (pages created DJ - needs filling out)
  • Standard set remedies: Antisemitism in Poland ("reliable-source consensus required") and Civility in infobox disucssions ("infobox probation")
• Status: looks done Implement 11 "using clear and concise formatting when describing page restrictions in place of long individual lines"
  • Create two editnotice templates: (1) for optional use on pages with no page restrictions, (2) for mandatory use on pages with page restrictions (Wug)
    • See {{Editnotice contentious topic}} and {{Editnotice contentious topic page restriction}}
      • Still need documented as of 00:37, 17 December 2022 (UTC)
        • Partly documented 01:55, 17 December 2022 (UTC) (DJ)
    • The only template currently in category #1 (for optional use) is {{COVID19 DS editnotice}}, for inspiration (and standardization).
    • Update edit filter 602 once the switch occurs
      • Change the filter name to "Contentious topics alerts" (DJ)
      • Replace line 7 ("comment" variable definition) by comment := "-- derived from template:contentious topics/alert --"; - Partly done (while keeping previous one there in case of issues) (DJ)
      • Use MediaWiki:abusefilter-warning-CT instead of MediaWiki:abusefilter-warning-DS (DJ)
      • Renaming the associated MediaWiki tag name to "contentious topics alerts" will probably require system administrator assistance (requested in phab:T327118). The public-facing text can be updated at MediaWiki:Tag-discretionary sanctions alert. (DJ)
        • It is not possible to rename the name for the tag (it is possible to update the user facing name), but this may be desired.
    • Update Template:AE sanction with content from this version in the sandbox once the switch occurs. (Used a slightly different version - DJ)
    • Update Template:AE sanction/topicban once the switch occurs.
  • Create custom ArbCom-maintained templates for cases with existing topic-wide restrictions (DJ)
    • GMOs (1RR, currently {{Editnotice GMO 1RR}} and {{ARBGMO alert}}
      • Editnotice created with {{Contentious topics/gmo editnotice}} - calls {{contentious topics/page restriction editnotice}} under the hood. (DJ)
      • Talk page notice created at {{Contentious topics/gmo talk notice}} (DJ)
    • ARBPIA (ECR and 1RR, currently {{ArbCom Arab-Israeli editnotice}} and {{ArbCom Arab-Israeli enforcement}}
      • Editnotice created with {{Contentious topics/Arab-Israeli editnotice}} (DJ)
      • Talk page notice created at {{Contentious topics/Arab-Israeli talk notice}} (DJ)
    • (non-DS case but could benefit from ArbCom maintained template nonetheless:) Macedonia (1RR)
    • The Troubles (1RR - technically the 1RR is a page restriction? uses {{ArbCom Troubles restriction}})
      • Created editnotice at {{Contentious topics/The Troubles editnotice}} (DJ)
      • Talk page notice created at {{Contentious topics/The Troubles talk notice}} (DJ)
    • American politics – no DS remedy but {{American politics AE}} is commonly used and should be under jurisdiction of the clerks. Same with {{COVID-19 AE/Edit notice}}, others at Category:Wikipedia arbitration enforcement templates. (DJ)
    • Change {{COVID-19 AE/Edit notice}} to use this version from the sandbox and update documentation for template. (DJ)
    • Change {{ArbCom Arab-Israeli editnotice}} to use this version from the sandbox and update documentation for template. (DJ)
    • Change {{ArbCom Arab-Israeli enforcement}} to use this version from the sandbox and update documentation for template. (DJ)
    • Change {{American politics AE/Edit notice}} to use this version from the sandbox and update documentation for template. (DJ)
    • Change {{American politics AE}} to use this version from the sandbox and update documentation for template. (DJ)
    • Change {{ArbCom sanctions - abortion}} to reference contentious topic templates or alternatively redirect and then delete it(?) (DJ)
    • Change {{ArbCom Troubles restriction}} to use this version from the sandbox and update documentation for template. (DJ)
    • Change {{Digwuren enforcement}} to reference contentious topic templates or alternatively redirect and then delete it(?) (DJ)
    • Change {{COVID19 DS editnotice}} to use this version from the sandbox and update documentation for template. (DJ)
    • Status: not done: See also: {{Editnotice 0RR}} (maybe should be standardized or deleted)
    • Modified the three alert templates to include text about existing topic-wide restrictions (DJ)
    • list known cases here for tracking
• status: done Implement 16
  • Add text to procedures with formatting for section transclusion
  • Transclude on CT procedures page
• Add 18 to procedures (thanks User:L235)
• Amend Wikipedia:Arbitration Committee/Procedures § Logging per 19 Done Dreamy Jazz ^{talk to me | my contributions} 23:42, 15 December 2022 (UTC)
• status: not done, batch on implementation day "amend all existing remedies authorizing discretionary sanctions to instead designate contentious topics." task technically for clerks per 21
• Update templates that are subpages of Template:Contentious topics (previously Template:Ds) to the new names and procedures (DJ, Wug, TBF)
• Implement 9, "maintain instructions for enforcing administrators", at WP:CT/ADMIN (partly done by Dreamy Jazz ^{talk to me | my contributions})
• Update Template:Ds family of templates
  • Redirect the templates where possible, make them wrappers for the new system, or mark them as deprecated
  • History merge for Template:Contentious topics templates that are largely based on a Template:Ds templates (?)

Drafting

• Merge language motions into single page (thanks User:Wugapodes)
• Add level-2 headers and arrange sections appropriately (L235)
  • This can look similar to the sample here. KevinL (aka L235 · t · c) 00:35, 15 December 2022 (UTC)
• Migrate anchors from the DS procedures to the CT procedures
• status: partly done, see talk Implement the directive in 6, "Amendment: Limiting blocks to one year": The drafting arbitrators are directed to modify the "Procedural summary" table within the "Contentious topic restrictions: imposition, types, duration, use" proposal and the "Changing or revoking a contentious topic restriction" section of the "Appeals and amendments" proposal for consistency with the changes made by this amendment.
• Update WP:GS
  • Lede description (DJ)
  • Authorisation lists
• write summary of changes (DS vs. CT; WP:DSVSCT) (done - DJ, L235 and others)
• ???
• Mark DS page as historical