User talk:Solidandrewsister

List of best-selling girl groups

Hello there fellow collaborator! I've seen that you put Girls Generation back on the list and reverted my edit, i didn't add it back cause my duty as an editor is to advoid edit warring so i am here to kindly discuss it, as WP editors we should communicate with each other and most importantly collaborate with each other to make WP a better and improved website, in Girls' Generation's case has been already agreed that there is no consesus on why they should be on the list, their source was used on the old version of WP and all listed sources from the old version are not allowed anymore now, only sources from 2017 and up are permitted except for groups that were active way before WP was created like The Supremes, Spice Girls etc etc, you mentioned all groups listed have non-updated sources and that's centairtly not true, all groups in the ranking have updated sources ranging from 2019 to 2023, even the Spice Girls sources are from this decade, there's no valid reason why Girls' Generation should stay since there hasn't been any update on their sales from reliable sources since 2012, their source is 11 years old and its far away from their real figure, many higher figures for them have been confirmed, and we can know this by calculating their sales on the Circle Chart, but unfortunately reliable sources aren't really talking about them so we"ll have to wait until it happens, keep in mind that this message is just a civilized discussion and not even an message advise like the one i sent you before with the illusion to help you and guide you better here on WP but you sadly took it as an "attack" and still call it as an "attack" for some unexplainable reason but okay that's a past thing, this about regarding a different topic, hope you can read this message, have a great day❤ Lightlylove (talk) 17:02, 17 June 2023 (UTC)

Hello there! I kindly request if you could share the discussion where it was agreed upon not to include Girls' Generation's overall sales on the list. I haven't come across any information indicating such a consensus. If you have any details to provide, I would greatly appreciate it if you could include them in your response. This would help me understand the reasons behind their exclusion. Thank you. Solidandrewsister (talk) 11:04, 18 June 2023 (UTC)