Jump to content

User talk:Pleasenowz

Page contents not supported in other languages.
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Jessica Biel

[edit]

Please read WP:TALK. Talk page comments are supposed to be directed toward the goal of improving the article. Your extended rant, at times incomprehensible, based on an innocuous comment by Biel that she has some Choctaw heritage, consisted primarily of a personal attack on her, accusing her of lying, and without the least shred of evidence. So while you're reading, read WP:BLP, which applies to everything on Wikipedia, not just articles. Your edit was not intended to improve article; it was intended to damage Biel's reputation (and I have no vested interest here; I don't even think she's a good actress, but she deserves the same protections as anyone else who has an article on Wikipedia). Even if she is 1/100 of one percent Choctaw, her statement is not a lie, and the burden of proof for an editor calling a living person a liar is on that editor. You had no intention of trying to improve the article. You just wanted a soapbox to rant about someone you thought might not have as much Choctaw heritage as you think she should. So here's your choice. You clean up your edit and take the unfounded attacks out of it. You add a reliable source for your allegations that she is lying. Otherwise, I plan to post a notice on the WP:BLP noticeboard and an WP:RfC on the Biel talk page, and we'll see what the larger Wikipedia community, not just me, thinks about your edit. And one final point: I don't plan to argue back and forth with you endlessly. I have pointed out the relevant policies that are problematic in your edit. You can either ignore that (in which case I post those notices), or you can clean up your edit. But if you want to argue with me on my talk page or your talk page, you're wasting your time. The appropriate venue is Talk:Jessica Biel so that everyone can see what you have to say. So messages sent to me will be immediately moved to Talk:Jessica Biel. End of discussion here and my talk page. Ward3001 (talk) 00:26, 9 June 2009 (UTC)[reply]

Personal attacks

[edit]

Please do not attack other editors, which you did here: Talk:Jessica Biel. If you continue, you will be blocked from editing Wikipedia. Ward3001 (talk) 16:11, 9 June 2009 (UTC)[reply]