Jump to content

User talk:Pierce blalock/sandbox

Page contents not supported in other languages.
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Nathan's Revisions

  • Title is appropriate
  • The first sentence is very informative
  • The lead is a great, well rounded summary of the article
  • Seems to be written in your own words, the first publisher of the article who wrote the 2010 census section may have copied a bit so you could reword that section
  • all of the data is easily understandable and in a readable format
  • Written in an unbiased manner
  • Does not use first or second person :)
  • Follows the wikipedia format very closely
  • The in-text citations seem to be very good but it may draw to much from the 2010 census alone and that section could be cut down a little
  • The article could use more links in the tourism and history sections but besides that, they are used well

Longnat (talk) 23:23, 22 October 2019 (UTC) Longnat (talk) 19:03, 25 October 2019 (UTC)[reply]

Dylan Jiao's peer revision

[edit]

First thing first, you got to add a title. Second, I can't really peer edit much since you didn't revise the article much. I noticed that you changed the order of the history and geography segments which I believe is a nice change to the article since it makes sense to talk about history first.