User talk:Ncutssss/Nullspeeds in General Relativity
Note to reviewers
[edit]In my opinion this article is nowhere near ready for mainspace:
- It gives no indication of the significance, meaning, or use of nullspeed in general relativity. Although probably verifiable, it is has issues of notability.
- It is mis-titled. The article deals specifically with the Schwarzchild metric, not GR as a whole. It does not discuss other metrics, or even indicate that the concept of null speed is even meaningful in other metrics.
- It contains algebraic errors. Equation 5 does not follow from equation 4.
- As far as I can tell, the comparison with optics and polarization is unsourced, and may be OR.
- Math formatting and indenting needs to be addressed.
SpinningSpark 13:54, 27 April 2012 (UTC)
- Redirected userspace draft to Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Nullspeeds in General Relativity. Pol430 talk to me 14:45, 27 April 2012 (UTC)