User:RachelTensions/XfD log

This is a log of all deletion discussion nominations made by this user using Twinkle's XfD module.

If you no longer wish to keep this log, you can turn it off using the preferences panel, and nominate this page for speedy deletion under CSD U1.

December 2024

1. Kim Jin-yi (actress): nominated at RM; New name: Kim Jin-yi 22:03, 20 December 2024 (UTC)
   • Reason: Unnecessary disambiguation page. Per WP:ONEOTHER, a hatnote is an acceptable disambiguation when there is a primary topic and only one other ambiguous article. In this case, the actress is the primary topic by pageviews (WP:PT1) receiving substantially more monthly average views over the last 12 months versus the handballer [1]
2. Lee Soo-jin: nominated at RM; New name: Lee Soo-jin (politician, proportional representation constituency)
3. Lee Su-jin (politician): nominated at RM; New name: Lee Su-jin (politician, Seoul Dongjak B constituency) 15:37, 22 December 2024 (UTC)
   • Reason: Proposing the following moves to try to untangle some ambiguity:
     Currently there are two politicians with the same name, Lee Su-jin (politician) and Lee Soo-jin. Both are the same name in Korean (이수진).
     Neither politician is the primary topic; they both have very close to the same amount of average monthly pageviews over the last 12 months. Pageview stats for all Lee Su-jin/Soo-jin articles show WP:NOPRIMARY pageview stats
     Having some trouble coming up with proper disambiguators for the two politicians. Both have the same name, same birth year, same nationality, both are members of the Democratic Party, both served in the National Assembly, and both began serving in the National Assembly beginning in 2020.
     Some options:
     * Lee Soo-jin represented the Proportional representation constituency, while Lee Su-jin (politician) represented a constituency in Seoul, so another option would be:
     ** Lee Soo-jin → Lee Soo-jin (politician, proportional representation constituency)
     ** Lee Su-jin (politician) → Lee Su-jin (politician, Seoul Dongjak B constituency)
     Another option would be:
     * Lee Soo-jin was a labor activist prior to her election in 2020, and Lee Su-jin (politician) was a judge, so one option would be:
     ** Lee Soo-jin → Lee Soo-jin (labor activist)
     ** Lee Su-jin (politician) → Lee Su-jin (judge)
     Also open to further suggestions on how they should be disambiguated.
     Whichever option we go with, after this move, Lee Soo-jin should be redirected to the disambiguation page at Lee Su-jin.
4. The Diplomat: nominated at RM; New name: The Diplomat (magazine)
5. The Diplomat (American TV series): nominated at RM; New name: The Diplomat 16:33, 22 December 2024 (UTC)
   • Reason: The news magazine entitled The Diplomat currently has the primary topic title for articles named "The Diplomat".
     However, since The Diplomat (American TV series)'s creation in April 2023, the article has received consistently and substantially more pageviews than all other "The Diplomat" articles combined.
     Over the last 18 months, The American TV series received 190,000 average monthly pageviews, while all the other "The Diplomat" articles combined received 32,000.
     Of course, this includes spikes of pageviews when the TV series was in the news because of a new season. But, even at its lowest, the American TV series still received 43,000 views while all other articles combined only received 19,000.
     Full pageview analysis
     WikiNav clickstream data also shows that 75% of the views on Diplomat (disambiguation) clicked in from The Diplomat (magazine), and 82% of outgoing clicks from Diplomat (disambiguation) were headed to The Diplomat (American TV series). WikiNav analysis
     I am proposing that The Diplomat (American TV series) is now the primary topic per the criteria at WP:PT1.
     At the very least, this shows that the news magazine entitled The Diplomat is no longer the primary topic and should be moved; whether or not the American TV series is now the primary is up for debate.
6. Lee Hye-in: nominated at RM; New name: Lee Hye-in (actress)
7. Lee Hye-in (disambiguation): nominated at RM; New name: Lee Hye-in 15:56, 27 December 2024 (UTC)
   • Reason: Seems to be some pageview overlap between Lee Hye-in (actress) and Lee Hye-in (fencer): pageview stats In addition, there is Hyein, whose birth name is also Lee Hye-in, and outdoes both of the others by several orders of magnitude, though she does not use her birth name professionally.
     In any case, I am unsure there is any clearcut primary topic for the name, so a disambiguation page is probably best here.

January 2025

1. Jang Hye-jin (actress): nominated at RM; New name: Jang Hye-jin 07:39, 4 January 2025 (UTC)
   • Reason: For all people named "Jang Hye-jin" (or Jang's alternative romanization, "Chang"), the actress seems to be the primary topic under WP:PT1.
     For the last two years, the actress has received an average of 7700 monthly pageviews, while the other two articles have received a monthly average of only 900 combined. pageview stats
     As far as disambiguation page vs. hatnotes, a simple hatnote is probably sufficient rather than keeping a full disambiguation page around under WP:TWOOTHER:
     This page is about the actress. For the singer, see Jang Hye-jin (singer). For the archer, see Chang Hye-jin.
2. Sunghoon: nominated at RM; New name: Sunghoon (singer, born 2002)
3. Sung Hoon (singer): nominated at RM; New name: Sung Hoon (singer, born 1980)
4. Sung Hoon: nominated at RM; New name: Sung Hoon (actor) 01:56, 6 January 2025 (UTC)
   • Reason: There are currently three people with Wikipedia articles who are known only as "성훈" (and romanized as Sunghoon/Sung Hoon):
     * Sunghoon, singer and former figure skater
     * Sung Hoon, actor
     * Sung Hoon (singer)
     At first I thought the space might be fine to disambiguate them (WP:SMALLDETAILS) beacuse Sunghoon is rarely referred to as "Sung Hoon" in English-language RS. However, the potential for confusion is still strong because Korean names can commonly be written as all one word, or hyphens between syllables, or with the syllables completely separate.
     I'm going to go out on a limb and say there is WP:NOPRIMARY for people with the name "성훈" (Sunghoon/Sung Hoon), given the almost perfect pageview overlap between Sunghoon and Sung Hoon (see pageview stats (Note the pageviews for Park Sung-hoon from pre-August 2024 are from before Sunghoon was moved to its current title.)
     Proposing the following:
     * Sung Hoon → Sung Hoon (actor)
     * Sung Hoon (singer) → Sung Hoon (singer, born 1980)
     * Sunghoon → Sunghoon (singer, born 2002)
     I've created a draft disambiguation page that would be moved to Sung Hoon if the move is successful: Draft:Sung Hoon; ideally Sunghoon would redirect here as well.