User:Otterathome/Deletion discussions

This page is to display a table of factual data for any users who don't want research in to my deletion history. Only deletion discussions related to web series type content, or subjects/websites related to web-series content is included.

As this is mostly data and facts only, it allows users to draw their own conclusions from it.

Table is ordered in oldest first, newest at the bottom.


Deletion discussion	Users who voted (people who only comment not included)	Result/notes
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Becki Kregoski	User:Atama, User:Milowent, User:Modelmotion, User:SummerPhD	Closed as delete, 3 deletes, 1 keep.
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Katherine Pawlak	User:Atama, User:Modelmotion, User:SummerPhD.	Closed as delete, 1 keep vote, 2 delete votes.
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Giles Alderson	User:Magnius.	Closed as delete, 0 keep votes, 1 delete vote.
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lucinda Rhodes-Flaherty	User:MichaelQSchmidt	Closed as keep, 1 keep vote, withdrawn nomination.
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/LG15: The Last	User:Byronwrites, User:Joe_Chill, User:Kayvahn, User:KindredPhantom, User:Modelmotion, User:Milowent, 3 anon ip editors	Closed as Keep, 10 Keep votes, 2 delete votes. Off-site canvassing.
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jackson Davis (2nd nomination)	User:Atama, User:ChildofMidnight, User:KindredPhantom, User:Mathieas, User:Modelmotion, User:Milowent, User:Sodam Yat	Closed as Keep by sock admin, 5 keep votes 2 delete votes. Off-site canvassing.
Wikipedia:Deletion_review/Log/2009_August_14#Jackson Davis	User:Pastor Theo, User:JoshuaZ, User:Juliancolton, User:Spartaz, User:Stifle, User:Hobit, 'Renegade'	4 endorse, 2 overturn, reclosed as 'No consensus; no prejudice against relisting' by admin User:King of Hearts.
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jackson Davis (3rd nomination)	User:Hullaballoo Wolfowitz, User:KindredPhantom User:Milowent, User:Modelmotion, User:MichaelQSchmidt User:NellieBly User:Peregrine Fisher, User:Zoeydahling, 'Renegade'	Closed as Keep, 10 keep votes 0 delete votes
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mesh Flinders	User:DGG, User:Dream_Focus, User:Milowent, User:Ret.Prof, User:SarekOfVulcan, User:Shoessss, User:Shiori, User:Zoeydahling	Closed as Keep, 9 keep votes 0 delete votes. Off-site canvassing.
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vincent_Caso	User:Izno, User:Lindaestabrook, User:Mathieas, User:Milowent, User:MrFizyx, User:Multixfer, User:NRTurner, User:SarekOfVulcan, User:Simonm223, User:Shiori, User:Zoeydahling, 'Graptor'	Closed as Keep, 8 keep votes 3 delete votes. Canvassed off-site at two places.
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/LG15: The Last (2nd nomination)	User:COMPFUNK2, User:Ikip, User:Milowent, User:Modelmotion, User:Zoeydahling, 'Renegade'	Closed as Speedy Keep by admin User:SarekOfVulcan 6 keep votes 0 delete votes.
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tubefilter	User:Billbowery, User:COMPFUNK2, User:Mathieas, User:Milowent, User:Zoeydahling, 'Renegade'	Closed as Keep, 5 keep votes 0 delete votes.
Wikipedia:Deletion_review/Log/2009_September_15#LG15: The Last	User:Billbowery, User:BWilkins, User:SmokeyJoe, User:GRBerry, User:Tim Song, ,User:Milowent, User:SarekOfVulcan,User:Umbralcorax, User:Zoeydahling, 'Renegade'	Speedy keep endorsed
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Poor Paul	User:COMPFUNK2, User:Milowent, User:Zoeydahling	Ongoing

Copy of the above table, with usernames that voted in more than one of the deletion discussions bolded.

Duplicate of above table but users who voted in more than 1 discussion are in **Bold**
Deletion discussion	Users who voted (people who only comment not included)	Result/notes
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Becki Kregoski	User:Atama, User:Milowent, User:Modelmotion, User:SummerPhD
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Katherine Pawlak	User:Atama, User:Modelmotion, User:SummerPhD.	Closed as delete, 1 keep vote, 2 delete votes.
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Giles Alderson	User:Magnius.	Closed as delete, 0 keep votes, 1 delete vote.
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lucinda Rhodes-Flaherty	User:MichaelQSchmidt	Closed as keep, 1 keep vote, withdrawn nomination.
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/LG15: The Last	User:Byronwrites, User:Joe_Chill, User:Kayvahn, User:KindredPhantom. User:Modelmotion, User:Milowent, 3 anon ip editors	Closed as Keep, 10 Keep votes, 2 delete votes. Off-site canvassing.
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jackson Davis (2nd nomination)	User:Atama, User:ChildofMidnight, User:KindredPhantom, User:Mathieas, User:Modelmotion, User:Milowent, User:Sodam Yat	Closed as Keep by sock admin, 5 keep votes 2 delete votes. Off-site canvassing.
Wikipedia:Deletion_review/Log/2009_August_14#Jackson Davis	User:Pastor Theo, User:JoshuaZ, User:Juliancolton, User:Spartaz, User:Stifle, User:Hobit, 'Renegade'	4 endorse, 2 overturn, reclosed as 'No consensus; no prejudice against relisting' by admin User:King of Hearts.
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jackson Davis (3rd nomination)	User:Hullaballoo Wolfowitz, User:KindredPhantom User:Milowent, User:Modelmotion, User:MichaelQSchmidt User:NellieBly User:Peregrine Fisher, User:Zoeydahling, 'Renegade'	Closed as Keep, 10 keep votes 0 delete votes
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mesh Flinders	User:DGG, User:Dream_Focus, User:Milowent, User:Ret.Prof, User:SarekOfVulcan, User:Shoessss, User:Shiori, User:Zoeydahling	Closed as Keep, 9 keep votes 0 delete votes. Off-site canvassing.
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vincent_Caso	User:Izno, User:Lindaestabrook, User:Mathieas, User:Milowent, User:MrFizyx, User:Multixfer, User:NRTurner, User:SarekOfVulcan, User:Simonm223, User:Shiori, User:Zoeydahling, 'Graptor'	Closed as Keep, 8 keep votes 3 delete votes. Canvassed off-site at two places.
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/LG15: The Last (2nd nomination)	User:COMPFUNK2, User:Ikip, User:Milowent, User:Modelmotion, User:Zoeydahling, 'Renegade'	Closed as Speedy Keep by admin User:SarekOfVulcan 6 keep votes 0 delete votes.
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tubefilter	User:Billbowery, User:COMPFUNK2, User:Mathieas, User:Milowent, User:Zoeydahling, 'Renegade'	Closed as Keep, 5 keep votes 0 delete votes.
Wikipedia:Deletion_review/Log/2009_September_15#LG15: The Last	User:Billbowery, User:BWilkins, User:SmokeyJoe, User:GRBerry, User:Tim Song, User:Milowent, User:SarekOfVulcan, User:Umbralcorax, User:Zoeydahling, 'Renegade'	Speedy keep endorsed
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Poor Paul	User:COMPFUNK2, User:Milowent, User:Zoeydahling	Closed as keep, 3 keep votes.

Deletion nominations of my content by other users.


Deletion discussion	Users who voted (people who only comment not included)	Nominator
Wikipedia:Templates_for_discussion/Log/2009_October_18#Template:.7B.7Bucfirst:Substantial_sources.7D.7D	User:Billbowery, User:DGG, User:Milowent, User:RL0919	User:SarekOfVulcan

Notes/data

'Renegade' & graptor are two IP users on different ranges and leaves their name at the end of their edits.
Any mistakes in this table are unintentional.
All discussions listed were started by Otterathome.

Users who voted in 3 or more discussions

Username	# of above discussions voted in	Vote types	Suspected motivation/notes
User:Milowent	10	All Keeps, 1 delete, 1 delete in my template TFD	Fan of articles nominated. Editor of lg15 wiki.[1]Canvassed from Modelmotion's blog.[2]
User:Zoeydahling	7	All Keeps	Fan of articles nominated. Editor of lg15 wiki.[3] Canvassed from Modelmotion's blog.[4]
User:Modelmotion	6	All Keeps	Fan of articles nominated, runs lg15today.blogspot.com where votes were canvassed from. Editor of lg15 wiki.[5]
Renegade (via IP editing)	5	All Keeps	Fan of articles nominated. Editor of lg15 wiki[6]. Canvassed from Modelmotion's blog.[7].
User:SarekOfVulcan	2 + speedy AFD close, and nomination of my template	All Keeps + Speedy close + one deletion nomination of my template	The only admin on this list. So much for WP:UNINVOLVED. Has also commented on but not voted in Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Poor Paul.
User:Mathieas	3	All Keeps	Fan of articles nominated. Editor of lg15 wiki.[8] Canvassed from Modelmotion's blog.[9]
User:COMPFUNK2	3	All Keeps	See comments: [10][11][12][13][14][15][16][17][18][19][20][21] That's all his comments in discussions related to me.
User:KindredPhantom	3	All Keeps	Fan of articles nominated. Editor of lg15 wiki[22]. Canvassed from Modelmotion's blog.[23].
User:Atama	3	All Deletes	Unknown.
User:Billbowery	3	2 Keeps, 1 delete on my template TFD	Didn't take part in any discussions until my nomination of Tubefilter which this user created.

Also note many articles on the lg15 wiki contain external links to their equivalent Wikipedia articles.

Notes/data

Users who voted in 3 or more discussions

Discussion outside of deletion space