User:MarissaGrosz
Appearance
Option 1: Bioorganic Chemistry
[edit]- Article title: Bioorganic Chemistry
- Article Evaluation
- - The article contains relevant information (just very little of it and does not expand on information)
- - Most claims have citations (some do not) and the citations are reliable
- - The article is written neutrally
- - The article does not tackle don of Wiki's equity gaps
- - Needs to expand on information and needs more subtopics
- Source: Bioorganic chemistry
Option 2
[edit]- Article title: Cross Coupling Reactions
- Article Evaluation
- - The article contains relevant information however leaves out a lot of information/diagrams that could be useful to the points that they are making
- - Most claims are backed up with a citation or link to another Wikipedia page however some are missing
- - All citations are reliable
- - The article does not tackle don of Wiki's equity gaps
- - The talk section of the article states that more needs to be added as there are important topics within the article that are hardly or only briefly mentioned
- Source:Cross-coupling reaction
Option 3
[edit]- Article title: Gabriel Synthesis
- Article Evaluation
- - The article contains relevant information, however they are missing key information through out the article
- - Some claims are backed up with a citation or link to another Wiki page however there are quite a few missing citations
- - The citations are reliable
- - The talk section mentions that there was very little information on the mechanism which I agree, there are also very few diagrams depicting what the Gabriel synthesis is
- - In my opinion a synthesis article should have a lot more diagrams - The article does not tackle don of Wiki's equity gaps
- Sources: Gabriel synthesis
This user is a student editor in The_University_of_British_Columbia/CHEM_300_(Fall_2023). |