Jump to content

User:King of Hearts/Admin coaching/AfD/Template

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

The following is an exercise in closing AfD discussions. Please follow these rules:

  1. Indicate your decision (keep, delete, no consensus, merge, redirect, etc.) as well as your reason for making that decision. The reason should not be your personal opinion, but rather your interpretation of the arguments presented in the debate. The reason can be a sentence long for simple matters, or an entire paragraph long for more complex cases.
  2. You are allowed to search Google or other websites, but do not check Wikipedia to see if the article exists.
  3. Do the exercises in order, as they are arranged in order of difficulty.
  4. Remember that AfD is not a vote, but rather a discussion designed to achieve consensus. Therefore, you should give more weight to exceptionally well-reasoned arguments and less weight to mere !votes, arguments based on WP:ATA, SPA's, sockpuppets, etc.

Example

Decision: Delete
Reason: Although a headcount shows an equal distribution of keep and delete !votes, the delete !votes are based on the lack of reliable sources and the presence of original research, while many of the keep !votes are based on WP:ILIKEIT.

Beginner

[edit]

Decision: TYPE HERE
Reason: TYPE HERE

Decision: TYPE HERE
Reason: TYPE HERE

Decision: TYPE HERE
Reason: TYPE HERE

Intermediate

[edit]

Decision: TYPE HERE
Reason: TYPE HERE

Decision: TYPE HERE
Reason: TYPE HERE

Decision: TYPE HERE
Reason: TYPE HERE

Decision: TYPE HERE
Reason: TYPE HERE

Advanced

[edit]

Decision: TYPE HERE
Reason: TYPE HERE

Decision: TYPE HERE
Reason: TYPE HERE

Decision: TYPE HERE
Reason: TYPE HERE

Decision: TYPE HERE
Reason: TYPE HERE

Decision: TYPE HERE
Reason: TYPE HERE