User:Gryllida/doc/AfC
This is a template for reviewing WP:AFC submissions.
Why?
[edit]- Even a short comment, by not being a template and by being at least vaguely specific to the article, usually helps the authors to move forward.
- Comprehensive feedback on all aspects of article quality helps the success of the next submission.
How?
[edit]- Select 'custom' and copy-paste, then fill in every field.
- Use 'custom' in the select box rather than shoving your comment down.
- It's usually hard to track which comment is which and I put them into the "this submission is declined" box itself.
- If there's no issues, put "Pass" next to the relevant line; authors might like that something they did was done right.
- Give me feedback when you alter the message. You're encouraged to edit this page directly.
What?
[edit]I am providing more details below. * '''[[WP:Copyright|Copyright]]''': * '''[[Wikipedia:Writing_better_articles#Layout|Article layout and focus]]''': * '''[[WP:Notability|Notability]] and [[Wikipedia:Your_first_article_in_more_detail#Gathering_references|references]]''': * '''[[WP:NPOV|NPOV / Neutral&encyclopedic phrasing]]''': * '''[[Wikipedia:Manual_of_Style|Style and formatting]]''':