User:Geo Swan/Guantanamo/Taliban Bounty list
![]() | This is not a Wikipedia article: It is an individual user's rough notes page, and may be incomplete and/or unreliable. |
See User:Geo Swan/Stale drafts#Scaffolding
The Template:TalibanBounty was nominated for deletion, on September 10th, 2007.
Specious claims
[edit]The nominator claimed the imiage it included had nothing to do with the articles it was trasncluded:
Absent from the articles I have reviewed is any evidence that the poster was involved or even seen by the bounty hunters or other witnesses against the combatants, so we have a WP:OR or WP:SYNTH problem as well.
One of the wikipedians who concurred with the nominator wrote:
...none of the articles I looked at (for reference, I started at the top of the linked articles and went through at least 20) of them reference the poster...
My findings
[edit]So, I have rechecked the first twenty articles that were transcluded. As I suspected, the claims of the nominator, and the other wikipedian, are wildly incorrect.
What I found was:
- Articles that directly quoted from the source where someone had stated the captive was sold fror a bounty -- and referenced at least one verifiable, authorititative source that supported that assertion.
- Articles that both explictly stated that someone had stated, often the captive himself, that he was sold for a bounty -- and referenced at least one verifiable, authorititative source that supported that assertion.
- Articles that explcitly stated that someone had reported the captive was sold for a bounty, where the reference link has expired. (I supplied new references in those cases.)
- Articles where the explicit statement that the captive was sold for a bounty -- but still referenced the captive's testimony, which did support that assertion. That is my bad. I have been busy.
That I applied the image, when I found a reference to the report that the captive was sold for a bounty, without promptly supplying a statement in the body of the article about the bounty was an unfortunate oversight. My apologies.
Referenced, with an explicit statement
[edit]name | supporting reference | supporting quote from wiki article | ||||
Ahcene Zemiri | Zemiri v. Bush |
| ||||
Abu Bakker Qassim | Christian Science Monitor |
| ||||
Abd al Malik Abd al Wahab | Amnesty International |
| ||||
A Profile of 517 Detainees through Analysis of Department of Defense Data | Second Denbeaux Report |
| ||||
Qari Esmhatulla | ARB hearing |
| ||||
Abdullah Khan | CSRT |
| ||||
Guantanamo Bay detention camp | The Guardian |
| ||||
Shahzada (Guantanamo detainee 952) | CSRT |
| ||||
Mohamed Abdullah Al Harbi | CSRT |
| ||||
Nazargul Chaman | CSRT | |||||
Adel Fattough Ali Al Gazzar | csrt |
| ||||
Abdul Rahman Abdullah Mohamed Juma Kahm | CSRT |
| ||||
Khalil Rahman Hafez | CSRT |
| ||||
Mustafa Ahmed Hamlily | CSRT |
| ||||
Abdul Wahab | ARB hearing |
| ||||
Muhammad Hamid Al Qarani | CSRT |
|
I am innocent. I have read all the CSRT, and, with these two captives, it was obvious to me that their capture was rewarded with a bounty. Both of Nasrullah]'s companions reported they were denounced for a bounty. And the only serious allegations against him were based on his assocaiation with them.
Batayev didn't claim he was sold to the Americans. He said he was sold to the Taliban. Several other captives who were held in Mazari Sharif described seeing their Afghan captors being paid for them, by Americans, when they were turned over.
The inclusion of the image in thse two article predates my awareness of WP:SYNTH.
name | supporting reference | supporting quote from wiki article | |
Nasrullah (Guantanamo detainee 951) | CSRT |
| |
Ilkham Turdbyavich Batayev | CSRT |
|
Referenced, but orginally lacking an explicit statement
[edit]name | supporting reference | supporting quote from wiki article | |
Abdul Matin |
| ||
Shabir Ahmed | |||
Omar Rajab Amin | |||
Abdul Halim Sadiqi |
References
[edit]- ^ "Innocent, but in limbo at Guantánamo". Christian Science Monitor.
- ^ Who are the Guantánamo detainees?, Amnesty International
- ^ a b Mark Denbeaux et. all., Report on Guantanamo detainees: A Profile of 517 Detainees (.pdf), Seton Hall University, February 8 2006 Cite error: The named reference "Denbeaux1" was defined multiple times with different content (see the help page).
- ^ Summarized transcripts (.pdf) from Qari Esmhatulla's Administrative Review Board hearing - pages 1-7
- ^ a b Allegations and response (.pdf), from Abdullah Khan's Combatant Status Review Tribunal - pages 59-63
- ^ a b Summarized transcripts (.pdf), from Abdullah Khan's Combatant Status Review Tribunal - pages 14-20
- ^ The allegations were in transcripts the U.S. government released in compliance with a Freedom of Information lawsuit filed by AP."404 error". Retrieved 2006-03-18.
{{cite web}}
: Cite uses generic title (help) - ^ a b Summarized transcripts (.pdf), from Haji Shahzada'sCombatant Status Review Tribunal - pages 88-96
- ^ Summarized transcripts (.pdf), from Mohamed Abdullah Al Harbi'sCombatant Status Review Tribunal - pages 41-50
- ^ Summarized transcripts (.pdf), from Nazargul Chaman'sCombatant Status Review Tribunal - pages 30-34
- ^ Summarized transcripts (.pdf), from Adel Fattough Ali Al Gazzar'sCombatant Status Review Tribunal - pages 22-30
- ^
"Seven home from Guantanamo". Taipei Times. December 17 2006. Retrieved 2007-09-15.
{{cite news}}
: Check date values in:|date=
(help) - ^ Summarized transcripts (.pdf), from Khalil Rahman Hafez'sCombatant Status Review Tribunal - pages 9-10
- ^ Summarized transcripts (.pdf), from Mustafa Ahmed Hamlily'sCombatant Status Review Tribunal - pages 16-20
- ^ Summarized transcript (.pdf), from Abdul Wahab's Administrative Review Board hearing - pages 174-186
- ^ Summarized transcripts (.pdf), from Muhammad Hamid Al Qarani's Combatant Status Review Tribunal - pages 4-7
- ^ Summarized transcripts (.pdf), from Abdul Matin's Combatant Status Review Tribunal - pages 23-50