User:Geo Swan/Guantanamo/OARDEC/Tribunal panels

This is not a Wikipedia article: It is an individual user's rough notes page, and may be incomplete and/or unreliable.

The Office for the Adminstrative Review of Detained Enemy Combatants commissioned multiple Tribunal panels in late 2004 and early 2005, when it oversaw the Combatant Status Review Tribunals of 558 captives present in the camp at that time.

The record shows that at least thirty-four different panels were commissioned during that period. Stephen Abraham, a reserve officer who is a lawyer in civilian life, sat on a panel that was only allowed to convene once. His panel reviewed whether al Ghazzawi should be considered an enemy combatant, and unanimously determined he should not be classified as an enemy combatant.

In September 2007 the Departmenf of Defense published the unclassified documents that arose from the CSR Tribunals of 179 men. Those documents record which panels reviewed sat to perform the review.

Tribunal panels

Tribunal panel 1

panel #	captive	notes
1	Mohamed Ben Moujane

Tribunal panel 2

**Convening order August 2 2004**
panel #	captive	notes
2	Abdallah Saleh Ali Al Ajmi	2 August 2004
2	Atag Ali Abdoh Al-Haj	4 August 2004
2	Gholam Ruhani	31 August 2004
2	Majeed Abdullah	20 August 2004
2	Nayif Abdallah Ibrahim Ibrahim	3 September 2004
2	Abdul Sahir	3 September 2004
2	Fawaz Naman Hamoud Abdullah Mahdi	date redacted
2	Rafiq Bin Bashir Bin Jalud Al Hami	date redacted

Tribunal panel 3

**Convening order 2004**
panel #	captive	notes
3	Fawaz Naman Hamoud Abdullah Mahdi	date redacted

Tribunal panel 4

**Convening order 2004**
panel #	captive	notes
4	Ibrahim Sulayman Muhammad Arbaysh	12 August 2004
4	Bandar Ahmad Mubarak Al Jabari	26 August 2004
4	Nasir Najr Nasir Balud Al Mutayri	27 August 2004
4	Sa'ad Madhi Ha Wash Al-Azmi	3 September 2004
4	Fouad Mahmoud Hasan Al Rabia	6 September 2004
4	Nayif Fahd Mutliq Al Usaymi	7 September 2004
4	Fouzi Khalid Abdullah Al Awda	11 September 2004

Tribunal panel 5

**Convening order August 17 2004**
panel #	captive	notes
5	Omar Khadr	7 September 2004
5	Ali Yahya Mahdi Al Raimi	20 September 2004
5	Bashir Nashir Al-Marwalah	20 September 2004
5	David Hicks	22 September 2004
5	Fizaulla Rahman	22 September 2004
5	Ali Husayn Abdullah Al Tays	24 September 2004
5	Zaban Thaaher Zaban Al Shamaree	24 September 2004
5	Jamil El-Banna	25 September 2004
5	Martin Mubanga	25 September 2004
5	Abdul Aziz Adbullah Ali Al Suadi	25 September 2004
5	Khaled Qasim	27 September 2004
5	Sadeq Muhammad Sa'id Ismail	27 September 2004
5	Yasin Qasem Muhammad Ismail	28 September 2004
5	Muktar Yahya Najee Al Warafi	29 September 2004
5	Faiz Mohammad Ahmed Al Kandari	29 September 2004
5	Abdullah Kamel Abdullah Kamel	30 September 2004
5	Murat Karnaz	30 September 2004
5	Mohommad Zahir	4 October 2004
5	Abd Al Malik Abd Al Wahab	6 October 2004

Tribunal panel 6

**Convening order 13 September 2004**
panel #	captive	notes
6	Adil Said Al Haj Obeid Al Busayss	17 September 2004
6	Mamdouh Ibrahim Ahmed Habib	September 20 2004
6	Musab Omar Ali Al Mudwani	23 September 2004
6	Salman Yahya Hassan Mohammed Rabeii	25 September 2004
6	Adil Kamil Abdullah Al Wadi	26 September 2004
6	Salem Abdul Salem Ghereby	27 September 2004
6	Salah Abdul Rasul Ali Abdul Rahman Al Balushi	28 September 2004
6	Khalid Bin Abdullah Mishal Thamer Al Hameydani	29 September 2004
6	Jamal Muhammad 'Alawi Mar'i	30 September 2004
6	Bensayah Belkacem	1 October 2004 Tribunal reconvened on 15 October 2004
6	Lakhdar Boumediene	1 October 2004
6	Abdul Latif El Banna	9 October 2004

Tribunal panel 7

**Convening order** 13 September 2004
panel #	captive	notes
7	Mohammed Mohammed Hassen	12 October 2004
7	Abdullah Ali Al Utaybi	16 October 2004
7	Ziy Ad Salih Muhammad Al Bahuth	19 October 2004
7	Mustafa Ait Idr	20 October 2004
7	Djamel Said Ali Ameziane	21 October 2004
7	Rashid Awad Rashid Al Uwaydah	24 October 2004
7	Tasbit Vokhidov	28 October 2004
7	Jarallah Al Marri	30 October 2004
7	Mohammed Ahmed Ali Al-Asadi	1 November 2004
7	Ahmad Tourson	5 November 2004
7	Habib Ullah	5 November 2004
7	Mohammed Abdul Rahman	6 November 2004

Tribunal panel 8

**Convening order** 13 September 2004
panel #	captive	notes
8	Uthman Abdul Rahim Mohammed Uthman	September 16 2004
8	Abdul Khaled Ahmed Sahleh Al Bedani	20 September 2004
8	Saeed Ahmed Mohammed Abdullah Sarem Jarabh	20 September 2004
8	Zohair Abdul Mohammed Al-Shorabi	23 September 2004
8	Redouane Khalid	25 September 2004
8	Jalal Salam Awad Awad	27 September 2004
8	Isa Ali Abdulla Almurbati	27 September 2004
8	Majid Mahmud Abdu Ahmad	27 September 2004
8	Faruq Ali Ahmed	September 27 2004
8	Majid Mahmud Abdu Ahmad	27 September 2004
8	Ali Ahmed Mohammed Al Rezehi	29 September 2004
8	Juma Mohammed Abdul Lativ Al Dosari	30 September 2004
8	Emad Abdalla Hassan	30 September 2004
8	Mohammed Fenaitel Mohamed Al Daihani	30 September 2004
8	Mahmoud Abd Al Azia Abd Al Mujahid	October 1 2004
8	Fahmi Abdullah Ahmed	1 October 2004
8	Batayev Turdbyavick Ilkham	5 October 2004

Tribunal panel 9

**Convening order**
panel #	captive	notes
9	Allal Ab Aljallil Abd Al Rahman Abd	date redacted

Tribunal panel 11

**Convening order** 29 September 2004
panel #	captive	notes
11	Feroz Ali Abbasi	7 October 2004
11	Sabir Mahfouz Lahmar	8 October 2004
11	Amin Ullah	9 October 2004

Tribunal panel 12

**Convening order 29 September 2004**
panel #	captive	notes
12	Fahd Salih Sulayman Al Jutayli
12	Khi Ali Gul	date redacted
12	Abdullah Al Tayabi	14 October 2004
12	Yusef Abdullah Saleh Al Rabiesh	9 October 2004
12	Said Muhammad Husayn Qahtani	23 October 2004
12	Aldl Al Nasr	20 October 2004
12	Bahtiyar Mahnut	Convened on 23 October 2004 and 27 October 2004 Tribunal President disputed that he had denied captive 277 due process.
12	Abdul Haq Wasiq	October 25 2004
12	Abd Al Hadi Omar Mahmoud Faraj	29 October 2004
12	Omar Rajab Amin	1 November 2004
12	Ali Bin Ali Aleh	6 November 2004
12	Mohammed Ali Zarnuol	10 November 2004
12	Abdul Rauf Omar Mohammed Abu Al Qusin	12 November 2004
12	Suleman Awad Suleman Bin Agil Alnahdi	12 November 2004
12	Dawut Abdurehim	19 November 2004
12	Abdullah Al-Noaimi	November 21 2004
12	Alif Mohammed	November 21 2004
12	Abdullah Wazir	22 November 2004
12	Hafizullah Shabaz Khul	4 December 2004
12	Abdul Majid Muhammed	10 December 2004
12	FNU Hamidullah	13 December 2004

Tribunal panel 13

**Convening order 4 October 2004**
panel #	captive	notes
13	Abdul Mohammed	6 October 2004
13	Ahmed Rashidi	7 October 2004
13	Salam Abdullah Said	12 October 2004
13	Yusef Modaray	12 October 2004
13	Fahed Nasser Mohamed	14 October 2004
13	Mohammad Lameen Sidi Mohammad	16 October 2004
13	Mohammad Nechle	19 October 2004
13	Nasir Maziyad Abdallah Al Qurayshi Al Asubayi	19 October 2004
13	Mohammed Nasir Yahya Khusruf	25 October 2004
13	Walid Said Bin Said Zaid	26 October 2004
13	Mohammed Ahmad Said Al Edah	28 October 2004
13	Abdallah Ibrahim Al Rushaydan	30 October 2004
13	Said Muhammed Salih Hatim	2 November 2004
13	Mahmud Idris	3 November 2004
13	Fahmi Salem Said Al Sani	4 November 2004

Tribunal panel 15

**Convening order 12 October 2004**
panel #	captive	notes
15	Abdullah Muhammad Al Ghanami	18 October 2004
15	Muhammad Abd Al-Rahman Al-Shumrant	18 October 2004
15	Musa Abed Al Wahab	20 October 2004
15	Abdal Razak Qadir	23 October 2004
15	Mahmud Salem Horan Mohammed Mutlak Al Ali	23 October 2004
15	Saiid Farhi	27 October 2004
15	Adel Fattough Ali Algazzar	29 October 2004
15	Martin Mubanga	unpublished -- a "do-over" -- see 5
15	Ha'il Aziz Ahmad Al Maythal	1 November 2004
15	Salim Mahmoud Adem Mohammed Bani Amir	November 1 2004 See "do-over" -- Tribunal panel 27
15	Maji Afas Radhi Al Shimri	5 November 2004
15	Richard Dean Belmar	10 November 2004
15	Ayman Saeed Abdullah Batarfi	12 November 2004
15	Khalid Abd Jal Jabbar Muhammad Juthman Al Qadasi	13 November 2004
15	Arkina Amahmud	17 November 2004

Tribunal panel 18

**Convening order 1 November 2004**
panel #	captive	notes
18	Abdel Qadir Hussein Al Mudhaffari	9 November 2004 Tribunal not held at Guantanamo
18	Zahar Omar Hamis Bin Hamdoun	10 November 2004
18	Hassan Anvar	First Tribunal, convened on November 16 2004, ruled he was a NLEC. See Tribunal panel 32

Tribunal panel 19

**Convening order 4 November 2004**
panel #	captive	notes
19	Yunis Abdurrahman Shokuri	date redacted
19	Abdul Al-Salam Al Hilal	date redacted
19	Akhtiar Mohammad	date redacted
19	Hassan Adel Hussein	date redacted
19	Mohammad Nabi Omari	date redacted
19	Mohammed Mustafa Sohail	date redacted
19	Mohamed Rahim	2 December 2004
19	Jowad Jabar	3 December 2004
19	Abdul Rahman Shalabi	5 November 2004

Tribunal panel 20

**Convening order**
panel #	captive	notes
20	Mashur Abdullah Muqbil Ahmnad Al Sabri	13 November 2004
20	Rami Bin Said Al Taibi	15 November 2004
20	Salman Ibrahim Al Khalifa	18 November 2004
20	Abdullah Al Anzy	1 December 2004
20	Abd-Al-Nisr Mohammed Khantumani	3 December 2004
20	Mohamedou Ould Slahi	4 December 2004
20	Muhammad Khantumani	9 December 2004

Tribunal panel 21

**Convening order**
panel #	captive	notes
21	Mohammed Ahmad Ghulam Rabbani	17 November 2004
21	Omar Said Salim Al Dayi	17 November 2004
21	Binyam Ahmed Mohammad	22 November 2004
21	Hassan Zumiri	22 November 2004
21	Abdul Al-Rahim Ghulam Rabbani	23 November 2004
21	Nag Mohammed	23 November 2004
21	Anwa Hamdan Muhammed Al-Nur	3 December 2004

Tribunal panel 23

**Convening order**
panel #	captive	notes
23	Abdullah Hamid Abdalsalam Alghazawy	24 November 2004

Tribunal panel 24

**Tribunal panel 24 26 November 2004**
panel #	captive	notes
24	Abdul Zahor	1 December 2004
24	Mohammed Ali Fowza	1 December 2004
24	Sa id Salih Sa id Nashir	8 December 2004
24	Saifullah Paracha	8 December 2004

Tribunal panel 25

**Tribunal panel 25**
panel #	captive	notes
25	Sharif Fathim Al Mushad	15 December 2004

Tribunal panel 26

**Convening order 9 December 2004**
panel #	captive	notes
26	Abdullah Mohammad Khan	Determined to be NLEC on December 15 2004 See 30, 34
26	Abdullah Musahid	December 17 2004
26	Abdul Nasir (Guantanamo captive 874)	17 December 2004
26	Mohammed Mubarek Salah Al Qurbi	29 December 2004

Tribunal panel 27

**Convening order December 9 2004**^[1]
panel #	captive	notes
27	Surajadin Abib	3 December 2004
27	Hussein Salem Mohammed	15 December 2004
27	Rashid Abd Al Muslih Qa id Al Qa id	16 December 2004
27	Abdul Mateen	20 December 2004
27	Chaman	20 December 2004
27	Abdul Rahman	22 December 2004
27	Hassam Al Doubaykhi	28 December 2004
27	Abdul Hakim Abdul Rahman Abduaziz Al Mousa	7 January 2005
27	Salim Mahmoud Adem Mohammed Bani Amir	15 January 2005 a "do-over" -- see Tribunal panel 15

Tribunal panel 29

**Convening order**
panel #	captive	notes
29	Abdelli Muhammad Feghoul	8 January 2005

Tribunal panel 30

**Convening order**
panel #	captive	notes
30	Abdullah Mohammad Khan	Determined to be NLEC on January 21 2005 See 26, 34

Tribunal panel 32

**Convening order 21 January 2005**
panel #	captive	notes
32	Hassan Anvar	January 2005 -- a "do-over"
32	Abdullah Hamid Abdalsalam Alghazawy	January 2005 -- a "do-over"

Tribunal panel 33

**Convening order**
panel #	captive	notes
33	Abdul Zahor	unpublished - see Tribunal panel 24 -- a "do-over"

Tribunal panel 34

**Convening order**
panel #	captive	notes
34	Abdullah Mohammad Khan	Overturned earlier NLEC determination sometime between March 18 2005 and March 21 2005 See 26, 30

References

^ Captive 710]]'s habeas package has this panel's appointment follow some of its meetings.

[1] Captive 710]]'s habeas package has this panel's appointment follow some of its meetings.

[1]