Jump to content

User:GRBerry/Data for Arbitration Enforcement RfC

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Data for the Arbitration Enforcement RFC, based on every 5th archive of WP:AE. Reviewed and prepared by GRBerry, who knows there are three or four "off by one" errors. Discussion of what the data means on a talk page please.

Disposition Summary

[edit]
116 reports in total

Some reports had multiple dispositions - i.e. a block and a topic ban for one editor or a block for one editor and a warning for a second.

17 (15%) not responded to in a timely fashion
  • Not responded to at all - 7
  • Handled elsewhere before WP:AE got to it - 1
  • Response did not get as far as a decision - 5
  • Stale at time of decision - 4
18 (16%) Invalid reports
  • Reported behavior out of scope or erroneously described - 17
  • Off wiki behavior not actionable - 1
34 (30%) No action taken or a warning
  • No action taken or a warning - 24
  • Advice given - 7
  • User put on notice of potential discretionary sanctions - 1
  • Heads up notice given to editors who might have been unaware - 1
  • Admin revert to restore status quo ante under an injunction - 1
35 (30%) Block imposed or kept
  • Block of up to 1 week - 24
  • Block of longer than 1 week - 3
  • Sockpuppets blocked - 6 (in 1 case master given long term ban)
  • Unblock denied - 2
3 (3%) Page protection used
  • Page protection for up to 1 week - 3
13 (11%) Non-standard discretionary sanctions
  • Existing discretionary sanction removed - 1
  • #RR limit imposed or extended - 2
  • Topic ban imposed - 7
  • Mentoring commenced - 1
  • Plan put in place for full page protection and a sandbox if disruption occurs - 1
Snapshot
  • 27 reports, none involving topic area discretionary sanctions
  • March 11 2007 to April 26 2007, 46 days
  • 1 report every 2 days
  • 98K archived; 3.6K per report
Uninvolved admin activity
  • Thatcher worked 19 reports on his own, 3 with New York Brad, 1 each with BucketsofG, Slim Virgin, and TomTheHand.
  • NewYorkBrad worked 1 report on his own and 3 with Thatcher.
  • BucketsofG, TomTheHand and SlimVirgin each worked no reports on their own and 1 with Thatcher.
  • One report was not responded to by anyone uninvolved.
Disposition Summary
  • Not responded to at all - 1
  • Reported behavior out of scope or erroneously described - 6
  • Stale - 2
  • Off wiki behavior not actionable - 1
  • No action taken or a warning - 5
  • Heads up notice given to editors who might have been unaware - 1
  • Block of up to 1 week - 7
  • Block of longer than 1 week - 1
  • Sockpuppets blocked - 3
  • Page protection for up to 1 week - 1
Snapshot
  • 19 reports, 3 involving topic area discretionary sanctions
  • October 24, 2007 to December 21 2007, 58 days
  • 1 report every 3 days
  • 246K archived; 12.9K per report
Uninvolved admin activity
  • Thatcher worked 3 reports on his own, one with JzG and Rlevse, and one each with J Greb, JzG, Steel, and Stifle.
  • Rlevse worked 1 report with AGK and one with Thatcher and JZG
  • JzG worked 2 reports with Thatcher, 1 of which was also with Rlevse
  • Moreschi worked 1 report on his own and 1 with both Shell Kinney and Stifle
  • Shell Kinney worked 1 report on his own and 1 with both Moreschi and Stifle
  • Stifle worked 1 report with Thatcher and 1 with both Moreschi and Shelly Kinney
  • Picaroon worked 1 report on his own and 1 with a non-admin
  • That non-admin worked 1 report on his own without any admin
  • Akradeki, Ioeth, and Ryan Postelthwait each worked 1 report on their own
  • Three reports were not responded to by anyone uninvolved
Disposition Summary
  • Not responded to at all - 3
  • Advice given (includes advice to move to SSP or RFCU) - 7
  • Existing discretionary sanction removed - 1
  • User put on notice of potential discretionary sanctions - 1
  • Reported behavior out of scope or erroneously described - 3
  • Warning - 1
  • Block of up to 1 week - 2
  • Page protection for up to 1 week - 1
  • Expanded authority requested from ArbComm (in addition to lines above) - 1
Snapshot
  • 10 reports, three involving topic area discretionary sanctions
  • February 27, 2008 to March 3, 2008, 5 days
  • 2 reports every 1 days
  • 106K archived; 10.6K per report
Uninvolved admin activity
  • One report worked by Longhair, Future Perfect at Sunrise, Moreschi, MastCell, Lawrence Cohen, GRBerry, Stephan Schulz, jpgordon (as checkuser) and Sandstein
  • One report worked by Lawrence Cohen, Rlevse, Jayvdb, and GRBerry
  • One report worked by Shell Kinney, Jayvdb, and GRBerry
  • One report worked by Jehochman, Moreschi, Stephan Shultz, Seicer, Shell Kinney, MastCell, Rlevse, and Akhilleus
  • Two by GRBerry
  • One by GRBerry & Rlevse
  • One by Moreschi & GRBerry
  • One by Moreschi & Rlevse
Disposition Summary
  • Reported behavior out of scope or erroneously described - 3
  • Admin revert to restore a status quo ante under an injunction - 1
  • No action taken or a warning - 4
  • Block of up to 1 week - 2
  • Sockpuppets blocked & a puppet master given a long term ban - 1
Snapshot
  • 30 reports, 14 involving topic area discretionary sanctions
  • April 13, 2008 to April 22, 2008, 9 days
  • 3.33 reports per day
  • 270K archived; 9K per report
Uninvolved admin activity
  • Tango, Slim Virgin & others (led to the Tango arbitration case) - 1
  • many (a Giano thread) - 1
  • Jossi - 2
  • Rlevse & Jossi - 2
  • Rlevse - 1
  • El C - 1
  • Moreschi & AGK - 1
  • Moreschi & MastCell 1
  • GRBerry, Carcharoth, Lawrence Cohen, Avruch, Philippe & Moreschi - 1
  • GRBerry - 3
  • John Carter & GRBerry - 1
  • John Carter & Hiding - 1
  • Philip Baird Shearer, Stifle & GRBerry - 1
  • Jehochman - 1
  • Raymond arritt - 1
  • Raul654, Raymond arritt, & East718 - 1
  • Raymond arritt, Will Beback, Ice Cold Beer & East718 - 1
  • Raymond arritt, & East718 - 2
  • Raymond arritt, Ice Cold Beer, John Carter & Chetblong - 1
  • Carcharoth, Jehochman & Will Beback - 1
  • Jossi, PhilKnight, Rlevse, & MBisanz - 1
  • Jossi, Seicer, MastCell, Akhilleus, Coren, Rlevse - 1
  • Phillippe, Cary Bass, & GRBerry - 1
  • Not worked at all - 2
Disposition Summary
  • Not responded to at all - 2
  • Response did not get as far as a decision - 2
  • Reported behavior out of scope or erroneously described - 3
  • No action taken or a warning - 7
  • #RR limit imposed or extended - 2
  • Topic ban imposed - 4
  • Block of up to 1 week - 7
  • Block of longer than 1 week - 2
  • Sockpuppets blocked -
  • Unblock denied - 2
  • Page protection for up to 1 week - 1
Snapshot
  • 14 reports, 8 involving topic area discretionary sanctions
  • July 25, 2008 to August 12, 2008, 18 days
  • 1 report per day
  • 209K archived; 15K per report
Uninvolved admin activity
  • Shell kinney & Jossi - 1
  • PhilKnight, WillBeback, Kbthompson & jayjg - 1
  • GRBerry, Akhilleus, Rlevse - 1
  • Future Perfect At Sunrise, Rlevse, Sandstein & jossi - 1
  • Jehochman & Shell Kinney - 1
  • Chet B Long - 1
  • Rlevse - 1
  • GRBerry, Khoikhoi & Rlevse - 1
  • Jossi, Rlevse - 1
  • many (Giano thread) - 1
  • Rlevse & AGK - 1
  • AGK - 1
  • Elonka, Jehochman, GRBerry, Seicer, Shell Kinney, Ronnotel, Rlevse, AGK
  • Lar, JzG, Shell Kinney - 1
  • SirFozzie, Rlevse, jossi - 1
Disposition Summary
  • Response did not reach a decision - 1
  • Reported behavior out of scope or erroneously described - 1
  • Stale - 2
  • No action taken or a warning - 2
  • Topic ban - 3
  • Mentoring commenced - 1
  • Block of up to 1 week - 2
  • Sockpuppets blocked - 2
Snapshot
  • 16 reports, 13 involving topic area discretionary sanctions
  • November 2, 2008 to November 6, 2008, 4 days
  • 4 reports per day
  • 260K archived; 16.25K per report
Uninvolved admin activity
  • Clreland & Jayron32 - 1
  • Risker - 2
  • Jayvdb - 1
  • Cool Hand Luke, Tznkai - 1
  • Rlevse - 1
  • Moreschi - 2
  • Tznkai - 1
  • Tznkai, Seicer - 1
  • Tznkai, Jehochman - 1
  • PhilKnight, Ryan Postelthwait - 1
  • Tznkai, Seraphimblade
  • Tznkai, Black kite, Rockpocket - 1
  • Many (Mantanmoreland case) - 1
  • not responded to - 1
Disposition Summary
  • Not responded to at all - 1
  • Handled elsewhere before WP:AE got to it - 1
  • Response did not result in a decision - 2
  • Reported behavior out of scope or erroneously described - 1
  • No action taken or a warning - 5
  • Block of up to 1 week - 4
  • Plan put in place for full page protection and a sandbox if disruption occurs - 1