Talk:Yamato Hotsuin

Notability issues

I am not going to review this page on the grounds that it probably should not have been created. While this character has the most development out of any other character in the Devil Survivor 2 series, there is not nearly enough reliable external sources to support the write-up of a fairly substantial character creation and reception sections of this article. On top of this, the reception is citing information from a blog which is not acceptable per WP:BLOG. In addition the user who created this page, Arami-re, is also attempting to create a page for Hibiki Kuze who is even less notable than this one already is for the same reasons. These characters are best left to be worked on in the List of Devil Survivor characters page. I will not push for AfD though. The pages should simply be redirected until sufficient notability can be attained albeit the chance is slim since Devil Survivor 2 is an isolated game. —KirtZ^Mail 03:04, 25 April 2014 (UTC)

I managed to expand the reception section a bit. What do you think?Tintor2 (talk) 22:02, 2 May 2014 (UTC)

Nice work, but four external sources (Kotaku, 2 Fandom Post and ANN) is far to little to satisfy WP:GNG especially since they only talk about Yamato's traits in the DS2TA anime and not the game, in a few passing lines. He doesn't have anything that stands out as notable, you know like how Yu Narukami is the P4 main with a lot of discussion or the sources about Kanji Tatsumi's sexuality. If you still feel that the page should be kept you can drop a line at the AfD. —KirtZ^Mail 06:58, 3 May 2014 (UTC)