Talk:Unlocked (Alexandra Stan album)/GA1

GA Review

Article (edit | visual edit | history) · Article talk (edit | history) · Watch

Reviewer: Azealia911 (talk · contribs) 17:51, 4 October 2015 (UTC)

Hello, I'm Azealia911 _talk and I'll be reviewing this article against the good article criteria. A full review is to come within a couple of days, thanks. Azealia911 _talk 17:51, 4 October 2015 (UTC)

General

• There are some really basic grammar issues throughout the article. I advise you make a request for the article to be copy-edited. However, this shouldn't discourage you from altogether trying to improve articles on here. Personally, if I were a 13 year-old Romanian I'd have no idea where to start on creating English Wikipedia articles, you're doing a fantastic job. Everything just needs somewhat fine-tuning. With this being said, comments about grammar and sentence structure will be kept to a bare minimum.

Credits and personnel

• The reference sentence at the beginning of the section needs a full stop.

 Done

• The four opening recording sentences need full stops.

 Done

• Per MoS:DASH, dashes ( - ) should not be used, so replace all instances of them in the section with ( – ) that.

 Done

• There's no need to capitalize after dashes, so change "Songwriter" to "songwriter", apply this to all other fields.

 Done

• Why is there only two instances of (track #)? either use them for all credits or none.

 Done

• Why are songwriters credited under 'Technical credits'? Songwriting isn't technical.

 Done

• 'remixer' isn't a word.

 Done

• Unlink Alexandra Stan in the 'Technical credits' section.

 Done

• Erik Lidbom is credited with 'producer, additional production' why is this? How can he only be 'additional production' but also be a principal producer?

 Done

• When faced with a long list of people who pretty much do the same thing (such as 'technical credits', organize them alphabetically, by last name)

 Done

Charts and sales

• Remove the 'Singles' section alltogether, it's already listed at Alexandra Stan discography and consensus has been to remove these sections in similar discussions.

 Done

• Capitalize the N in None

 Done

Release history

• Countries shouldn't be linked.

 Done

• "U.K." → "UK"

 Done

References

• Most of the titles contain MoS:DASH violations, switch - for – or —

 Done

• Foreign reference titles need translations if possible.

 Done

• The work = value shouldn't be a website.

 Done

• Multiple references need changing (4, 5, 6, 8, 20, 49, 50, 51, 52, 53) are all unreliable.

 Done

• I've reviewed a select few sections, but as you can see, there are a substantial amount of basic errors with lack of referencing, and when there are references for something, it's usually an unreliable, or primary reference. However, PLEASE do not be discouraged. If anything positive has come out of reviewing your articles, it's that I've fallen in love with her music haha. I think the first step would be to request the article be copy-edited as I mentioned above, and then even request someone to help you improve the article (however, I'd discourage asking me as I'd quite like to re-review this when it's been worked on, and if I've worked on it, I can't review it!) Best of luck, Azealia911 _talk 21:48, 5 October 2015 (UTC)