Talk:Something Wicca This Way Goes

Question mark

What evidence is there that the episode title should have the question mark at the end? I checked on TV.com and IMDB.com and both have the episode listed without the question mark. If no one minds I will move the page unless someone can give a reason why the title should have the question mark.--NeilEvans 02:16, 5 February 2007 (UTC)

Isn't the episode's name "Something Wicca This Way Comes"? "Goes" doesn't make any sense.

Um, you did read the Trivia part about how this is a pun on the series premier with the title you say above which itself is a pun on 'Something Wicked This Way Comes' right? Nil Einne 21:30, 12 April 2007 (UTC)

Ending

The info in the article is not particularly clear. Was this shot before or after the series was renewed. Regardless, the following doesn't really make much sense to me:

An alternative ending was written by Brad Kern, he pitched both the alternate ending and the ending that aired on the episode to the writers and cast. They all agreed that the alternate ending wasn't a good one because it involved the deaths of the Charmed Ones, leading it to close after seven seasons.

If the series had not yet been renewed, then surely the choice was do you want to give it a definite ending with the death of the main characters (and thereby rule out any chance of a revival should WB change their minds). Or give it a less definite ending without the death of the main characters (which would allow the series to me revived if WB change their minds). There are two issues here. One is whether to kill off the main characters or make them possibly live happily ever after. The other is whether keep the hopes for the series alive. It seems to me this would have been what was in the minds of the writers and cast. If this was after the series had been renewed, then surely there was no debate Nil Einne 21:36, 12 April 2007 (UTC)