Talk:Samaikhya Andhra
 | This redirect does not require a rating on Wikipedia's content assessment scale. It is of interest to the following WikiProjects: | |||||||||||||
| ||||||||||||||
Support for SA movement in Telangana
[edit]Ramcrk - Let's please discuss this objectively. My points:
1. "There is no political support for this movement in Telangana. Only people in AP who support united Andhra Pradesh are people from Rayalaseema and Coastal Andhra regions and migrants from these regions to Telangana" - Please tell me how this is NOT a POV. 2. "We have not seen even single organized event by Samaikhya Andhra JAC within Telangana." - Agree to this point, but wiki language doesn't permit use of "We" & "I". Please also add reference for this if you can and change language. 3. "Political leaders who support Samaikhya Andhra are finding it difficult to attend any public events in Telangana." - Again, agree with you that such leaders WILL find it difficult to attend any public event in Telangana. But none of them have tried. 4. Jagan Mohan Reddy's Odarpu Yatra is not related to SamaikhyaAndhra movement - Please tell me how is it relevant to mention it here. Similarly CBN's tours in this region is not related to this article. 5. "Only Seema-Andhra politicians attended the meetings organized by this organization." - I disagree because Mr. Teegala Krishna Reddy, an ex-mayor of Hyderabad has attended this meet. 6. I agree that there should be a change in this - This movement has also received support from CERTAIN NRIs settled abroad with AndhraPradeshNRI.org 7. Similarly, we can write SOME Telangana NRIs are not supporting this movement.
Please let's discuss these changes. In good faith, I will not make any edits to this article before we conclude this discussion. Vamsisv (talk) 08:54, 13 December 2010 (UTC)
- Vamsisv, Thanks for discussion.
- A) Your point 2 will explain your point1. I changed the language of as you suggested in point 2. I cleaned up some and added links per your suggestion.
- B) Both of your points 3 and 4 are related. Jagan supported SA movement(in Parliament). CBN changed the stand on Telangana after Dec 9, 2009. Hence they both have trouble attending public events in Telangana. Still I cleaned up some.
- C) Regarding 5, 6, 7; I can say only following. AP people are divided on regional lines. Most of the Telangana community is asking for Telangana. Most of Seema-Andhra community is asking for United AP. There may be few exceptions. You can see the support on the streets, in assembly, in public events etc. But this article, originally, was trying to potray Samaikhya Andhra movement is popular through out the state of AP which is not true. I was trying to correct it and present the truth to the reader. I made some changes here too. Ramcrk (talk) 17:49, 13 December 2010 (UTC)