The following discussion is closed. Please do not modify it. Subsequent comments should be made on the appropriate discussion page. No further edits should be made to this discussion.
Thanks for taking on the review. I look forward to addressing the comments. I'm out of town until Sunday, but I can promptly work on this when I return. CipherSleuth (talk) 17:12, 29 February 2024 (UTC)[reply]
Hi, I have addressed all your comments. Happy to discuss if any points need clarifying or did not meet expectations. Thanks for your time. CipherSleuth (talk) 22:20, 3 March 2024 (UTC)[reply]
Well-written:
Criteria
Notes
Result
(a) (prose)
Reformatting/Replacing:
Use of the word heave in the article is a bit too informal, suggest replacing to throw.
Done
I heavily suggest using timephrases such as "a month later" and "the following year" since the article looks like a timeline rather than an overview.
Done –– I modified a sentences where applicable to use timephrases like you suggested.
12 Indoor Championships, and he secured, replace , and with where.
Fixed –– I copy edited this sentence for clarity and added more citations. (The change isn't exactly as requested because of rewriting the paragraph.)
June 2017, and he competed in..., replace and he with then.
Done
Use of the word he:
Crouser holds the world record..., replace Crouser with He, and add As of [DATE],... on the start of the sentence.
Partly done –– I added a sentence to indicate how long Crouser has held the indoor world record (January 2021). Now, both the indoor and outdoor world records have the date on which they were set.
In his fourth year, the athlete, I suggest using he instead of the athlete but that's on you.
Done
Ryan started participating..., use He instead of Ryan.
Done
Adding text:
Crouser was born on 18 December 1992 in Portland, Oregon, add comma on the end.
Comment: There is already a comma after Oregon. Please clarify if you meant something different.
Adding spaces:
...in Bressanone, Italy.There,..., add between Italy. and There.
Done
Sentences that have shotput to shot put.
Done
Removing words:
he opted to switch his major from engineering, omit he.
Done
(b) (MoS)
Lists in Achievements; I suggest to change to similar list formats such as in Tyson Gay and Yulimar Rojas. Make the list dates in descending order to follow format in alike articles about athletes. Also rename to Major results, International competitions, or something similar instead.
Done –– I added a column to each table in this section with the year, allowing the viewer to sort by year of achievement. I also changed the heading "NCAA competition" to "NCAA championships". All the headings are now consistent with having "competition" in the name, just modified by whether it's global, national, or NCAA.
@CipherSleuth I forgot to mention to make the list in ascending order, starting with older years then working your way to more recent! If this is addressed I believe I can pass it!
I suggest changing Collegiate competition to Collegiate career or something similar. Same with Early life and youth sports to Early life and youth career.
Comment: I changed the heading "Early life and youth sports" to "Early life and youth competition". This makes the heading consistent with collegiate competition and senior competition.
Not done Thanks for pointing this out. I reviewed the MOS and did not identify in this particular usage that it presented a problem.
Inconsistency:
Usage of 18 December 1992 and December 18, 1992, suggest using the "m/d/y" dating format as the article is about an American athlete. See Wikipedia:Manual of Style#Retaining existing styles. Can also be found in 9 February, On 24 January,, 11 August 2021., etc., I suggest following the pattern to be consistent.
Fixed –– All dates changed to m/d/y format.
Use meters instead of metres in the list World Athletics Rankings. Either use only m or meters when being consistent in the article when describing measurements, examples such as throwing 21.21 m to defeat Stephen Mozia..., ...a third of all 22-m throws in the history of the sport., and ...and in Zagreb with 22.09 meters..
Earwig puts up nothing, did a manual spot check nothing to be seen.
Broad in its coverage:
Criteria
Notes
Result
(a) (major aspects)
Everything in the article seems to highlight the athlete's career well.
(b) (focused)
This method adds a lateral stepping motion across the throwing circle, which differs from traditional rotational or glide techniques. It is designed to optimize balance and power, allowing for a more efficient transfer of energy during the throw., somewhat relevant so it's the editors' choice to retain or not.
Comment: I prefer to keep this information. The technique Crouser used to set the world record is written about in several secondary sources about this performance. I think it's also nice to have some additional context about his performances, preventing the article from feeling like a timeline of he did X result, then Y, then Z etc. (which was a good observation you had in an earlier comment to prevent sounding like timeline).
Neutral: it represents viewpoints fairly and without editorial bias, giving due weight to each.
Notes
Result
Reviewer has no notes, everything looks centered to the person with no bias.
Stable: it does not change significantly from day to day because of an ongoing edit war or content dispute.
Notes
Result
Article is stable, no ongoing edit war or content disputes.
Illustrated, if possible, by media such as images, video, or audio:
Criteria
Notes
Result
(a) (images are tagged and non-free images have fair use rationales)
Every image complies.
(b) (appropriate use with suitable captions)
I suggest arranging the images for his campaign at the 2016 Summer Olympics to be a bit more organized.
Comment: I am not sure what to change here. I like the multi-panel image, but I am open to only including one image, rather than two, if you think that look would look cleaner.
Nicknames, height, and weight in the infobox should be included in the body of the article and sourced.
Removed –– Nicknames removed from infobox due to absence of any reliable source to support them.
Done –– Crouser's height and weight have been added to the article (in the training regimen and coaching section) with attribution to source.
Statements that need sources:
He was the first American man to win the event since 2004.
Done
At the 2015 NCAA Outdoor Championships, Crouser placed fifth in both the shotput and the discus.
Done
Crouser won another national title in the shot put in June 2017, and he competed in the event at the 2017 World Championships in London, where he finished sixth. At the 2018 USA Outdoor Championships on 23 June, he placed second with a throw of 20.99 m, behind Darrell Hill's 21.57 m. In the Diamond League, an annual series of international competitions, he won in Eugene with a throw of 22.53 meters, in Monaco with 22.05 meters, and in Zagreb with 22.09 meters.
Done
On 19 July, he resumed competition on at the American Track League Meet, achieving a personal best of 22.91 m and the fourth best mark in history. The American ended the year undefeated in all 11 meets in which he participated.
Done
On 27 February, Crouser finished first in the shot put at the 2022 USA Indoor Track and Field Championships.
Done
Fixed –– I copy edited this sentence for clarity and added more citations. (The change isn't exactly as requested because of rewriting the paragraph.)
Partly done –– I added a sentence to indicate how long Crouser has held the indoor world record (January 2021). Now, both the indoor and outdoor world records have the date on which they were set.
Comment: There is already a comma after Oregon. Please clarify if you meant something different.
Not done Thanks for pointing this out. I reviewed the MOS and did not identify in this particular usage that it presented a problem.
Removed –– Nicknames removed from infobox due to absence of any reliable source to support them.