Jump to content

Talk:Retail/Archives/2019

Page contents not supported in other languages.
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia


What happened to the retail apocalypse?

Sad Icecreammac (talk) 03:58, 19 January 2019 (UTC)

Global top ten retailers

The following table, which appears in the article, needs to be removed entirely. It is constructed from different sources which report revenues in different years. Because it is a ranked list, it needs to report data from a single source in a defined period.

  • 1. In the literature, there are several different market research companies that provide estimates of retail sales, but these estimates are based on different data collection methods and different approaches to estimation. Therefore data from these sources cannot be combined.
  • 2. Over the past 2 years various editors updating the data for one or more companies with more recent estimates, but fail to supply their sources or alternatively simply replacing one of the existing companies with their preferred company. These apparent "minor" alternations have consequential changes for the rankings in the entire list. Tables that need to be updated annually are very problematic in Wikipedia, because few editors are willing to maintain the update process. In other words, the way that the table is currently reported, it provides paid editors and POV pushers with too many opportunities to list their favourite company, and delete close rivals.
  • Finally, members of the "tag team" repeatedly add "citation needed" tags to individual rows, columns or cells - something that should be entirely unnecessary if the table were constructed from a single source.

I checked the entire table about 6 months ago, and it was accurate and up-to-date, but since then there have been a number of minor changes, but I am unwilling to check its accuracy every time an editor wants to add their favourite source or company to the list. In spite of this, the table is apparently so bothersome to some editors that it is subject to constant changes, and the addition of citation needed tags. The simple solution is to delete a table that arguably adds very little to the article's overall value, contains inconsistent data and cannot be maintained on an ongoing basis. A alternative service that could be provided to readers is to link to those market research companies such as Nielsen that provide industry accepted estimates of global retail sales. (The only downside to the last suggestion is that the good folk from Wikipedia External Links would almost certainly oppose it on the basis that it consistutes an "embedded link".

Worldwide top ten retailers[1]
Rank Company Country of origin 2017} revenue ($US billion)[2] Dominant format 2015 Number of countries of operation 2015
1 Walmart  United States $500.34[3] Hypermarket/Supercenter/Superstore 30
2 Amazon  United States $177.86[4] Non-Store 14
3 Walgreens Boots Alliance  United States $131.5[5] Drug Store/Pharmacy 10
4 Costco  United States $129.0[6] Cash & Carry/Warehouse Club 10
5 Kroger  United States $122.66[7] Supermarket 1
6 Schwarz Gruppe (Lidl)  Germany $110.05[8] Discount Store 26
7 The Home Depot  United States $100.9[9] Home Improvement 4
8 Carrefour  France $89.63[10] Hypermarket/Supercenter/Superstore 35
9 Tesco  United Kingdom $72.96[11] Hypermarket/Supercenter/Superstore 10
10 Aldi  Germany $69.18[12] Discount Store 17

References

  1. ^ "2017 Top 250 Global Retailers". Retrieved 26 April 2017.
  2. ^ "STORES Top Retailers 2018 - STORES: NRF's Magazine". STORES: NRF's Magazine. Retrieved 2018-11-08.
  3. ^ "Walmart", Wikipedia, 2018-11-08, retrieved 2018-11-08
  4. ^ "Amazon (company)", Wikipedia, 2018-11-07, retrieved 2018-11-08
  5. ^ "Walgreens Boots Alliance", Wikipedia, 2018-11-04, retrieved 2018-11-08
  6. ^ "Costco", Wikipedia, 2018-11-07, retrieved 2018-11-08
  7. ^ "Kroger", Wikipedia, 2018-11-07, retrieved 2018-11-08
  8. ^ "Schwarz Gruppe", Wikipedia, 2018-10-30, retrieved 2018-11-08
  9. ^ "The Home Depot", Wikipedia, 2018-10-31, retrieved 2018-11-08
  10. ^ "Carrefour", Wikipedia, 2018-11-05, retrieved 2018-11-08
  11. ^ "Tesco", Wikipedia, 2018-11-07, retrieved 2018-11-08
  12. ^ "Aldi Group revenue in Germany 2017 | Statistic". Statista. Retrieved 2018-11-08.