Talk:Pleinair

This article was nominated for deletion on 16 September 2008 (UTC). The result of the discussion was no consensus.

"Quite often, her age has been mistaken, and fans claim her to be around 9-10 years old in human years. This is in fact not true, and has been proven so by Takehito Harada himself. Those who can read Kanji can see this for themself in the November 2005 archive in his blog, where he makes a comment about it, before this page had been revised to not including that piece of false information. You can find the link to his blog on his website, found below."

The last two sentences are something to be explained on this talk page, not in the actual article. I took them out for this reason.

Rumor or insight?

Some time ago (enough to forget the link) i found a forum thread that said that a plenair manga was being made. Now im sure this is most likely just a baseless rumor since someone might have unknowingly mistaken doushinji for official manga... but the pictures they posted in the forum were rather, high grade quality drawings (also had cover, etc.) so, does anyone have any info on this?? im sorry i cant provide a link, this happened a while ago. —Preceding unsigned comment added by 200.89.158.147 (talk) 14:38, 24 January 2008 (UTC)[reply]

If you are still searching for this, I believe you may be mistaking it with the Pleinair Handbook. At least four of the pages in it are done in a colored manga format. It doesn't really go anywhere, but it's full of nice depictions of Pleinair. BerserkLeon (talk) 12:46, 20 September 2008 (UTC)[reply]

Plenair

Article seems quite, well, subjective and extremely biased. Consider rephrasing entire article.

Pleinair's voice bubble

The symbol that is in her voice bubble, what is it supposed to mean? Is it a kanji, or has Haradaya been asked about it or mentioned it? (I'm sure he has)

http://hompyr.jocoso.jp/nfs/hp/blob4/623/115/0/115623/art/404/17/1/1017404/2/u7e3NO_RESIZED.jpg

It appears in this photo on the back of the car (i'm not sure about restrictions linking to Haradaya's artwork which is why I linked to the figurine instead).

Signature?

I believe the bubble is Harada's signature. It'd make sense, as it's in nearly all of his pictures.

-Either his signature or a symbol representing his signature, since it's not hiragana or katakana and really doesn't look like any kanji.

It's a stylized "H.Y." representing his last name and the nickname monicker on the end, "Haradaya." Skeletonbrain 00:34, 8 July 2007 (UTC)[reply]

Overhaul

A majority of the content of this article was non-encyclopedic fluff, so I took it upon myself to redo it. I think it was an improvement. Skeletonbrain 06:06, 10 November 2006 (UTC)[reply]

Redirect

I just wanted to voice my support for the redirect done by User:A Man In Black, even though it's already been done. I think that's reflected in the AFD too, where there was no consensus for a delete but a redirect seemed like an appropriate compromise. If someone wants to add more information about Pleinair, I might suggest creating a section in an existing article. Randomran (talk) 17:04, 17 October 2008 (UTC)[reply]