Jump to content

Talk:Palaestina Secunda

Page contents not supported in other languages.
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Nothing on Peraea! Map is wrong!

[edit]

See Talk:Perea#More about 390-630s: Palaestina Prima?. Needs to be fixed.

The current map used for all 3 provinces - Palaestina Prima, Palaestina Secunda, Palaestina Tertia and probably more - SEEMS to (probably wrongly) include Perea into Pal. II! Map must be redrawn. Arminden (talk) 3 July 2024

The Jordan (blue line) is not doubled anywhere by a black line indicating a border, most of it seems to be within Pal. II (although the half of Samaria seen on the map as in Pal. II is never mentioned in the text!), but its southernmost segment is where Pal. I and Pal. II seem to meet on the map, and there it's particularly needed. As it is now, Perea can be seen as part of either of Pal. I or Pal. II, more likely Pal. II, as it is at least on the same side of the Jordan, but this is either wrong and Perea was part of Pal. I, or impossible to say based in what we know.
The southern boundary of Palaestina Secunda is not clearly defined in the article text (as opposed to the map), but seems to be further north of Perea, judging from what's written so far - Pella!. Arminden (talk) 16:23, 18 February 2025 (UTC)[reply]