Jump to content

Talk:Order of Air Merit

Page contents not supported in other languages.
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

All the facts of this order were take in two sources, one in english from Medals of the Dominican Republic, International Electronic Phaleristic Encyclopedia, and the other in spanish from the dominican Law number 3351 of the year 1952 that created the Order of Air Merit.

I help me in the traslation. Almost all the facts were corroborate with Law (in spanish).

To avoid any copyright issue and until can be expanding it, I propose change the article for the follow:

The Order of Air Merit was established on 3 August 1952. It's a military decoration of the Dominican Republic to awarded member of the Dominican Air Force. The Head of State confer the order.

It's divided in three divisions to recognize services to the air force:

  • Red ribbon: for combat or war service awarded in four classes.
  • Blue ribbon: for long and faithful service awarded in four classes.
  • White ribbon: for other service awarded in four classes

—Preceding unsigned comment added by Drawdennep (talkcontribs)

I have fixed the copyvio. Smile a While (talk) 22:45, 3 September 2008 (UTC)[reply]

Thanks for the help. And sorry for didn't sign. Drawdennep (talk) 14:03, 4 September 2008 (UTC)[reply]

Confusing information, unreliable sources

[edit]

How can there be a differential order of precedence for the three different Order(s) of Merit for the various branches of the armed forces of the Dominican Republic? According to the articles for the Air Force's Order of Air Merit, the Army's Order of Military Merit (Dominican Republic) and the Navy's Order of Naval Merit (Dominican Republic), the Army's is higher than the Air Force's, while the Navy's is higher than both.

This is dramatically different from the US Armed Forces showing the four different Cross awards as being equivalent to each other: the Army's Distinguished Service Cross, the Air Force / Space Force Air Force Cross, the Navy / USMC Navy Cross, and the Coast Guard's Coast Guard Cross. Not saying that they can never be different orders of precedence, but seems unlikely, so need an explanation as to why as the only difference across the Dominican awards appears to be the year when they were created.

Does not help that the cited sources in the articles for the Dominican awards are dead links, one of them a link to an organization that does not come up on any web search - the supposed International Electronic Phaleristic Encyclopedia (IEPE). Furthermore, the archived IEPE citation even states that "No special assertion is offered that these awards are listed in the correct order and all additional information is welcomed." Very confusing information, from unreliable sources.

Perhaps there is some overall believe in Dominican military ranks that some branches are less important, or the actions of their service people less meritorious, than others? If so, this still needs to be explained, with citations, in these articles and the associated article Orders, decorations, and medals of the Dominican Republic. If not, then all these articles are in need of a major adjustment to their "Order of precedence" information. Jmg38 (talk) 00:24, 30 August 2022 (UTC)[reply]