Talk:Killy

From Wikipedia:Requested moves

Killy (disambiguation) → Killy — Killy was incorrectly the title page for a character in Blame!, and I think "Killy" should be the page name for the disambiguation page. ~I'm anonymous

It looks like Killy (Blame!) is the primary topic; none of the others is particularly known by that name. --Stemonitis 09:15, 5 May 2007 (UTC)[reply]

{sighs} - if that were that true, why would there be a disambiguation page? I still support this move, its easier to just type "Killy" and be led to a disambiguation. The reason why the others aren't particularly known by that name is because those articles *suck now, and have yet to be expanded. ~I'm anonymous

The question that must be asked is: "what will a reader expect to find when he/she types 'Killy'?" If the majority of cases are likely to be the Blame! character, then that article should be at Killy. If it's Kilmarnock, then Killy should redirect to Kilmarnock. If two or more are similarly likely, then it should be a disambiguation page. It is not "easier to be led to a disambiguation" if that requires an extra click to reach the intended target of Killy (Blame!) (for instance). You need to demonstrate that the Blame! character is not clearly the primary meaning in order to make the move reasonable. In my opinion, anyway. --Stemonitis 12:00, 5 May 2007 (UTC)[reply]

Resolved

Following discussion at my talk, I concede that the dab page belongs at Killy, and have moved it. --Stemonitis 19:30, 5 May 2007 (UTC)[reply]