Talk:Khaksar movement/Archive 1

Archive 1

untitled comments

This article needs wikification, I don’t think you should disagree with me. So don’t remove tab "wikify" and "context". They both will make this article good for reading. The only problem is tag "NPOV". Again, it is not making this article irrelevant. It is just saying that material in it may not be balanced. Again, I don’t think you should worry about it, as it will not make it irrelevant. I hope you understand. These tags will make this article more useful and a good read. Don’t worry about it. Also you added allama mashriqi link, I did not remove it, because using this link, we can improve this article. --Spasage 05:27, 25 March 2006 (UTC)

What is wikification? You are putting the tags unnecessarily. The tags make the article irrelevant. It is very disturbing to note that someone is putting the tabs without any justification. I hope you will understand the concern, which is being expressed here. It is expected that the tag will be removed asap. If you think the article is no good, you may remove it. If you insist on putting the tags, the article will be removed. There is no need to exchange anymore notes on the subject.

No one will remove this article. I'll not let anybody do this. These tags are meant to improve this article. You don’t have to worry about it. Links you have added some time back are relevant. Don’t worry; no one will remove this article. This is good article, but need some work, these tags allow it to be a good read. --Spasage 12:36, 27 March 2006 (UTC)

Attention: webmaster wikipedia Someone is adding objectionable tags such as “The neutrality of this article is disputed”. Is it someone from wikipedia putting these tags? Please advise how to resolve this issue. What is wikification? What needs to be done to remove all tags?

Yes, someone from wikipedia is adding these tags. Please do not remove them. "Neutrality" means that the article isn't PRO or CON toward the subject matter, but Neutral. This article is not currently an encyclpiac article, it is trying to influence someone reading it rather than inform. The Wiki tag means to format the article in the standard formats of Wikipedia. The Context means that frankly this article doesn't make sense to outsiders (like me). I almost don't understand what this article is about at all. The best articles have multiple users editing them to come to a Neutral article. Please do not remove the tags until the issues have been properly addressed. The tags explain what to do. If you want write a non-neutral article, please do so on your own webspace. Denaar 04:46, 3 April 2006 (UTC)

Correct !!!!!!! --Spasage 07:56, 3 April 2006 (UTC)

There are so many articles on your web site without references or sources.Why are you making an exception here? One must not be biased.

The article does not have any issues. If you have any genuine issue, please provide full details with references. The references must be credible. A person who puts these objectionable tags must provide proof of his/her knowledge on the subject. How do I know whether the person has any knowledge about Khaksar Tehreek ? How do I know, he/she is not biased? It seems someone is biased towards Khaksar Tehreek. Because I have seen articles on this web site with different issues but I do not see any tags. Policy must not be discriminatory and dictatorial. At the end I would say, please do not make up issues.

Language like "to revive the lost glory of ..." is clearly POV.

Point out all the POVs

There is nothing wrong with the article.

I do not see any new comments here. Your objection were removed longtime ago.

Cleanup tags

Hello

Although Wikipedia:Template_messages/Cleanup says "tags ... should be placed at the top of the article", I am adding the "introrewrite" and "nofootnotes|article" tags to this talk page because reading the above comments it seems they will offend the main author. Also, Wikipedia:Template_namespace says "Templates that provide information only of service to editors belong on an article's talk page." - Open4D 23:06, 30 November 2007 (UTC)