Jump to content

Talk:François Adriaan van der Kemp

Page contents not supported in other languages.
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia


Removed quotes

[edit]

I removed the quotes section for several reasons:

  1. These quotes are unattested in primary source material, so far as I can determine.
  2. Who is "Harry F. Jackson" and what places him as a reliable source? I can narry find a single-paragraph biograph of the man, much less a CV.
  3. This work by Jackson is sufficiently obscure that it is not generally available for someone to peruse and see if these quotes actually exist within it.
  4. Even if they do, where do they come from? What is their provenance?
  5. Wikipedia is not Wikiquote.
  6. That all the quotes come from this one source is highly dubious, and suggests someone trying to inject particular ideas into the article, disproportionate to their relevance or proven authenticity.

--75.58.83.74 (talk) 02:29, 3 July 2008 (UTC)[reply]