Talk:Faris Scherwiz/GA1

GA Review

Article (edit | visual edit | history) · Article talk (edit | history) · Watch

Reviewer: Harrias (talk · contribs) 11:57, 22 September 2019 (UTC)[reply]

Overall, a nice tidy piece of work. Detailed review to follow, but I doubt there will be much! Harrias ^talk 11:57, 22 September 2019 (UTC)[reply]

Lead

Possibly worth linking antagonist and protagonist in the opening sentence.
- Fixed
"She was born Princess Sarisa Scherwil Tycoon, but is lost.." Keep the tense consistent; if she was born, then she was lost.
- Fixed
"She joins the quest to understand why protagonist Lenna Charlotte Tycoon has the same pendant as her." Is the quest to discover why Lenna Charlotte Tycoon has the same pendant as her, or did she join their quest with her own, separate, aim of finding that out?
- Fixed

Concept and creation

The infobox mentions Emily O'Brien as the English voice, but this isn't mentioned in the body.
- Fixed

Appearances

"..but decides to help them in their quest to find the Wind Shrine when she realizes that she and Lenna share the same pendant. She joins the quest to find King Tycoon.." Does she join the quest to find King Tycoon after they find the Wind Shrine, or alongside it, or to the same final goal? I'm a little confused that she has joined two quests.
- Fixed
"..to protect the other Crystals." What Crystals? This seems to be their first mention. More explanation needed.
- Fixed
"Her true gender is discovered by Bartz and Galuf, and is later shown a vision.." Her true gender is shown a vision? Assume this is missing a word.
- Fixed
"Faris admits to Lenna that they are sisters.." When did she discover that they were sisters? That revelation has not been mentioned.
- Fixed
"..and they discover King Tycoon on their way to find the Earth Crystal who attacks the group." Who attacks the group? King Tycoon or the Earth Crystal? Unclear.
- Fixed
"..where he shatters this world's Crystals.." "this" is the wrong world: Final Fantasy is not in this world that we live in, after all.
- Fixed. But can you be sure it's not in our world? [1]
"Faris returns to Tycoon to serve as Queen.." Is Tycoon also a location, as well as the family name?
- Yes, fixed for clarity.
"She appears in World of Final Fantasy as a supporting character, where she is given her first voiced role." I'm confused about the timeline here, is she voiced in World of Final Fantasy before she is voiced in Final Fantasy V?
- Yes, though I removed it due to being sourced to btva.

Reception

"..also regarded Faris highly among its case," Is "case" the right word here?
- Fixed typo

References

What makes behindthevoiceactors.com a reliable source?
- Replaced
Provide page numbers for ref #2, Kohler, Chris (2017).
- Added
Are there any further details for ref #4? A page number as a minimum, and ideally volume or issue number would be ideal?
- Sadly, specific information is hard to come by for Japanese sources, and that is the most I could glean.
Ref #19, Musashi. "Final Fantasy Anthology" needs publisher details.
- Fixed
As does ref #21, Juba, Joe. "Final Fantasy V Advance".
- Fixed

Right, that should be the lot. Nothing major in the prose as expected, just some tidying up to make a few things clearer. A bit more work than I realised in the referencing, but shouldn't be anything too arduous. I'll stick this on hold and watch the page, but feel free to ping me. Harrias ^talk 16:30, 24 September 2019 (UTC)[reply]

I believe I've responded to/addressed all issues. - Bryn (talk) (contributions) 02:37, 25 September 2019 (UTC)[reply]

Nice speedy work on this, it all looks good now. Harrias ^talk 06:42, 25 September 2019 (UTC)[reply]