Jump to content

Talk:Debrune

Page contents not supported in other languages.
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

I'm quite certain most of this article is utter bogus. According to official sources nothing is known about Debrune sociaty or what happened to them, and I'm not sure the "romulan historians purged debrune refferences" section is true either. Being a guest I'm rather hesitant to delete large sections, But basicly only the first and last sentence are completely factual. I suggest just copying the memory alpha article.

First - everyone is encouraged to make edits so being a guest shouldn't stop you. Second, please ensure you sign your comments by using four ~ signs so it tags your comments with your username and date like this Rmkf1982 15:53, 27 December 2006 (UTC).[reply]
I'm inclined to agree with you that most of this article doesn't seem to be verifiable - i checked the Star Trek Encyclopedia and there's no mention of a lot of the information in this article. However, I didn't want to delete it out of hand - instead I've made an attempt to rewrite it with a more out of universe perspecitive (not sure if I succeeded or not, please have a look and maybe leave me comments on my talk page as this is my first such rewrite and suggestions would be welcome for future use). I've also added a reference section.
I don't know if anyone is watching this page but if so what do you all think about the comments by the anonymous user above - should we just eliminate a lot of the middle sections entirely. If the original author is reading this can you add references / sources if possible. thanks. Rmkf1982 15:53, 27 December 2006 (UTC)[reply]

P.S. should this article be renamed "Debrune (Star Trek)"??? Rmkf1982 15:55, 27 December 2006 (UTC)[reply]