Jump to content

Talk:Abigail Doyle

Page contents not supported in other languages.
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Edit 8/20/18

[edit]

This page has a lot of information and potential considering Dr. Doyle is an active chemist currently. I attempted to clean up the page so it didn't sound so much like it was written from the perspective of a person within the research group. I also removed redundancies and unnecessary hyperlinks. I attempted to add citations to uncited sentences, but those citations are a work in progress. My one question comes from the sentence " Doyle also co-authored a Chemical Review article on hydrogen-bond donor catalysis, which has received more than 1200 citations so far". Although this is a serious feat, it hardly seems to add value to the page. I left it in the page, but I would love to hear feedback on whether it should stay there. Great page with great organization, thank you for your contribution! Aegolliher (talk) 04:31, 21 August 2018 (UTC)[reply]

I think the Chemical Review part was added as a nod towards the academic notability guidelines - well-cited publications is evidence of being a notable academic. I think Doyle's career stands on its own without it...but I didn't think it hurt the page (a previous writer put it in). Thanks for looking through it!

Claire.jarvis42 (talk) 17:12, 21 August 2018 (UTC)[reply]