Strong Mayors, Building Homes Act
| Strong Mayors, Building Homes Act, 2022 | |
|---|---|
| Legislative Assembly of Ontario | |
| Citation | S.O. 2022, c. 18 |
| Territorial extent | Toronto, municipalities designated under O. Reg. 530/22 |
| Royal assent | September 8, 2022 |
| Introduced by | Minister of Municipal Affairs and Housing Steve Clark |
| Related legislation | |
| Municipal Act, 2001 City of Toronto Act, 2006 | |
| Status: In force | |
The Strong Mayors, Building Homes Act is a statute in Ontario that grants extra powers to the Mayor of Toronto and the mayors of other designated municipalities within their mayor–council governments.
Powers granted
[edit]Previously, all Ontario mayors had little to no direct unilateral power, with the role largely limited to chairing council meetings, appointing committee chairs and performing ceremonial duties. All decisions had to be approved by council via a majority vote. Mayors generally did have considerable soft power in terms of influence over council, however they could still be overruled if a majority of council disagreed with their actions. This system can be defined as a "weak-mayor" system. [1][2]
Under the Act, the provincial government could designate municipalities to use an alternative "strong-mayor" system. Under this, the mayors of designated municipalities would be granted direct control over the following matters:[1]
- Drafting of the city budgets, which would normally done by a council committee
- The appointment and dismissal of city managers and department leaders (except for police chiefs, fire chiefs, and auditors general)
- The creation, dissolution and reorganisation of municipal administrative departments
- Veto power over by-laws that may conflict with priorities defined by the provincial government, which may be overridden by a two-thirds supermajority of council
Initially, the cities designated under this system included Toronto and Ottawa. This was later expanded to include numerous other municipalities.[3]
In terms of Toronto, the "strong-mayor" powers are defined directly in the City of Toronto Act and can only be revoked by an Act of Provincial Parliament.[4] As for other municipalities, the designation is done by Order-in-Council and defined in regulation, meaning the "strong-mayor" powers can granted or revoked by the provincial government at will.[5] The "provincial priorities" which relate to the mayor's veto power are also defined in regulation.[6]
Expansion (Better Municipal Governance Act, 2022)
[edit]On December 8, 2022, the Ontario legislature passed the Better Municipal Governance Act, 2022, which expanded the "strong-mayor" powers. Particularly, it added the ability to pass a by-law with only one-third support of council if it relates to priorities defined by the provincial government.[7]
The ability to pass certain by-laws with only one-third support of council was criticized by political experts as being highly undemocratic, noting that no other established democracy is known to have a mechanism which allows for laws to be passed with only minority legislative approval.[8]
Reactions
[edit]John Tory, the mayor of Toronto at the time, expressed appreciation for the powers granted to him under the act.[1]
All five living former Toronto mayors, David Crombie, David Miller, Barbara Hall, Art Eggleton and John Sewell, wrote a letter to Tory describing the new powers as an "attack" on local democracy and majority rule.[9] The Ford government defended the new powers by pointing out the mayor's "city-wide mandate", having received more votes than the rest of council.[10]
Outgoing Ottawa mayor Jim Watson deemed the powers unnecessary, also opining that "if they have to gather up two-thirds of their members to overturn a mayor's decision that's not really democratic at all." Mayoral candidate Catherine McKenney also criticised the reforms as "undemocratic."[11]
Former Hamilton mayor Bob Bratina expressed support for the powers. Andrea Horwath, a mayoral candidate, opposed the powers.[12]
Bonnie Crombie, the then-mayor of Mississauga, voiced opposition to the Act. Despite this, in October 2023 she would invoke the one-third power to pass a bill permitting the construction of fourplexes.[13]
Designated municipalities
[edit]All municipalities (except for Toronto) are defined in O. Reg. 530/22.[5]
- Town of Ajax
- Town of Aurora
- City of Barrie
- City of Belleville
- Town of Bradford West Gwillimbury
- City of Brampton
- City of Brantford
- City of Burlington
- Town of Caledon
- City of Cambridge
- Municipality of Chatham-Kent
- Municipality of Clarington
- Town of East Gwillimbury
- Town of Georgina
- City of Greater Sudbury
- City of Guelph
- Town of Halton Hills
- City of Hamilton
- Town of Innisfil
- City of Kawartha Lakes
- City of Kingston
- City of Kitchener
- City of London
- City of Markham
- Town of Milton
- City of Mississauga
- City of Niagara Falls
- City of North Bay
- Town of Oakville
- City of Oshawa
- City of Ottawa
- City of Peterborough
- City of Pickering
- City of Richmond Hill
- City of Sarnia
- City of Sault Ste Marie
- City of St Catharines
- City of Thunder Bay
- City of Toronto (under the City of Toronto Act)
- City of Vaughan
- City of Waterloo
- City of Welland
- Town of Whitby
- Town of Whitchurch-Stouffville
- City of Windsor
- City of Woodstock
References
[edit]- ^ a b c "How will Toronto and Ottawa's new 'strong mayor' powers work?". CBC. October 5, 2022. Retrieved October 23, 2022.
- ^ The Canadian Press (October 17, 2022). "Strong mayor powers coming to more large Ontario cities in a year, Ford says - CBC News". CBC News. Retrieved October 23, 2022.
- ^ "Doug Ford says he'll extend strong-mayor powers beyond Toronto and Ottawa next year". The Toronto Star. October 17, 2022. Retrieved October 23, 2022.
- ^ City of Toronto Act, 2006, S.O. 2006, c. 75, Sched. A (City of Toronto Act, 2006 at Government of Ontario)
- ^ a b O. Reg. 530/22: PART VI.1 OF THE ACT, S.O. 2001, c. 25
- ^ O. Reg. 580/22: PROVINCIAL PRIORITIES, S.O. 2001, c. 25
- ^ Better Municipal Governance Act, 2022, S.O. 2022, c. 24
- ^ Keenan, Edward (2022-12-08). "'Good luck, Toronto': Our new minority-rule mayor law leaves global experts baffled". thestar.com. Retrieved 2024-04-15.
- ^ "Former mayors of Toronto pen letter to Mayor John Tory, urging him to reject strong-mayor powers". thestar.com. 2022-11-20. Retrieved 2023-01-10.
- ^ "Why did John Tory get more 'strong-mayor' powers? Because of his 'city-wide mandate,' Ford government argues". thestar.com. 2022-11-24. Retrieved 2023-01-10.
- ^ "'A solution looking for a problem': Ottawa's mayor says 'strong mayor' powers not needed". CTV News. August 10, 2022. Retrieved October 23, 2022.
- ^ "Hamilton candidates split on 'strong mayor' powers". thespec.com. October 21, 2022. Retrieved October 23, 2022.
- ^ "Mississauga mayor overrules council, to use 'strong mayor' powers to allow fourplexes". CBC News. 2023-10-23.