James French (murderer)

James French
French's 1965 mugshot photo.
Born	James Donald French (1936-06-16)June 16, 1936 Peoria, Illinois, U.S.
Died	August 10, 1966(1966-08-10) (aged 30) Oklahoma State Penitentiary, McAlester, Oklahoma, U.S.
Cause of death	Execution by electrocution
Criminal status	Executed
Conviction(s)	First degree murder (2 counts)
Criminal penalty	Life imprisonment (Boone murder) Death (Shelton murder)
Details
Victims	Frank Boone Eddie Shelton

James Donald French (June 16, 1936 – August 10, 1966) was an American double murderer who was the last person executed under Oklahoma's death penalty laws prior to Furman v. Georgia, which suspended capital punishment in the United States from 1972 until 1976.

French was convicted of the 1961 murder of Eddie Lee Shelton, his cellmate, while he was serving a sentence of life imprisonment for a separate 1958 murder of a motorist named Frank Boone. French ultimately faced trial three times for Shelton's murder, with his sentence being overturned twice; French requested a death sentence and waived his appeals, fighting multiple efforts from attorneys hired by third parties to spare his life despite application of the death penalty otherwise being at a near standstill in Oklahoma and the United States as a whole.

Aside from being the final person executed in Oklahoma before the Furman v. Georgia ruling, French was the third-to-last person executed in the United States prior to the ruling, surpassed only by Aaron Mitchell in California and Luis Monge in Colorado, who were respectively executed in April 1967 and June 1967. French was the only person executed in the United States in 1966.

Background and murders

French was born on June 16, 1936, and adopted by a couple from Peoria, Illinois, Mr. and Mrs. C.D. French, 19 days after he was born. When French was five years old, he allegedly stabbed a man who he believed was flirting with his mother. When he was a second grade elementary student, he attempted an arson attack on a schoolhouse. Later, after "a forged check spree," he was committed to a psychiatric hospital in Illinois for six months. Later, he was committed to a federal reformatory in Ohio for a 19-month stint. He moved to California and attempted to find work as a racecar driver but was eventually barred from this line of work. Overall, prior to the murder which landed him in prison with a life sentence, French was committed to psychiatric hospitals three times, including one stint in the Eastern State Hospital in Vinita, Oklahoma. While reflecting on these visits, French told reporter Bob Gregory that every commital ended with authorities ultimately finding him mentally sane.

Murder of Franklin Boone

At the time of the murder for which French was executed, French was serving a life sentence in the Oklahoma State Penitentiary in McAlester for killing Franklin R. Boone, a 24-year-old West Virginia motorist who had offered French a ride from Amarillo, Texas, to Oklahoma while French was hitchhiking, in December 1958. French had pleaded guilty to Boone's murder and requested a death sentence for that charge, but the court handed down a life sentence in 1959 anyway, against his wishes, likely due to a plea deal between his court-appointed attorney and the prosecutor trying his case. Dismayed, French wrote several letters to the governor asking for a new trial, one in which he could obtain a death sentence, but authorities did not answer his letters.

Murder of Eddie Shelton

While serving his life sentence, French was placed with inmate Eddie Lee Shelton. The two did not get along, in addition to French growing tired of prison life. French would later state that he determined Shelton "wasn't fit to live. He deserved to die".

On October 27, 1961, French attacked Shelton. According to Oklahoma County District Judge Charles Owens, who was an assistant attorney general during French's time on death row, French "determined the victim should have a last meal," so French treated Shelton to a steak sandwich from the prison canteen and "allowed" Shelton to go to breakfast. Upon Shelton's return from breakfast, "French wrapped a towel around [Shelton's] neck" as well as a pair of shoelaces and strangled Shelton to death.

French was fully aware of the consequences for his actions, making an immediate voluntary confession and explaining that he murdered Shelton because Shelton "was stupid [...] and refused to shape up." When he went on trial for Shelton's murder, French asked the judge to sentence him to death and deny all future appeals because he wished to die in the electric chair, and he explained that he committed the murder to compel the state of Oklahoma to execute him. The judge obliged his request, imposing a death sentence.

Trials and appeals

Third parties tried to save French's life during his time on death row. He won a total of three trials thanks to the efforts of attorneys working against his wishes. After the first trial, those attorneys won French a new trial based on the fact that jury members saw French in shackles while he was in court, which biased their view of him during the trial. After the second trial, attorneys argued that the judge who presided over the trial gave an improper response to an inquiry by the jury regarding the definition of "life imprisonment". French had his third trial in 1965. All three trials involved French making a full, voluntary, and eager confession to Shelton's murder and giving the exact same reason each time. Each trial ended with a death sentence. The third was the only one that was not successfully appealed, largely because French himself wrote to the Oklahoma Courts of Appeal asking them to reject all future legal efforts made on his behalf to save his life, and the Court of Appeals obliged him.

During his time on death row, psychiatric tests revealed that French was of above average intelligence. Unlike most death row inmates, French had completed high school and two years of post-secondary education at college. He was also the author of a book on crime compulsion called We. The tests also revealed that French had long been suicidal, with one psychiatrist writing that French had "seriously attempted suicide several times in the past but always 'chickened out' at the last minute. His basic (and obviously abnormal) motive in murdering his inoffensive cellmate was to force the state to deliver to him the electrocution to which he felt entitled and which he deeply desired."

Execution and last words

Shortly before his execution, French told prison employees, "I am not dying for murder; I am dying for my beliefs." He also requested that a psychiatrist "hypnotize [him] and find out what is wrong inside of [him]" before his death, a request which went unfulfilled. After French "resisted all efforts to spare his life", he walked calmly into the execution chamber at 10:00 p.m. on August 10, 1966. An Associated Press reporter at the scene wrote that "James Donald French got what he demanded: death in the electric chair", and commented that "he faced death with the same cockiness he faced life".

At the time of French's execution, the death penalty was at a near standstill nationwide as a result of changing sentiments towards the death penalty. Oklahoma's last execution before French's was that of Richard Dare, who died in the electric chair on June 1, 1963. Dare was executed for murdering his father-in-law and notably spent 717 days awaiting execution after his death sentence, which was unusually long for the time. Dare was executed only after a protracted legal struggle.

Charles Owens was quoted as saying, almost two decades later, that had French not aggressively pursued his own death, he likely never would have been executed. After the Furman v. Georgia ruling six years after French's execution, the U.S. Supreme Court placed a nationwide moratorium on the death penalty, causing every state to re-sentence all condemned inmates to life imprisonment. French's psychiatrist, upon reflecting on the crimes that sent him to the death chamber, wrote: "If Oklahoma had not had the death penalty, it is likely that both of the men murdered by James French would still be alive."

Disputed last words

It has been alleged that French's last words were: "How's this for your headline? 'French Fries'." The story appeared in 1977 in The Book of Lists. However, contemporaneous accounts of the execution confirm that when prison warden Ray Page asked if French had any last words, French actually replied: "Everything's already been said."

French himself did make a quip about French fries. However, the remark was not made at his execution, but in days prior, when French discussed his upcoming execution with reporter Bob Gregory. Gregory attended the execution and corroborated that French's real last words were, "Everything's already been said." Earlier, however, Gregory had met with French for an interview in the office of the warden of the Oklahoma State Penitentiary. During the interview, Gregory reported that the following exchange took place:

[S]haking hands as French prepared to return to death row, he leaned over to say: "If I were covering my execution, do you know what I'd say in the newspaper headline?"

"What?"

"'French Fries.' See ya."

— Bob Gregory, "They Died for Their Sins", Oklahoma Monthly Magazine (1976)

Aftermath

The execution of James French was the last execution by electric chair in the United States before Furman v. Georgia, and the only execution to occur in the United States in 1966. Overall, it was the third to last nationwide, only being succeeded by that of Aaron Mitchell in California's gas chamber on April 12, 1967, and Luis Monge in Colorado's gas chamber on June 2, 1967.

After the moratorium on capital punishment was lifted, Gary Gilmore became the first person to be executed nationwide when he volunteered for death by firing squad in Utah on January 17, 1977. Two years later, the first post-Furman electrocution occurred when John Spenkelink was executed in Florida on May 25, 1979. The first post-Furman execution in Oklahoma did not occur until September 10, 1990, when Charles Coleman was executed via lethal injection at the Oklahoma State Penitentiary. It was the first execution carried out in Oklahoma in over twenty-four years, since that of French's in 1966.

External links

• French v. State, 1966 OK CR 84 416 P.2d 171.