Elgar Symphony No. 2 discography
Edward Elgar's Symphony No 2 was first recorded complete in 1927 by His Master's Voice (later part of the EMI group) conducted by the composer. (Elgar had conducted a truncated version by the old acoustic process in 1924.)[1] This recording was reissued on LP record and later on compact disc. There was no further recording for seventeen years, until Sir Adrian Boult made the first of his five recordings of the symphony in 1944. Since then there have been many more new recordings, the majority played by British orchestras with seven of them recorded by the London Philharmonic.
Recordings by date
[edit]| Conductor | Orchestra | Record company | Date |
| The composer | Royal Albert Hall Orchestra | HMV | 1924 |
| The composer | London Symphony Orchestra | EMI | 1927 |
| Sir Adrian Boult | BBC Symphony Orchestra | EMI | 1944 |
| Sir John Barbirolli | Hallé Orchestra | EMI | 1954 |
| Sir Adrian Boult | London Philharmonic Orchestra | Nixa | 1956 |
| Sir Adrian Boult | Scottish National Orchestra | Waverley | 1963 |
| Sir Malcolm Sargent | BBC Symphony Orchestra | BBC | 1964 (live) |
| Sir John Barbirolli | Hallé Orchestra | EMI | 1964 |
| Sir John Barbirolli | Boston Symphony Orchestra | Music & Arts | 1964 (live) |
| Sir Adrian Boult | London Philharmonic Orchestra | Lyrita | 1968 |
| Sir Georg Solti | London Philharmonic Orchestra | Decca | 1972 |
| Daniel Barenboim | London Philharmonic Orchestra | CBS | 1973 |
| Sir Adrian Boult | London Philharmonic Orchestra | EMI | 1976 |
| Sir Alexander Gibson | Scottish National Orchestra | RCA | 1977 |
| James Loughran | Hallé Orchestra | Enigma | 1979 |
| Yevgeny Svetlanov | USSR Symphony Orchestra | EMI | 1979 (live) |
| Vernon Handley | London Philharmonic Orchestra | EMI (CFP label) | 1980 |
| Bernard Haitink | Philharmonia Orchestra | EMI | 1984 |
| Bryden Thomson | London Philharmonic Orchestra | Chandos | 1986 |
| Giuseppe Sinopoli | Philharmonia Orchestra | DG | 1989 |
| Leonard Slatkin | Philharmonia Orchestra | RCA | 1989 |
| Yehudi Menuhin | Royal Philharmonic Orchestra | Virgin | 1991 |
| Jeffrey Tate | London Symphony Orchestra | EMI | 1991 |
| Andrew Davis | BBC Symphony Orchestra | Teldec | 1992 |
| André Previn | London Symphony Orchestra | Philips | 1993 |
| Sir Edward Downes | BBC Philharmonic | Naxos | 1994 |
| Sir Charles Mackerras | Royal Philharmonic Orchestra | Decca | 1994 |
| Sir Colin Davis | London Symphony Orchestra | LSO Live | 2001 (live) |
| Sir Mark Elder | Hallé Orchestra | Hallé | July 2003 |
| Richard Hickox | BBC National Orchestra of Wales | Chandos | 2005 |
| Owain Arwel Hughes | National Youth Orchestra of Wales | Divine Art | 2006 |
| Sir Andrew Davis | Philharmonia Orchestra | Signum | 2007 (live) |
| Vladimir Ashkenazy | Sydney Symphony Orchestra | Exton | 2008 (live) |
| Kirill Petrenko | Berliner Philharmoniker | Berliner Philharmoniker Digital Concert Hall | 2009 (live: DVD via subscription) |
| Tadaaki Otaka | NHK Symphony Orchestra | King International | 2009 (live) |
| Sakari Oramo | Royal Stockholm Philharmonic Orchestra | BIS | 2013 |
| Daniel Barenboim | Staatskapelle Berlin | Decca | 2014 (live) |
| Vasily Petrenko | Royal Liverpool Philharmonic Orchestra | Onyx | 2017 |
| Edward Gardner | BBC Symphony Orchestra | Chandos | 2018 |
Critical opinion
[edit]BBC Radio 3's "Building a Library" feature has broadcast comparative reviews of all available recordings of the symphony on three occasions since the 1980s. The recommendations were as follows:[2]
- 18 May 1985, reviewer, Robert Philip:
- BBC Symphony Orchestra, Sir Adrian Boult
- London Philharmonic Orchestra, Vernon Handley
- 8 April 1995, reviewer, Jerrold Northrop Moore:
- London Symphony Orchestra, Sir Edward Elgar
- London Philharmonic Orchestra, Sir Georg Solti
- 15 October 2005, reviewer, David Nice:
- BBC Symphony Orchestra, Sir Adrian Boult
- London Symphony Orchestra, Sir Colin Davis
The Penguin Guide to Recorded Classical Music, 2008, gave its maximum four star rating to the Decca recording by Solti and the London Philharmonic, coupled with the First Symphony, and the EMI recording by Handley with the same orchestra.[3]
In September 2011, Gramophone in a comparative review of all recordings of the work recommended those by the composer, Thomson, Elder, and, as first choice, Boult (1968).[1]
Notes
[edit]- ^ a b Lewis, Geraint. "Symphony for a King", Gramophone, September 2011, pp. 46–50
- ^ Index to reviews BBC Radio 3, accessed 24 October 2010
- ^ March, pp. 431 and 433
References
[edit]- March, Ivan (ed). The Penguin Guide to Recorded Classical Music, Penguin Books, London, 2007. ISBN 978-0-14-103336-5
