Confessional subscription

In confessional churches, office-bearers (such as ministers and elders) are required to "subscribe" (or agree) to the church's confession of faith. In Presbyterian denominations, this is the Westminster Confession of Faith, while in Confessional Lutheranism it is the Book of Concord. The degree to which subscribers are required to agree with the confession varies from denomination to denomination.

History

The Presbyterian Church in Ireland wrestled with the issue of confessional subscription in the early 18th century. In 1726, the Synod of Ulster expelled ministers who refused to subscribe to the Westminster Confession of Faith – this group formed the Synod of Antrim, which eventually became the Non-subscribing Presbyterian Church of Ireland. In the American colonies, the Synod of Philadelphia originally did not have a confession of faith: while the Scots-Irish stressed precise theological formulation, professional ministry, and the orderly and authoritarian nature of church government, the New Englanders emphasized "spontaneity, vital impulse, adaptability."^[1] The Scots-Irish believed that confessional subscription would preserve Reformed orthodoxy from the threat of rationalistic ideas, while the New England party preferred declaring the Bible to be the common standard for faith and practice. The impasse was resolved with passage of the Adopting Act of 1729. This was a compromise that required subscription to the "essential and necessary" parts of the Westminster Standards – what was deemed to be essential and necessary was left to individual presbyteries to determine.^[2]

Levels of subscription

Strict subscription

Strict subscription, sometimes called "full subscription", means that subscribers must agree to everything in the confession, without exception. This was the original approach in the Church of Scotland: in 1693 it required all ministers to affirm, "I do sincerely own and declare the above Confession of Faith... to be a Confession of my faith, and that I own the doctrine contained therein to be the true doctrine". However, minor reservations regarding government and church/state relations were allowed.^[3] In 1711 this was changed to requiring that ministers believe "the whole doctrine of the Confession... to be the truths of God, contained in the Scriptures of the Old and New Testaments".^[4] In 1889 this was changed back to something very similar to the original wording: "I declare the Confession of Faith . . . to be the Confession of my faith."^[5]^[6]

Good faith subscription

Good faith subscription allows subscribers to take certain exceptions to things in the confessional standard. In presbyterian denominations, these exceptions are normally approved by a presbytery. This is the position of the Presbyterian Church in America, adopted in 2002.^[7] Its Book of Common Order says,^[8]

The court may grant an exception to any difference of doctrine only if in the court’s judgment the applicant’s declared difference is not out of accord with any fundamental of our system of doctrine because the difference is neither hostile to the system nor strikes at the vitals of religion.

System subscription

In system subscription (sometimes called "loose subscription") a subscriber is required to agree with the "system of doctrine" of the confessional standard. According to Morton H. Smith, "System subscription holds to the adoption of all the fundamental and essential doctrines of the system. Other expressions of the Confessions and Catechisms are not judged to be essential to the system of doctrine as a matter of indifference, whether the ordinand adopts them or not."^[9]

This was the approach adopted by the Presbyterian Church in the United States of America from its founding in 1789: ministers promised to "sincerely receive and adopt the confession of faith of this church, as containing the system of doctrine taught in the Holy Scriptures".^[10] This is still the form of vow used in the Orthodox Presbyterian Church.^[11]

Charles Hodge noted that the phrase "system of doctrine" was interpreted in three different ways: (1) "every proposition of the Confession" (equivalent to strict subscription described above); (2) the doctrines "peculiar to" the Reformed churches; (3) the "essential doctrines of Christianity". Of the first, Hodge argued that "Such a rule of interpretation can never be practically carried out, without dividing the Church into innumerable fragments. It is impossible that a body of several thousand ministers and elders should think alike on all the topics embraced in such an extended and minute formula of belief."^[12] The third, he said, "has been tried, and found to produce the greatest disorder and contention." Thus, Hodge concluded that the only viable view was the second one.^[13]

Declaratory statements

Some Presbyterian denominations have added a declaratory statement to the Westminster Confession of Faith in order to clarify, modify, or soften its teaching, and thus make it easier for office-bearers to subscribe without scruples. Many of these statements include a clause granting liberty of opinion on matters deemed non-essential.

"Quia" versus "Quatenus" subscription

In Confessional Lutheranism, a model of "quia" subscription is used. From the Latin for "because", the Book of Concord is adhered to because it is faithful to the Scriptures – the subscriber believes that there is no contradiction between the Book of Concord and the Scriptures. The alternative, "quatenus" (Latin for "insofar as") subscription means there might be a contradiction of the Scriptures in the Book of Concord, in which case the subscriber would hold to the Scriptures against the Book of Concord.^[14]

References

^ Loetscher, Lefferts A. (2016). The Broadening Church: A Study of Theological Issues in the Presbyterian Church Since 1869. University of Pennsylvania Press. p. 1. ISBN 9781512803747. Retrieved 31 October 2023.
^ Longfield, Bradley J. (2013). Presbyterians and American Culture: A History. Westminster John Knox Press. p. 6. ISBN 9780664231569. Retrieved 31 October 2023.
^ Fortson, S. Donald (2007). "The Adopting Act Compromise". Colonial Presbyterianism: Old Faith in a New Land. Wipf and Stock. p. 64. ISBN 9781597525312. Retrieved 31 October 2023.
^ Cooper, James (1906). Confessions of Faith and Formulas of Subscription in the Reformed Churches of Great Britain and Ireland, Especially in the Church of Scotland. James MacLehose. p. 64. Retrieved 31 October 2023.
^ James Cooper, Confessions of Faith and Formulas of Subscription, p. 75.
^ Macleod, John (1926). "The Reformed Faith in Modern Scotland". Free Church of Scotland (Continuing). Retrieved 1 November 2023.
^ Strain, David (29 June 2021). "Good Faith Subscription? (Part 2)". Gospel Reformation Network. Retrieved 31 October 2023.
^ Book of Common Order, 19-2. Presbyterian Church in America.
^ Smith, Morton H. (1993). "Subscription to the Westminster Standards in the Presbyterian Church in America" (PDF). Mid America Journal of Theology. 9 (1): 47. Retrieved 31 October 2023.
^ "The Historical Development of the Book of Church Order: Chapter 21: The Ordination and Installation of Ministers". PCA Historical Center. Presbyterian Church in America. Retrieved 1 November 2023.
^ "Confession and Catechisms". Orthodox Presbyterian Church.
^ Hodge, Charles. "What is the "System of Doctrine"?". PCA Historical Center. Presbyterian Church in America. Retrieved 4 November 2023.
^ Williamson, G. I. (2004). "What Does It Mean to Subscribe to the Westminster Standards?" (PDF). Ordained Servant. 13 (1): 8. Retrieved 4 November 2023.
^ Preus, Robert, Confession Subscription, archived from the original on 2006-06-29.