Battle of Scary Creek

Battle of Scary Creek
Part of the American Civil War
Plaque commemorating the Battle of Scary Creek
Date July 17, 1861 (1861-07-17) Location Mouth of Scary Creek, in Scary, Putnam County, West Virginia Result Confederate victory
Belligerents
United States of America (Union)	Confederate States of America
Commanders and leaders
Jacob Dolson Cox John W. Lowe Jesse Norton  (WIA)	Henry A. Wise George S. Patton, Sr (WIA) Albert G. Jenkins
Strength
1,000+ (est.)	800
Casualties and losses
14 killed, 30 wounded, 7 captured	4 killed, 6 wounded

The Battle of Scary Creek was a minor battle fought on July 17, 1861 during the American Civil War in Scary across the Kanawha River from present day Nitro in Putnam County, West Virginia. It was the first Confederate victory in Kanawha Valley.

Battle of Scary Creek, Putnam County, Virginia, 1861

Background

The battle occurred three months after the beginning of the war and days before the first major battle at Manassas (Bull Run).

Union forces under General Jacob Cox began a push up the Kanawha Valley from Ohio. In June and July, he had captured Ravenswood, Ripley, and Guyandotte, and he split his force into three columns to advance to Charleston. One column met Confederate resistance at Barboursville on July 13 and 14, while Cox’s main force established a camp near Poca.

Confederate General Henry A. Wise commanded a few thousand troops stationed near St. Albans, just south of Scary and Poca, and intended to halt the Union advance.

Skirmishes at Poca

On July 14, while fighting occurred at Barboursville, Cox sent a detachment of the 21st and 12th Ohio Infantries to scout towards Scary for Confederate detachments. They met confederate pickets and artillery at Scary Creek, and after a brief skirmish fell back to the main Union column. The following day, there was another small skirmish as Confederate pickets probed the Union camp at Poca, on the north side of the Kanawha River. Union reconnaissance discovered the Confederates fortifying a position at Scary Creek on the opposite side of the river, so Cox pushed elements of his force to occupy both sides of the river and wait for supply wagons to reinforce them.

On the morning of July 17, Cox sent Lt-Col. Carr B. White with a detachment of the 12th Ohio Infantry to probe the Confederate positions at Scary Creek. Around 9am, Carr and his men were ferried across the river from Camp Poco to the farm of John Morgan. Confederate sentries noticed the Union movements and fell back to their lines to warn George Patton.

White advanced to Scary and met resistance at the mouth of the creek when Confederate pickets fired on them. White, under orders not to bring on an engagement, retreated back to camp to inform Cox.

During the meeting, Colonel John Lowe of the 12th Ohio requested to conduct an advance on the Confederates and clear them from Scary Creek. Cox approved of the request, and Lowe assembled a force of the 12th Ohio Infantry, companies D and K from the 21st Ohio Infantry, George’s Ohio Cavalry, and Cotter’s and Barnett’s Ohio Light Artillery Batteries, consisting of approximately 1,500 men.

Order of battle

Union

• 12th Ohio Infantry Regiment - Colonel John Lowe (Union field commander)
• Co. D & K, 21st Ohio Infantry Regiment - Colonel Jesse S. Norton
• George's Independent Ohio Cavalry Company - Captain John S. George
• Cotter's Battery of Ohio Light Artillery - Captain Charles S. Cotter

Reinforcements:

• Co. A, B, C, E, F, G, H & I, 21st Ohio Infantry Regiment - Lt-Colonel James M. Neibling
• 11th Ohio Infantry Regiment - Colonel Charles A. De Villiers
• 2nd Kentucky Infantry Regiment (Union) - Colonel William E. Woodruff

Confederate

• Kanawha Riflemen - Colonel George S. Patton Sr. (Confederate field commander)
• Kanawha (Charleston) Sharpshooters - Capt. John S. Swann
• Buffalo Guards - Capt. William E. Fife
• Border Guards - Capt. Albert J. Beckett
• Elk River Tigers - Capt. Thomas B. Swann
• Fayetteville Rifles - Capt. Robert A. Bailey
• Mountain Cove Guard - Capt. William Tyree
• Kanawha Border Rangers - Captain Albert G. Jenkins
• Sandy Rangers - Capt. John M. Corn
• Hale's Battery, Kanawha Artillery - Capt. John P. Hale

Battle

The Federals under Lowe advanced along both the Bill’s Creek Road and the River Road towards Scary. At 1:30pm they reached and drove in Confederate pickets at Little Scary Creek and approached the main Confederate positions at Scary around 2pm. Lt-Col. George S. Patton, (grandfather of the famous George S. Patton of World War II), commanded the Confederate line behind Harlem Creek, 2 miles from the main Confederate camp. The Union forces quickly engaged the Confederates, launching artillery barrages and musket volleys for an hour.

Around 3pm, companies from the 21st Ohio Infantry under Col. Norton launched a bayonet charge towards the Confederate positions on the bridge, supported by a detachment of the 12th Ohio Infantry led by Colonel Lowe, which forded the creek and attacked the Confederate left flank. The left flank panicked and 3/4 of the Confederates fled. Captain Patton tried to rally his men but during the attack was wounded in the left shoulder and Albert Jenkins assumed command. During the charge, Col. Norton was severely wounded in the hip and captured by the confederates.

Fresh Confederate reinforcements arrived from Coal Knob and drove the Ohioans back from the bridge and the left flank by 5pm.

Sustaining casualties from the fierce bayonet charge and fighting around the bridge, the Federals pulled back, aiming to return to the main column at Camp Poca. Jenkins assumed they intended to regroup for another assault, and he ordered his forces to retreat, leaving the battlefield deserted by both armies. Once the Confederates realized the Federals were not reforming, they returned to burn buildings on the battlefield to prevent their use in another attack.

Throughout the afternoon, Lt-Col. James Neibling of the 21st Ohio Infantry had urged General Cox to send him and the rest of the 21st Ohio across the river to reinforce Lowe and Norton. Cox refused, and the men of the 21st were compelled to wait at the opposite side of the river, listening to the sounds of the nearby battle. When word reached Neibling of Norton’s wounding and capture, he immediately took his regiment across the river and marched to join the 12th Ohio and the two companies of the 21st Ohio. They neared the battlefield but were met by Lowe’s retreating forces, and taking up a rear guard to skirmish with advance Confederate pickets, returned to the main camp.

A group of Union officers at Poca saw the buildings in Scary burning and thought it a sign of a Union victory. They crossed the Kanawha with detachments from the 2nd Kentucky Infantry and 11th Ohio Infantry to meet with the 12th and 21st Ohio, but were surprised by the Confederates and retreated. Colonel Charles De Villiers of the 11th Ohio, and Colonel William Woodruff, Lieutenant Colonel George Neff, Captain George Austin and Captain John Hurd all of the 2nd Kentucky were captured by Jenkins men and sent to Libby Prison.

Aftermath

General Wise ordered a force of 800 men to attack the Union camp at Poca after the battle around 10PM but they were repulsed by elements of the Ohio infantry.

Despite the tactical victory, General Wise decided to withdraw back up the Kanawha Valley toward the Confederate supply bases in Fayette and Greenbrier Counties in a highly criticized move. Thus, the victory was hollow for the South. Wise's retreat resulted in most of the Kanawha Valley falling into Union hands.

Notable participants

Edward Settle Godfrey fought at Scary Creek as a Private in Company D, 21st Ohio Infantry.

Americus V. Rice was present at Scary Creek as Captain of Company E, 21st Ohio Infantry.

Harrison G. Otis fought at Scary Creek as a Sergeant in Company I, 12th Ohio Infantry.

James B. Bell was present at Scary Creek as a Corporal in Company H, 11th Ohio Infantry.

Elihu H. Mason was present at Scary Creek as a Corporal in Company I, 21st Ohio Infantry.

John Reed Porter was present at Scary Creek as a Private in Company A, 21st Ohio Infantry.

Casualties

Casualties were rather light considering the ferocity of the battle. The Union lost 14 killed, approximately 30 wounded, and several missing. The Confederates lost between 1-5 killed, and a half a dozen wounded, including Lieutenant Colonel Patton.

Known Union Casualties at Scary Creek

Name	Regiment	Casualty
Capt. Thomas G. Allen	Co. D, 21st Ohio Infantry	Killed
Pvt. George W.C. Blue	Co. K, 21st Ohio Infantry	Killed
Pvt. William P. Taylor	Co. D , 12th Ohio Infantry	Killed
Pvt. Jabez Turner	Co. F, 12th Ohio Infantry	Killed
Cpl. Frederick Hanford	Co. G, 12th Ohio Infantry	Killed
Pvt. Benjamin Hebbel	Co. G, 12th Ohio Infantry	Killed
Pvt. John McNeeley	Co. G, 12th Ohio Infantry	Killed
Pvt. William Jackson	Co. I, 12th Ohio Infantry	Killed
Pvt. Richard Lambert	George’s Independent Ohio Cavalry	Killed
2nd Lt. Guy Pomeroy	Co. D, 21st Ohio Infantry	Mortally Wounded
Pvt. Barton Smith	Co. K, 21st Ohio Infantry	Mortally Wounded
Pvt. Warren C. Timberlake	Co. D, 12th Ohio Infantry	Mortally Wounded
Cpl. Jacob Banker	Co. G, 12th Ohio Infantry	Mortally Wounded
Pvt. John R. Haven	Cotter’s Independent Ohio Battery	Mortally Wounded
Cpl. William Bishop	Co. K, 21st Ohio Infantry	Wounded
Pvt. James M. Miller	Co. K, 21st Ohio Infantry	Wounded
Capt. Joseph L. Hilt	Co. G, 12th Ohio Infantry	Wounded
Col. Jesse Norton	21st Ohio Infantry	Wounded & Captured
Lt. Brown	12th Ohio Infantry	Captured
Col. Charles De Villiers	11th Ohio Infantry	Captured
Col. William Woodruff	2nd Kentucky Infantry	Captured
Lt-Col. George Neff	2nd Kentucky Infantry	Captured
Capt. George Austin	2nd Kentucky Infantry	Captured
Capt. John Hurd	2nd Kentucky Infantry	Captured

Known Confederate Casualties at Scary Creek

Name	Regiment	Casualty
Col. George S. Patton	Kanawha Riflemen	Wounded
Lt. James Welch	Hale’s Kanawha Artillery	Killed

Sources

• Lowry, Terry. The Battle of Scary Creek: Military Operations in the Kanawha Valley, April–July 1861. Quarrier Press; 2 edition (April 1998).