Jump to content

Wikipedia:WikiProject Food and drink/Wines task force/Newsletter/02-21-2008

Add links
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
The Wine Project Newsletter!
Issue XI - February 21st, 2008

Welcome to this edition of the Wine Project Newsletter. The harvest season is in full swing for the wine regions of the southern hemisphere. For our wiki-winos in Australia, New Zealand, South Africa, Chile, Argentina and other southern hemisphere wine regions, now would be a great time to pack your camera for a beautiful vacation to wine country. You know you deserve it. ;) In addition to the wine & the sun there will be opportunities to snap a picture that could help some of Category:Wine articles needing photos. From grapes (Pinotage, Sémillon, Viognier, etc) to wine regions (Coonawarra, Heathcote, Western Cape, Catamarca, Casablanca, etc) to wineries (Klein Constantia, Vergelegen, Yalumba, Wynns, Brown Brothers Milawa Vineyard, etc) there is always a need for good quality wine photos.

On to the rundown.

News & Notes

[edit]
  • Boxes, they want Boxes! Infoboxes that is. Thanks to a nifty amount of bot work by User:FlagSteward we now have a a list of high or B level articles that are missing infoboxes. In addition to be a quick and easy source of information for our readers, infoboxes will also be important for articles that the Project will want to take up to WP:GA or WP:FA level. Below is a listing of available infoboxes.
  • All American Viticultural Areas now have articles! Thanks to the awesome work by User:Kharker, every American Viticultural area has at least a stub quality article. There is still room for improvement and Kharker has pinpointed the top 12 AVA articles most in need of some love and affection.
  • Speaking of some good old, fashion down home love and affection.... (Still legal in most countries, I believe :p) FlagSteward has compiled a list of some important start class & stub class articles that really could use some brushing up. Later on in the newsletter, I'll include some of these articles in our Traffic count section.
  • Speaking words of wisdom, let it beeeee a B-class wine article. What exactly is a B-class wine article and how much work needs to be down on some of our Top importance wine articles to get them up to B-standard. There is a discussion about this going on at the Project talk page, feel free to share your opinions here.
  • ONGOING housekeeping

Traffic Cop

[edit]
Sparkling wine is a subject that sparks the interest of many readers. What type of first impression do you think the article gives about Wikipedia's wine articles?
  • Traffic cop-A sampling of how often wine related article are being viewed. In this edition we are going to take a look at the 18 Top importance wine article, currently listed as being a start class. There is a strong likelihood that these are the articles that will first introduce people to the quality and depth of Wikipedia's wine coverage. The type of first impression that these articles give will have a large influence on how often they'll come back to use our articles.

Rankings based on page views in Dec 2007.--Top five entries also show January page views for added context.

  1. Cabernet Sauvignon - 19,321 views, in Jan 2008 23,588 views
  2. Merlot - 18,122 views, in Jan 2008 19,331 views
  3. Sparkling wine - 15,452 views, in Jan 2008 16,199 views
  4. Chianti - 13,095 views, in Jan 2008 17,111 views
  5. French wine - 11,061 views, in Jan 2008 15,599 views
  6. Italian wine - 8654 views
  7. Burgundy wine - 7803 views
  8. Winemaking - 7334 views
  9. Sangiovese - 4352 views
  10. Australian wine - 3929 views
  11. Grenache - 3815 views
  12. Vitis Vinifera - 3729 views
  13. Spanish wine - 3425 views
  14. Cabernet franc - 3151 views
  15. American wine - 2331 views
  16. Argentine wine - 1771 views
  17. Portuguese wine - 1437 views
  18. South African wine - 1261 views

Potential wine Good Articles & Features

[edit]

Wiki-Winos

[edit]

For this edition of Wiki-winos, we are stepping outside of the project to a fellow long time Wikipedian who is every bit a Wiki-Wino at heart. Meet User:EvanProdromou who, in addition to being a MediaWiki developer, is one of the founders of Vinismo, an online wine guide with a focus that compliments Wikipedia's Wine articles. While Wikipedia is not a wine guide, Vinismo certainly is. The Wine Project may want to open up some discussion on importing articles and content that might not be appropriate for Wikipedia (an non-notable winery or extensive discussion on a particular wine, etc) over to Vinismo where such content is desirable.

Evan Prodromou has been a Wikipedian since 2002; he's a MediaWiki developer and an admin on en:. He's the founder of Wikitravel, and in 2007 founded a new Open Content wine wiki, Vinismo.

What got you first interested in wine?
My Greek grandfather was a home winemaker, using grapes he'd grown in his own backyard. His wine was pretty awful, but as a kid I thought it was pretty impressive that he could take this fruit from the garden and make it into something to drink at the table.
Since then, I've had a casual interest in wines, but I'd never been much of a connoisseur and had mostly bought by price. I think like a lot of people I'd ceded knowledge of wines to a select priesthood. We don't want to know more about wines because we think you have to be a well-trained expert just to understand wines a little bit.
I think my real passion for wine started when I lived for a while in Geneva in 2002 and Lisbon in 2003. I was completely unaware of the domestic wines available in Switzerland and Portugal. I really loved picking up inexpensive vinho verdes at my local stores, and doing port tours in Porto. And you can get decent wine in the stores in Switzerland for just nothing. Finding out that drinkable, inexpensive table wines were a staple for Europeans was a real eye-opener; it made it seem like a big secret that I now knew about.
I think wine knowledge is something people can pick up iteratively. By which I mean, that you can take some time to study Sauvignon Blanc from New Zealand or Merlot from the Central Coast of California, without worrying about every other wine in the world. If you concentrate on some small wine subject, later it can be easier to learn about other wines and regions. You don't have to learn everything all at once in one big gulp -- going from wine bonehead to sommelier in one step.
I also think that when we learn about wines we "accidentally" learn about a lot of other things: geography, toponymy, geology, botany, languages, economies and governments. It's pretty valid to look at the world through a wine glass; there's a lot to see there.
So one of the main reasons I started Vinismo was to give myself a chance to learn more about wines from remote places, and to go into other regions that I thought I knew about already in more depth. I think that's one of the great things about wikis: it gives us a chance to teach each other. And I've learned a lot already in the time that Vinismo's been up and running.
What brought you to Wikipedia?
In the fall of 2002 I was writing a novel and I needed a good way to procrastinate. I'd remembered Everything2, which I'd edited back when it was just "Everything". So I went back and edited some more in 2002. I posted a few stubs on various subjects I was interested in at the time that didn't have articles on E2 -- I remember Paul Auster in particular. Just one- or two-paragraph glosses on each subject.
They were all deleted within 24 hours. On top of that, I got a mean message from an admin, saying something to the effect of, "You obviously underestimate the kind of work needed to write an E2 entry, and you should reconsider contributing here." I was pretty mad; I felt like the something I'd added was better than nothing.
So I started looking around at similar projects, and I found Wikipedia. The first article I started was distributive justice, but within a few months I was working on a lot of longer articles, like Palo Duro Canyon, Arkansas River, First Barbary War, Los Angeles Times, John Cassavetes and Lollapalooza. It was a pretty fun time to be working on Wikipedia; you could pick some pretty important topics and start them from scratch. I also started Wikipedia:Avoid weasel terms and Wikipedia:Avoid peacock terms, which have become important style guidelines.
In 2003 my wife Maj and I took a trip to Thailand and Viet Nam, and we were really frustrated with the accuracy and quality of the printed travel guides we had. Remembering my experience with Wikipedia, I thought that we could do something similar with travel guides: have people who were on the spot edit and update the information in the guides. We started Wikitravel that summer, and it really started taking up all my time.
I became a MediaWiki developer, and I also became a Wikipedia admin, so I guess I've stayed involved with this project, too. I guess at this point I'm pretty committed; I've been to Wikimania twice (in Cambridge, Massachusetts and Taipei) and I'll be in Alexandria this year, too.
What type of wine articles do you enjoy editing?
Well, most of the editing that I do is on Vinismo, not on Wikipedia. But the type of articles that I find most interesting are geographical ones -- articles for wines of a particular country or region. It might be an American's fascination with the mysterious foreign concept of terroir, but more likely it's a holdover from the immense amount of geographical work I did on Wikitravel.
I also try to add pages on wines and wineries on Vinismo whenever I drink a bottle of wine. Unlike Wikipedia, Vinismo has articles on each and every bottle of wine we can find -- each year of each wine by each winery in the world. So that means that every time I drink a bottle of wine, I've got something new to write. We estimate that there are probably >200K possible articles for Vinismo -- in each language -- and it's good to keep writing them.
What non-wine related activities do you also enjoy on Wikipedia?
I've always loved writing about 19th-century American history and American geography. It's probably been the work that I've enjoyed most out of the encyclopedia. But I think the greatest part of my work here is piecemeal -- I correct grammar, spelling, and clumsy constructions when I see them. A few times I've re-structured an entire messy article, but it's rare that I have the time or courage to do it.
I have spurts of doing admin work, and I continue to work on MediaWiki, although most of my contributions nowadays are as extensions.
What is your favorite wine? Least favorite wine?
Right now I'm trying to learn more about Burgundy, so I'm poking around at, for example, Mercurey. I'm also really into Greek wine, like Naoussa. I think there are a lot of bargains in Greek reds right now. I also am working on Rieslings from Germany and Alsace.
I'm not sure if I have a least-favourite wine. It's probably easy to be "ABC" and kick poor ol' Chardonnay, but I actually enjoy Chardonnay, even when it's really oaked up. I like "easy" wines, if only because they make people think a bit about what they're drinking. I think when people take that first step and say, "I like this wine," that's when they start trusting themselves to learn more about wines.
What is the most under-appreciated wine, in your opinion?
I can't say. I think there are really just giant swathes of land with longtime traditions of making good wines that North Americans and Europeans don't know about because they're made for domestic markets. We see it in places like Spain or even Eastern European countries like Bulgaria.
I'm going to Argentina this week, and I'm looking forward to digging into their domestically available wines. I think there's a whole lot there -- people like to turn up their noses at Argentinian wine, but I think there's lots to discover in that country.
What efforts on a wine related article are you the most proud of to-date?
Uh... Hmmm. Again, on Vinismo, I like our article on Yarra Valley, which is our appellation of the month. I also like the start I gave to Spain and Italy, as well as a few others.
Know any good wine jokes/quotes?
I know it's really déclassé, but I really like what the character Maya in the movie Sideways says about wine: I like to think about the life of wine. How it's a living thing. I like to think about what was going on the year the grapes were growing; how the sun was shining; if it rained. I like to think about all the people who tended and picked the grapes. And if it's an old wine, how many of them must be dead by now. I like how wine continues to evolve, like if I opened a bottle of wine today it would taste different than if I'd opened it on any other day, because a bottle of wine is actually alive. It's a nice sentiment.
Have you ever had a "Wine snobbish" moment? If so, tell us about it.
Here in Quebec, where I live, we have two kinds of wine. The official provincial store, the SAQ, is the exclusive seller of most wines. Except, that is, for wines bottled in Quebec itself, which can be sold in grocery stores and corner stores called dépanneurs. "Dep wine" is typically shipped in in bulk and repackaged here, and it's mediocre at best.
Anyways, my wife brought home a bottle of dep wine late at night when the SAQ was closed, and I got real angry. "We can't have dep wine in the house! C'mon! I'm a wine guy now!" My wife wisely pointed out that she was the only one who'd see the bottle, but I burst out, "What if the neighbours see it in our recycling bin?"
Yeah, it's pretty bad when you get to that point.
What area of the wine project would you like more editors to focus on?
I think probably the big thing for me would be to see more collaboration between Vinistos and Wiki Winos. I think that the two projects have a great complementary synergy: because WikiProject Wine is part of Wikipedia, it shares the authority of the project as a whole. But I think that because Vinismo is concentrated solely on wine and wines, we can be a little more focused. Our requirements for notability are nowhere near as high as Wikipedia's; I think that it'd be unlikely to have an article about a single wine in Wikipedia (I could be wrong, though...), but it's de rigeur on Vinismo. And we cover things from more of a wine-drinker's perspective: tasting notes, prices, that kind of thing are pretty important for us.
So, I guess what I'd like to see is more interactions between the two projects. Could we use dual-licensing to make transitioning text and images between the two projects easier? What about more inter-linking? Vinismo uses the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 2.5 license, which is very similar to the GFDL in spirit but technically incompatible. I think that as those two licenses become compatible, based on Wikimedia Foundation work on the matter, we can hope for easier portability of content between the two projects.
What are some wine related reliable sources (i.e. a wine book or web site) that you like using when editing wine articles?
Well, I know that there are about 4-5 right answers on this point in terms of wine books, but I'm going to go out of the way to sing the praises of national and regional wine board Web sites. Although the surface layers usually have empty, promotional language and meaningless Flash videos, I've found some amazingly deep, complex statistics about wine production in different countries on their sites. Once you start digging into the parts of the site that are only for statisticians and wine importers, you can get some real nuggets of data that are very useful.

Wine articles on the Web

[edit]

A sampling of how Wikipedia's wine articles are viewed and used across the Web

Till next time

[edit]

"And Noah he often said to his wife when he sat down to dine, I don't care where the water goes if it doesn't get into the wine." -G.K. Chesterton "Wine and Water"

Agne

This newsletter is sent to those listed under Participants on the Wine Project page. If you wish to no longer receive this newsletter please include Decline newsletter next to your name on the Participant list.
If you have any Wikipedia wine related news, announcements or suggestions drop a note in the Comments/Suggestion area of Wikipedia:WikiProject Wine/Newsletter.
Retrieved from "https://wiki.riteme.site/w/index.php?title=Wikipedia:WikiProject_Food_and_drink/Wines_task_force/Newsletter/02-21-2008&oldid=1255122646"