Jump to content

White savior

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
(Redirected from White savior narrative)

The term white savior is a critical description of a white person who is depicted as liberating, rescuing or uplifting non-white people; it is critical in the sense that it describes a pattern in which people of color in economically under-developed nations that are majority non-white are denied agency and are seen as passive recipients of white benevolence.[1][2] The role is considered a modern-day version of what is expressed in the poem The White Man's Burden (1899) by Rudyard Kipling. The term has been associated with Africa, and certain characters in film and television have been critiqued as white savior figures. Writer Teju Cole combined the term with "industrial complex" (derived from military–industrial complex and similarly applied elsewhere) to coin "White Savior Industrial Complex".[3]

Usage

[edit]

The concept of the white savior originates from the poem "The White Man's Burden" (1899) by Rudyard Kipling.[4] Its original usage was in the context of the Philippines, but the term has since become associated primarily with Africa, as well as with other regions of the world.[citation needed]

Association with Africa

[edit]

Africa has a history of slavery and of colonization. Damian Zane of BBC News said due to the history, Africans find the "white savior" attitude to help them "deeply patronising and offensive". Zane said, "Some argue that aid can be counter-productive, as it means African countries will continue to rely on outside help."[4] Bhakti Shringarpure, writing for The Guardian, said, "Westerners trying to help poor, suffering countries have often been accused of having a 'white saviour complex': a term tied up in colonial history where Europeans descended to 'civilise' the African continent."[5] The Washington Post's Karen Attiah said the white savior framework in Africa "follows the venerable tradition" of the novella Heart of Darkness (1899) by Joseph Conrad and that the tradition included the film Machine Gun Preacher (2011), the public relations campaign related to the documentary Kony 2012 (2012), and the writings of journalist Nicholas Kristof.[6]

For example, actor and producer Louise Linton wrote a memoir about her gap year in Zambia, In Congo's Shadow, and wrote an article for The Telegraph, "How my dream gap year in Africa turned into a nightmare", to promote the book.[7] Michael Schaub of Los Angeles Times said, "The reaction to Linton's article was swift and negative, accusing her of using clichés and misrepresentations... Several people have described Linton's memoir as a 'white savior' fantasy."[8] Zambians and other Africans negatively criticized the article on social media.[9] Attiah said the popular Instagram account "BarbieSavior" was inspired by the backlash to Linton's words.[6] Special Broadcasting Service's Amal Awad said the Instagram account parodied "a reckless trend" of voluntourism (volunteering and touring) in which "'white saviours' use the less fortunate like props in their social media profiles". Awad said the interest in volunteering encouraged a business model that leverages a country's existing social issues and charges tourists for volunteering to be a "saviour".[10]

Baaz, Gondola, Marijnen, and Verweijen, writing in Foreign Affairs, were critical of the "white savior complex" in the 2014 documentary Virunga, which features the Democratic Republic of the Congo's Virunga National Park and the conservation work of its park rangers. They said, "The movie features endless footage of a park guard hugging and playing with the gorillas, evoking the notion of the 'noble savage' who is close to nature, honest and naive, and dependent on the white man for his salvation. Rarely do we see the Congolese exercising political agency, even though there are numerous civil society activists in the region, often working at great personal risk."[11]

For decades, the British charity Comic Relief sent white celebrities to African countries in order to film their emotional reactions to impoverished conditions as part of asking the public for money. In 2020, they suspended the practice after criticism that it perpetuated white-savior stereotypes.[12] One of the key critics was British Labour Party politician David Lammy, who in 2019 criticized the charity for "white savior" media in its African campaign. Reuters reported, "Lammy, who is of Guyanese descent, said online photos... evoked negative stereotypes about Africa and its reliance on Western white people for help." The charity and its presenter Stacey Dooley initially argued against the criticism. The Uganda-based campaign group No White Saviors said of the controversy, "There are levels to the white savior complex. You can mean well, do some good along the way and actively be perpetuating the (white savior complex)."[13] NBC News said No White Saviors "tries to raise awareness about the negative impact many 'mainly white' aid workers have had on 'black and brown communities in the name of charity or mission work'".[14]

Musician and activist Bob Geldof has been called a white savior for organizing the 1985 Live Aid event to raise funds for Ethiopian famine relief. He called the accusation "the greatest load of bollocks ever".[15]

Association with the Middle East

[edit]

The term has been used to refer to white Americans and Europeans that independently partake or assist in Middle Eastern wars. T. E. Lawrence, "Lawrence of Arabia", can be seen as the prototypical white savior figure. Similar accusations have been made against white European men that traveled to fight alongside pro-democracy rebels in the Syrian civil war.[16]

Protection of Muslim women

[edit]

White feminists are sometimes categorized as white saviors when supporting causes relating to the protection of Muslim women, especially as the implication of Muslim men as oppressors is seen as Islamophobic.[17][18][19] The case of Malala Yousafzai has been criticized as advancing white saviorism in Pakistan, due to her high approval in the West and her life having been saved by white doctors.[20][21]

In media

[edit]

Appearance in film

[edit]
Main article: White savior narrative in film

In film, the white savior is a cinematic trope in which a white character rescues people of color from their plight. The white savior is portrayed as messianic and often learns something about themselves in the process of rescuing.[22] The trope reflects how media represents race relations by racializing concepts like morality as identifiable with white people over nonwhite people.[23] White saviors are often male and are sometimes out of place in their own society until they lead minorities or foreigners. Screen Saviors: Hollywood Fictions of Whiteness labels the stories as fantasies that "are essentially grandiose, exhibitionistic, and narcissistic". Types of stories include white travels to "exotic" Asian locations, white defense against racism in the American South, or white protagonists having "racially diverse" helpers.[24]

The white lead character is often delegated the role of racial leader in films, taking it upon themselves to save non-white minorities and immigrants from their struggles.[25] In the 2011 film The Help In 1963 in Jackson, Mississippi, a young white woman (played by Emma Stone) strives for a career in journalism and encourages black maids to share their personal experiences despite the racism prevalent at the time. This has been described as an example of a white main character exploiting the lives of underserved African American's to financially benefit herself without giving much relief to that community.[26][27]

Appearance in television

[edit]

Stephanie Greco Larson, writing in Media & Minorities: The Politics of Race in News and Entertainment, said Diff'rent Strokes (1978–1986) and Webster (1983–1987) were "shows in which white families adopt black children" and represented versions of "the white man's burden theme on television".[28] Robin R. Means Coleman said, "In these comedies, Black children are rescued from their dysfunctional families or communities by Whites."[29] In particular, Diff'rent Strokes featured the white millionaire character Philip Drummond. Film historian Donald Bogle said, "The millionaire Drummond becomes a great white father figure, able to provide the material comforts (as well as the subliminal emotional ones) and the cultural milieu that the Black community supposedly could never hope to match." Dustin Tahmahkera writes that Coleman labeled Drummond a "white savior" type who uses "his representational power to save the day by determining a conflict resolution that appeases all parties" including the indigenous representative Longwalker in the episode "Burial Ground". Tahmahkera also said a 1985 episode of Punky Brewster featured the girl protagonist telling a ghost story about her alter-ego Princess Moon helping "ancient Indians [who] suddenly appear... as cave dwellers who need a white savior... to defeat an evil spirit and help keep their Last of the Dogmen-like secret existence intact."[30]

Larson said, "Inner-city schools have been the site of white man's burden dramas on television for decades" with TV series featuring white savior teachers. Larson identified the following series with such teachers: Room 222 (1969–1974), Welcome Back, Kotter (1975–1979), The White Shadow (1978–1981), and Boston Public (2000–2004). Larson said while Room 222 and Boston Public also had black teachers that "challenge the assumption that blacks are inherently inferior... these shows continue to avoid laying blame on social institutions for the status of blacks by showing the success of the individual black teachers."[28]

Appearance in comic books

[edit]

The Marvel Comics character Iron Fist has been criticized as a white savior character.[31][32][33] When the character was adapted in the TV series Iron Fist (2017–2018), The New York Times reported before the show premiered that the casting had received criticism for not changing the character to be Asian-American. The newspaper quoted arguments put forward by Keith Chow, editor-in-chief of The Nerds of Color pop culture blog, "If you’re going to have all these trappings of Orientalism on top of a white savior trope, why not upend both of those things by casting an Asian-American to play the role?" Iron Fist actor Finn Jones denied that Danny Rand would be a white savior figure and said that the series would address critics' concerns.[34] In 2021, Marvel responded by having Rand retire the mantle and introducing a Chinese successor, Lin Lie.[35]

Celebrity humanitarianism and adoption

[edit]

High-profile Hollywood celebrities have taken on humanitarian roles, and also been criticized for embodying the white savior complex, particularly those who have adopted children from economically underdeveloped environment or countries, or have undertaken publicized trips to underdeveloped countries. Figures such as Bono, Bob Geldof, George Clooney, Madonna, Angelina Jolie, Charlize Theron, Bill Gates and Lady Gaga have become associated with initiatives to alleviate poverty, combat conflict, and support disaster-struck areas in Africa, South Sudan, Malawi, and Haiti respectively.[36][37][38][39][40][41]

"White Savior Industrial Complex"

[edit]
Writer Teju Cole, who coined the term "White Savior Industrial Complex"

Writer Teju Cole coined the term "White Savior Industrial Complex" following the release of the documentary Kony 2012 in March 2012, extrapolating the term in a seven-part response on Twitter. He later wrote an article for The Atlantic about the term.[42]

  1. From Sachs to Kristof to Invisible Children to TED, the fastest growth industry in the US is the White Savior Industrial Complex.
  2. The white savior supports brutal policies in the morning, founds charities in the afternoon, and receives awards in the evening.
  3. The banality of evil transmutes into the banality of sentimentality. The world is nothing but a problem to be solved by enthusiasm.
  4. This world exists simply to satisfy the needs--including, importantly, the sentimental needs--of white people and Oprah.
  5. The White Savior Industrial Complex is not about justice. It is about having a big emotional experience that validates privilege.
  6. Feverish worry over that awful African warlord. But close to 1.5 million Iraqis died from an American war of choice. Worry about that.
  7. I deeply respect American sentimentality, the way one respects a wounded hippo. You must keep an eye on it, for you know it is deadly.

Cole's response became a viral phenomenon, and The Guardian's Bhakti Shringarpure reflected on the supportive Internet response to the Kony 2012 political campaign, "With the prevalence of campaigns, apps and games calling on us to help without really putting ourselves out, it seems that the white saviour idea is still alive and well – but now, the mode is digital."[5] Heather Laine Talley, writing in Saving Face: Disfigurement and the Politics of Appearance, said of the response to Cole coining the term, "The very idea of the white savior industrial complex was met with both celebration and rage. Cole was alternately described as a truth teller and as a racist." Talley summarized Cole's response to his critics, "Ultimately, Cole implores Western (white) do-gooders to rethink doing good in two ways. First, own up to the motives that drive philanthropic interventions, so that personal catharsis does not subsume the real need of others. Second, consider the structural underpinnings and historical legacies that together sustain the very infrastructure of the problems that captivate our activist hearts."[43]

Tim Engles, writing in Rhetorics of Whiteness: Postracial Hauntings in Popular Culture, Social Media, and Education, concurred with Cole's assessment, "The lack of real-world efficacy of their efforts, and the apparent unwillingness of most to go any further than such limited and self-aggrandizing steps, suggests that mere validation of white racial privilege was indeed the most significant outcome."[44]

In essence, Cole's concept of the "White Savior Industrial Complex" refers explicitly to the damaging effects of white saviors who prioritize a "big emotional experience" achieved through minor acts of charity or activism over tackling larger issues like systematic oppression and corruption that plague many nations around the world – notably, issues that are often directly caused or perpetuated by the United States.[45]

See also

[edit]
  • Baizuo – Derogatory Chinese term: Western leftism
  • Christian mission – Organized effort to spread Christianity
  • Civilizing mission – Purported rationale or justification for colonialism
  • Development theory – Theories about how desirable change in society is best achieved
  • Economic growth – Measure of increase in market value of goods
  • Green imperialism – Political phenomenon
  • International volunteering – Paid travel which includes volunteering for a charitable cause
  • Manifest destiny – Cultural belief of 19th-century American expansionists
  • Progress – Movement towards a refined, improved, or otherwise desired state
  • Westsplaining – Political interpretation of Eastern European events by Westerners
  • White guilt – Guilt felt by some white people for harm resulting from racist treatment of ethnic minorities
  • White gods – Fringe theories about the origin of some Gods
  • Savior complex – Belief that one is responsible for assisting others

References

[edit]
  1. ^ Cammarota, Julio (2011-07-01). "Blindsided by the Avatar: White Saviors and Allies Out of Hollywood and in Education". Review of Education, Pedagogy, and Cultural Studies. 33 (3): 242–259. doi:10.1080/10714413.2011.585287. ISSN 1071-4413. S2CID 144651303.
  2. ^ Yu, Chunhua (August 2021). "An Examination of the Institutionally Oppressive White Savior Complex in Uganda Through Western Documentaries". International Social Science Review. 97 (2).
  3. ^ Aronson, Brittany A (2017). "The White Savior Industrial Complex: A Cultural Studies Analysis of a Teacher Educator, Savior Film, and Future Teachers". Journal of Critical Thought and Praxis. 6 (3). doi:10.31274/jctp-180810-83. ISSN 2325-1204.
  4. ^ a b Zane, Damian (May 1, 2016). "Barbie challenges the 'white saviour complex'". BBC News. Retrieved February 21, 2017.
  5. ^ a b Shringarpure, Bhakti (June 18, 2015). "The rise of the digital saviour: can Facebook likes change the world?". The Guardian. Retrieved February 21, 2017.
  6. ^ a b Attiah, Karen (July 6, 2016). "Louise Linton just wrote the perfect White-Savior-in-Africa story". The Washington Post. Retrieved February 21, 2017.
  7. ^ Linton, Louise (July 1, 2016). "How my dream gap year in Africa turned into a nightmare". The Telegraph. Archived from the original on July 1, 2016.
  8. ^ Schaub, Michael (July 6, 2016). "Controversial Africa memoir draws fire for Louise Linton, actress, self-published author and Trump dining companion". Los Angeles Times. Retrieved February 21, 2017.
  9. ^ Shearlaw, Maeve (July 5, 2016). "Briton's African gap year memoir sparks angry Twitter response". The Guardian. Retrieved February 21, 2017.
  10. ^ Awad, Amal (April 28, 2016). "When the saviour becomes the story". Special Broadcasting Service. Archived from the original on June 9, 2020. Retrieved February 21, 2017.
  11. ^ Baaz, Maria Eriksson; Gondola, Didier; Marijnen, Esther; Verweijen, Judith (March 5, 2015). "Virunga's White Savior Complex". Foreign Affairs. Retrieved February 21, 2017.
  12. ^ Waterson, Jim (October 27, 2020). "Comic Relief stops sending celebrities to African countries". The Guardian. Retrieved October 30, 2020.
  13. ^ Taylor, Lin (March 1, 2019). "Star humanitarian or white savior? Celebrities in Africa spark online furor". reuters.com. Reuters. Retrieved December 3, 2019.
  14. ^ Harman, Sarah (August 5, 2019). "U.S. citizen went to Uganda to help kids. Now her charity is accused of killing them". nbcnews.com. NBC News. Retrieved December 3, 2019.
  15. ^ Taggart, Emma (15 February 2024). "Bob Geldof: Organising Live Aid doesn't make me white saviour". The Times. Retrieved 9 March 2024.
  16. ^ Goudsouzian, Tanya. "Arabs' white 'saviours'". www.aljazeera.com. Retrieved 2021-12-02.
  17. ^ Briskman, Linda; Latham, Susie (2017). "Muslims at the Australian periphery". Coolabah. 21: 33–46.
  18. ^ Fluri, Jennifer L. (2009). "The beautiful 'other': a critical examination of 'western' representations of Afghan feminine corporeal modernity". Gender, Place & Culture. 16 (3): 241–257. doi:10.1080/09663690902836292. S2CID 143827345.
  19. ^ Lodi, Hafsa (2021-09-02). "How not to be a white savior when you talk about women in Afghanistan and Texas". The Independent. Retrieved 2022-02-27.
  20. ^ Baig, Assed (2013-07-15). "Malala Yousafzai and the White Saviour Complex". HuffPost UK. Retrieved 2022-02-27.
  21. ^ Aimen, Umema (2013). "In Pakistan, Malala is seen as an overexposed poster child of the West". The Washington Post.
  22. ^ "Matthew W. Hughey: The White Savior Film". temple.edu. Temple University. Retrieved October 1, 2014.
  23. ^ "Interview with Matthew W. Hughey". temple.edu. Temple University. Retrieved October 1, 2014.
  24. ^ Vera, Hernán; Gordon, Andrew M. (2003). "The Beautiful White American: Sincere Fictions of the Savior". Screen Saviors: Hollywood Fictions of Whiteness. Rowman & Littlefield Publishers. pp. 32–33. ISBN 978-1-4616-4286-2.
  25. ^ Latini Wolfe, Naomi (2022). Social Problems and Silver Linings (1st ed.). Toronto, Ontario: Tophatmonocle Corp.
  26. ^ Goff, Keli (May 4, 2014). "Can 'Belle' End Hollywood's Obsession with the White Savior?". The Daily Beast. Retrieved May 14, 2014.
  27. ^ "How 'white savior' films like 'The Help' and 'Green Book' hurt Hollywood". Business Insider. Retrieved March 25, 2021.
  28. ^ a b Larson, Stephanie Greco (2006). "African Americans in Film and Television Entertainment". Media & Minorities: The Politics of Race in News and Entertainment. Spectrum Series: Race and Ethnicity in National and Global Politics. Rowmn & Littlefield. pp. 32–33. ISBN 978-0-8476-9453-2.
  29. ^ Coleman, Robin R. Means (2003). "Black Sitcom Portrayals". In Dines, Gail; Humez, Jean M. (eds.). Gender, Race, and Class in Media: A Text-Reader (2nd ed.). SAGE. p. 83. ISBN 978-0-7619-2261-2.
  30. ^ Tahmahkera, Dustin (2014). "Settler Self-Determination". Tribal Television: Viewing Native People in Sitcoms. UNC Press Books. pp. 96–97. ISBN 978-1-4696-1869-2.
  31. ^ Bricken, Rob (March 7, 2016). "It Actually Really, Really Sucks That TV's Iron Fist Is White". io9. Archived from the original on July 2, 2018. Retrieved July 2, 2018.
  32. ^ Lee, Jonathan (July 25, 2018). "'Iron Fist' Was Always Racist — and the Netflix Show Isn't Helping". Inverse. Archived from the original on December 5, 2018. Retrieved December 5, 2018.
  33. ^ Leon, Melissa (March 15, 2017). "The 'Iron Fist' White Savior Controversy: Creator and Stars Discuss the Mounting Backlash". Daily Beast. Archived from the original on October 31, 2021.
  34. ^ Victor, Daniel (March 8, 2017). "'Iron Fist' Actor, at Center of Whitewashing Debate, Asks Fans to Wait and See". The New York Times. Retrieved March 15, 2017.
  35. ^ Schedeen, Jesse (2021-11-11). "Why Marvel Is Introducing an Asian Iron Fist After 50 Years". IGN. Retrieved 2022-02-27.
  36. ^ Mwenda, Andrew M. "Celebrities Should Not Victimize Africa". The New York Times. Retrieved 2023-06-29.
  37. ^ Mlanjira, Duncan (2023-01-04). "Africa: Ethiopian World Federation Asks President Chakwera to Institute Investigations On Integrity of Madonna's Malawi Charity, Raising Malawi". Nyasa Times. Retrieved 2023-06-29.
  38. ^ Kachipande, Sitinga (2015-07-27). "Madonna, Malawi and the problem with celebrity adoptions – Voices of Africa". Retrieved 2023-06-29.
  39. ^ "Malawi: Presidents, Pop Stars and the 'White Savior' Complex". Global Voices. 2013-04-23. Retrieved 2023-06-29.
  40. ^ Bell, Katherine. "Raising Africa?: Celebrity and the Rhetoric of the White Saviour". ResearchGate.
  41. ^ "Case study – Celebrity humanitarianism – The digital saviour". FutureLearn. Retrieved 2023-06-29.
  42. ^ Cole, Teju (March 21, 2012). "The White-Savior Industrial Complex". The Atlantic. Retrieved February 21, 2017.
  43. ^ Talley, Heather Laine (2014). Saving Face: Disfigurement and the Politics of Appearance. NYU Press. pp. 128–129. ISBN 978-0-8147-8411-2.
  44. ^ Engles, Tim (2016). "Racialized Slacktivism". In Kennedy, Tammie M.; Middleton, Irene Joyce; Ratcliffe, Krista (eds.). Rhetorics of Whiteness: Postracial Hauntings in Popular Culture, Social Media, and Education. SIU Press. p. 98. ISBN 978-0-8093-3546-6.
  45. ^ Aronson, Brittany A (2017). "The White Savior Industrial Complex: A Cultural Studies Analysis of a Teacher Educator, Savior Film, and Future Teachers". Journal of Critical Thought and Praxis. 6 (3): 9270485. doi:10.31274/jctp-180810-83. ISSN 2325-1204.

Further reading

[edit]
[edit]
Retrieved from "https://wiki.riteme.site/w/index.php?title=White_savior&oldid=1258154633#In_media"