User:DumbBOT/RfArSummary/Paranormal

Summary of Wikipedia:Requests_for_arbitration/Paranormal/Proposed_decision (experimental)

• Majority: 6
• Total: 10

Color legend

Passed

Rejected

Cannot pass with current votes

Number	Title	Support	Oppose	Abstain	Status
1	Neutral point of view	9	0	0	Passed
2	Advocacy	9	0	0	Passed
3	Basis for inclusion	9	0	0	Passed
4	Categorization	1	8	0	Rejected
4.1	Categorization, non-content	9	0	0	Passed
5	Pseudoscience	1	8	0	Rejected
6	Appropriate handling of epistemological status	4	5	0	Cannot pass with current votes
6.1	Appropriate handling of epistemological status, no content	8	1	0	Passed
6.2	Appropriate handling of epistemological status	5	2	0
6a	Adequate framing	9	0	0	Passed
7	Subjects which have not been investigated	1	6	2	Rejected
8	Conflation of parapsychology	1	7	0	Rejected
9	Editorial judgment regarding reliability	8	1	0	Passed
9.1	Editorial judgment regarding reliability	8	1	0	Passed
10	Conflict of interest	3	6	0	Rejected
10.1	Conflict of interest	9	0	0	Passed
11	Generally considered pseudoscience	8	1	0	Passed
11.1	Generally considered pseudoscience	6	0	0	Passed
1	Perfectblue97	1	5	1	Cannot pass with current votes
2	Loci of dispute	9	0	0	Passed
3	Status of parapsychology	7	1	0	Passed
4	Davkal	9	0	0	Passed
5	Cultural artifacts	8	0	0	Passed
6	Subjects without referents	9	0	0	Passed
7	External campaigning	9	0	0	Passed
8	Popular culture	8	0	0	Passed
9	Flat statements of fact	8	0	0	Passed
10	Conflation of parapsychology with unscientific concepts	3	0	0
10.1	Conflation of parapsychology with unscientific concepts, mk. II	9	0	0	Passed
11	Three layer cake with frosting	8	0	0	Passed
12	Paranormal as an effective tag	8	0	0	Passed
13	Template:Dubious	7	1	0	Passed
14	Category:Pseudoscience	7	0	0	Passed
15	Dradin	7	0	0	Passed
16	Kazuba	8	0	0	Passed
17	WikiProjects	8	0	0	Passed
18	Simoes	8	0	0	Passed
1	Davkal placed on especial civility parole	3	3	0
1.1	Davkal placed on standard civility parole	2	4	0
1.2	Davkal placed on standard civility parole, mk. II	4	3	0
2	Article probation	3	4	0
3	Revert limitation	1	6	0	Rejected
3.1	Revert limitation	5	3	0
4	Dradin	8	0	0	Passed
5	Kazuba	8	0	0	Passed
6	Perfectblue97	1	6	0	Rejected
1	Application of remedies	3	3	0
2	Enforcement by block	7	0	0	Passed